Power, misogyny and casteism

Published: August 10, 2012
Parading women naked to  ‘punish’ them is not just criminal but a misogynistic act.  PHOTO: FURSID/FILE

Parading women naked to ‘punish’ them is not just criminal but a misogynistic act. PHOTO: FURSID/FILE

On August 8, a shameful incident in the Khangarh sub-district of Muzaffargarh took place. A woman and her sister were stripped naked, tied to a motorcycle rickshaw and paraded around in public. The reason for this vile act of misogyny was that one of the women had asked for a girl’s hand in marriage for her son but the girl’s father felt insulted that she had dared to  ‘dishonour’ their biradari (clan/caste). However, the woman’s son and the man’s daughter wanted to marry each other. If the man did not agree with this, he could have said no to the proposal in a civilised manner. Instead, he chose to humiliate and punish the victim and her sister. Not only were the two women paraded naked but they were filmed by the man’s cohorts.

The men left them naked on the road when the residents of the area started to protest. The police were conspicuous by their absence while this was going on. Policemen arrived three hours after residents protested and blocked the National Highway. In the meantime, the man fled his house. Those men, who were arrested, denied any knowledge of the marriage proposal and instead accused the women of trying to rob the house. While all reports indicate otherwise, let us for a moment assume that the women were, indeed, robbers.

Why did the man call his friends instead of calling the police to take action against the so-called  ‘robbers’? Parading women naked to  ‘punish’ them is not just criminal but a misogynistic act. There are many more men in our society, who are high on patriarchy, feudalism and their powerful connections and caste(s). It is a shame that our law-enforcement agencies turn a blind eye to such criminal acts as they have been co-opted by these powerful elements. In most such cases, criminals go scot-free. This must not be allowed to continue. The man and his gang of thugs must be punished severely. Until such men are not punished for crimes committed, we cannot dream of becoming an egalitarian society.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 10th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (3)

  • stenson
    Aug 10, 2012 - 2:08AM

    I think you are mistaken to refer to this as castism – rather it is just a casteof upper class people looking down on poor people which more reflective of elitism. Yes some people may think their tribe or clan is better than another group but this is not really an issue of “caste” which is more of an Indian phenomenon. Clans and tribes all freely intermarry in Pakistan provided they are at the same socio economic level.


  • naeem khan Manhattan,Ks
    Aug 10, 2012 - 4:41AM

    It all boil down to this that when any government of any country disregard the laws of the land like they are doing it in Pakistan , this lawlessness seeps through to the rest of the society.Would the Federal or Punjab government suspend or fire the police officials who are so incompetent to reach the scene of the crime after 3 hours, I doubt it very much. If punishing the alleged criminals now is wanted by the government of the day because of the public outcry , it will happen again and again. It is the police which has failed the public and they are the ones should be punished along with the criminals and removed form their services regardless of their ranks. Perhaps they will think about their callous and incompetent behavior and losing a job and receiving some punishment may bring in some accountability to their behavior.


  • Ravi
    Aug 10, 2012 - 8:43AM

    It’s a crime that perpetrators must be punished for.


More in Editorial