Pope condemned Rimsha case but stayed mum on anti-Islam film: Khosa
Speaking to the media at Multan airport, Khosa said that when the Rimsha case surfaced, the entire world including the Pope “made a lot of noise” and questioned why they are tight-lipped over the anti-Islam film.
He said that Pakistanis living abroad should not only be used for strengthening their economy, but be given the rights of citizens.
The blasphemy charges leveled against the Christian girl Rimsha of allegedly burning Quranic pages in breach of Pakistan's blasphemy laws caused an uproar in the world, with humanitarian organisations demanding her release.
Rimsha was arrested in a poor suburb of Islamabad on August 16 after a neighbour accused her of burning papers containing verses from the Quran, in breach of Pakistan’s strict blasphemy laws.
On September 7, the court had granted bail to Rimsha against two surety bonds of Rs500,000 each. She was then transported by a helicopter to an undisclosed location after her release from jail.
COMMENTS (51)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
1732626034-0/BeFunky-collage-(92)1732626034-0-165x106.webp "article")
1732621030-0/Express-Tribune-(7)1732621030-0-270x192.webp "won t leave until imran khan orders us to k p cm gandapur")
Rimsha was arrested on August 16 for allegedly burning the pages of Holy Quran at Mehra Jaffar, a suburb of the federal capital. justice depend on the rule of law, and rule of law based on the unity of law where no respect of law, the rule of law can not fit perfectly among the society. In Pakistan all press media make a great news on the front page of every newspaper. This issue base on the "burning the pages of Holy Quran', Rimsha was arrested on this issue. All urdu newspapers published a Verse Of Holy Quran on the top of paper. Recently i went to a hotel for buying some food. This food packed in a newspaper..i m shocked "Rimsha was arrested on for allegedly burning the pages of Holy Quran at Mehra Jaffar" not on this news....the verse write on top of the page. I ask a question from Islamabad High Court before the judgement through a proper medium ....Who neglect the respect of Islam...Divine laws? We are not muslims if neglect the rule of law. Rule of law based on the Hadith Prophet(SAW)...A woman named Fatima arrested in case of theft during the period of Muhammad (SAW)..her Belong to A famous tribe"Makhzoom". Some people asking to bailing of her. This time Muhammad(SAW) Replied in Refusing and Say! O people previous nations destroy from the earth on this act when rich make a crime free with respect but poor arrested on little mistake and able to sanctions. I swear of Allah! If my daughter Fatima commits i must same punished her with to cutting the both hands. Question to Islambad High Court ..Remsha arrested in allegation of destroy the respect of Quran while who destroy the respect of Quran with using it for food packing....is in the eye of law both equally punishable?....Try to established rule of law not make the way for rule of bias..
Protest is a democratic right of every individual. However the state apparatus has to stand guard to any and every protest so that it does not destruct the life and liberty of other fellow beings and the state itself. The fact that every protest of this magnitude results in colossal loss of property and avoidable loss of precious lives speaks about the inability of the state institutions in maintaining law and order.
This is a core issue - forth coming elections, religious events such as Ashura and Eid-e-Milad un Nabi shall make tougher testing grounds for our relevant instituions - will our Interior Minister enlighten us about what remedials he has taken on this count ?
When innocent people have to pay for the excesses of deviant minds - it is reprehensible. But what our governor should understand is how much is he contributing in already fragile situation. Does his comment help in diffusing the tension or it further aggravates it. Should people feel themselves vindicated over burning a church in Mardan, now that we have a statement by the governor of the biggest province (population)? Incumbent of such office need to show more responsibility and discretion rather than swaying with popular emotions.
Gov got a point !!! If you have no answer, the best way is to insult the other's intelligence. My dear indians please stop flooding this place like fleas!
Unbelievable! guess Khosa was sitting on his brains when he made this comment. The Pope denounced religious fundamentalism, calling it “a falsification of religion" on his visit to Lebanon. The Pope also appealed for peace and reconciliation over the deadly protest around the world due to this due to this insane and ridiculous movie. Obviously, do you think anyone would want to listen or hear his message of peace and forgiveness at the moment? Therefore, in my opinion it's better he doesn't make any comments because under no circumstances the Pope is going to put a bounty on the heads of people associated with this movie, no matter how insane, stupid and totally wrong. Moreover, Christianity or the Pope has nothing to do with the movie and do not portray their views about the Prophet(PBUH). Please get it! It's doing of a handful of crazy/insane people with hate in their hearts. And of course a DEATH WISH!
Governor forgot that khadim haramain shareefain is also mum!!!
Governor Khosa has made a correct remark for the first time in his life.
Anyone would like to comment why no media outlet in Pakistan commented on a Church and School being burnt in Pakistan with Bibles being burnt also
Anyone who has even the intelligence of a person with mild retardation will not want to remind the world of Rimsha and how Pakistani treated a minor for alleged blasphemy that was later proven to be false and fabricated by a Muslim against a Christian child .
@antanu g: Responding to your post would be equivalent to banging my head against a wall , and I have no interest in that .
@FN: Te day Pakistani start boycotting Pakistani electronic media that will be the start of a better Pakistan .
Looks like everyone's trying to "one-up" each other proving how much they love the prophet. Governor's criticizing the pope and Railway Minister is announcing a bounty on the filmmaker. And this is from our so-called "left-wing" liberal politicians. I guess Salman Taseer's murder did have a strong impact. On the other hand, in Libya, thousands of people stormed the headquarters of the extremist militia responsible for violent attack on US embassy, forcing them to flee. I wish Pakistanis would one day rise up against extremists like the Libyans did.
"He said that Pakistanis living abroad should not only be used for strengthening their economy, but be given the rights of citizens."
Has any overseas Pakistani complained to him? Why then is he dragging Overseas Pakistanis in this issue?
@antanu g: What law did it violate to be a crime? That's usually the requirement for anything to be considered a crime. Don't give me any Pakistani law. The only laws relevant are the ones of the country they did it in. That's how companies can change locations to get out of certain taxes and restrictions. Unless you want to tell me that Hafiz Saeed is fair game for India or the US to stroll in and take without resistance.
Well,according to Pope and all Christians... Jesus Christ is a son of God,not a prophet as you claim and Abraham wanted to sacrifice Isaac not Ismail ...So technically,all muslims are commiting blasphemy by calling Jesus as a prophet....
Founders of Pakistan had said that if Pakistan is not created those "bad" Hindus will not let them grow and become better human beings , when I read about what is going on in Pakistan I wonder what they would have been like if even without the Hindu oppression this is where leaders were able to get them and their people to .
Mr. Khosa why are you inciting violence against the Christian community in Pakistan which is already living in fear. Rimsha was a child who had been unjustly accused, the other is a movie that no one would have known about if the extremists had not publicized it for their own ends. Why bring the Pope into this? PPP has lost my respect and my vote because of its cowardice and appeasement of the extremists and because of the poor calibre of its leaders and politicians.
He said that Pakistanis living abroad should not only be used for strengthening their economy, but be given the rights of citizens."
Overseas Pakistanis will face potential backlash in western societies from the events back home.
Does anyone know if Pakistan's best buddy China condemn the video ? did they try to block the video like India did?
Just as YOU Mr Khosa have stayed mum about the minority persecution and shia killings and the hundreds of poor labor men and women who burnt to death in your own country but have promptly spoken on a movie made by a no body across 7 oceans. Keeps the janta busy, eh?
What a wonderful change from that man Salman Taseer!
Rimsha is an actual human being. If the pope has not talked baout this movie, he has not talked about thousands of other yut ube that make fun of Christianity either. Please stop drwaring false equivalnce to generate more anger.
Your leaders seem to go out of there way to fuel the fires of discord --- why is that?
When the Governor of the most populous province in Pakistan is able to make such a comparison, then he confirms what we already know, not a poor state of mind, no mind at all.
The governor is ok, just lacks a little bit of common sense.
Mr Governer,
U have no right to give lectures to the Pope or the western world when you and your government is so mute on the cold blooded murder of your predecessor at the hands of the militant Islam and later the kidnapping of his son to be kept as insurance policy for you and your government to stay mum on the issue..........
Two very different cases - appealing to jahils
because Pope seems to be a christian himself.
Who said the Pope didn't condemn this nonsense. He categorically called for Christian Muslim understanding in the wake of this outrageous film.
Time is short. Elections are near. More and more votes are needed. Best method is to incite the religious feelings. Well done Khosa. Has Pope read your statement or taken notice of it? If you were a true Ashiq-e-Rasool (PBUH) you would have written to Pope about his alleged hypocrisy.
Gov Khosa very sensible of you, inciting more violence towards Christians. To be fair nobody in the world even knew about this video, except when Muslims made it famous. Does anybody remember Da Vinci Code??
Going, going, gone.
Is something mentally wrong with this guy Khosa? He should know the difference between condemning and scapegoating a 11 year old mentally-challenged Christian girl, who was framed by a dishonest and crooked mullah, and the controversial filmmaker. It would have been a greivous sin and totally inhuman if that poor child had been thrown to the pack of the wild blood-baying mob that was incited by the mullahs. Khosa is seeking cheap publicity at the expense of the religious minorities, most of whom would leave Pakistan anyday if any country in the neighbourhood would take them. We know that the religious minorities of Pakistan would love to migrate to India which for centuries has taken the world's persecuted religious minorities who suffered all kinds of harassment and even death. Pakistan is now a classical case where even Muslims don't feel safe and many of them want to migrate to India (where else can they get sanctuary?!!). Many Pakistani Muslims envy those Muslims who decided to stay back in India at the time of partition. That, in retrospective, was a wise decision.
good question to pope
Even Saudi Arabia stayed largely silent on the anti-Islam movie, Mr. Khosa! Where were the fiery protests and clerical denunciations from Riyadh, Jeddah, Mecca and Medina on Friday? Were they silent because they were close US allies?
The Pope is a CIA-RAW-MOSSAD puppet who conspires to defame Pakistan.
Sir, both Obama and Hillary Clinton strongly condemned the film and lets be honest for you politicians both of them are way more important than the Pope...........so stop stirring the pot.
The Governor has the right to Freedom of Speech as long as it does not 'incite lawless action'!
Oh yes, we forgot to blame the Pope! Nice of Gov Khosa to remember.