Rimsha’s plight

Politicians, police, courts need to treat false accusers of blasphemy with same toughness reserved for minorities.

Editorial September 24, 2012

As news stories about the violence sparked by the anti-Islam film abound, there is a danger that the plight of the young Christian girl Rimsha Masih will be relegated to the inside pages. Rimsha was accused of blasphemy and released on bail when it emerged that her accuser may have planted the evidence. Bail, however, is not the same as complete exoneration, which is exactly what Rimsha deserves. Now that the police have submitted a written statement to the court declaring that she is innocent and it was a set-up by cleric Khalid Jadoon Chishti, the judge needs to do the right thing and dismiss the case against Rimsha as being frivolous and unfounded. Then, Chishti needs to face trial for falsely accusing this helpless girl and probably putting her life in danger.

The idea of going on trial for Rimsha pales in comparison to the dangers she will likely face should she go back to her home. Those accused of blasphemy have often been targeted by enraged mobs and seldom found security thereafter. Rimsha’s best shot at a normal life lies in a foreign country. Pakistan is no place to live even for those who have merely been accused without any basis of offending religious sentiments. It is now the government’s job to provide her with foolproof security and arrange for her safe passage out of Pakistan. Meanwhile, the prosecution, which has already disgraced itself with its conduct, needs to let go of the case. The prosecutor is now claiming that Rimsha is 21 years old and not 12, as originally claimed. This is a mere smokescreen for bigotry as Rimsha’s age has absolutely no bearing on her innocence.

Ideally, the next step taken by the government would be to repeal the blasphemy laws but that is simply not possible in the current climate. Instead, the laws need to be balanced a bit by making the punishment for false accusations tougher. Politicians, the police and courts need to start treating those who make false accusations of blasphemy with the same toughness they currently reserve for child minorities.

Published in The Express Tribune, September 25th, 2012.

Our Publications


Cautious | 8 years ago | Reply

Great example of why the World should ban Blasphemy laws - even when a super slow investigation proves their is no evidence this poor girl still has to maintain an enormous bail bond and is likely to be murdered even if your court ever decides to drop the case. The prosecutor, judge and police personnel responsible for investigating this alleged crime should all be fired for incompetence. The imam and any accomplices who falsely accused this child should prosecuted and charged with attempted murder and conspiracy - this child barely escaped with her life.

Habib Hussain Khan | 8 years ago | Reply There should be a death penalty for the false accuser. People are using the blasphemy law for their advantage. But my friend if you really understand Islam, you would acknowledge that the blasphemer should be punished however, this is not the responsibility of people ... it should be left to the government.....
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ