Media reports suggest that the violence has not subsided despite a slew of ‘cosmetic measures’ by the quasi-democratic government of President Thein Sein. Alarmingly, state agencies — the border security force in particular — are colluding with marauding Arakanese mobs in what is now being dubbed as ‘ethnic cleansing’ of the Rohingyas.
Local media blames the Rohingyas for setting off the latest upsurge in violence. Given the pathetic conditions of the Rohingyas, who live in squalid towns as ‘lesser’ citizens of the Buddhist-majority land, and given a history of state discrimination against them, the Rohingyas are unlikely to have invited the wrath of their ‘superior’ fellow countrymen.
Independent observers suspect a bigger conspiracy at play. They believe that Myanmar’s powerful military has unscrupulously planned the violence to cash in on popular anti-Rohingya sentiment in an effort to reassert its importance and discredit the iconic pro-democracy leader, Aung San Suu Kyi. A statement in favour of the Rohingyas would definitely damage Suu Kyi’s popularity among the majority Arakanese community. Perhaps, Suu Kyi knows this and this is why she did not respond to calls, including one from the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, to use her clout to get the violence stopped.
Rakhine is facing a media blackout: foreign journalists are denied access to the strife-torn region, while local media persons are barred from reporting on the violence. President Sein has spurned calls from Amnesty International and the top US envoy for his country to hold an independent inquiry into the deadly rioting. Instead, he has set up an official inquiry commission. How can one expect an ‘impartial inquiry’ from President Sein, who believes that the expulsion of all 800,000 Rohingyas from Rakhine is the only solution to the communal discord in his country?
Aside from subdued condemnations from some Muslim states, no serious effort has been made to get the bloodletting stopped. Regrettably, Pakistan has not offered even the ceremonial lip-service. This pogrom against the Rohingyas also does not figure on the priority lists of our ratings-hungry media, squabbling politicians and spotlight-savvy rights crusaders.
The international community should pressure the Myanmar leaders to get the senseless violence stopped. Inaction would only help radicals and jihadists, who might use the ‘Muslim genocide’ in Myanmar as a rallying call. They are already flooding the social networking websites Facebook and Twitter with disturbing images and hearsay accounts of the violence to build their case.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 21st, 2012.
COMMENTS (69)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Ganesh
kaalchakra was a hindu who converted to Islam when Babri Masjid was vandalized.
@kaalchakra: Superb jokes!!I Cant stop laughing!!Should I call you Zaid Hamid Junior!!!!??Hahaha....
@kaalchakra: Why I get a feeling that you are a Hindu and deliberately typing msgs of pro-muslim,that too with a Indian name - kaalchakra.LOL.
@a hosain
Can you also ask illegal bangladeshi immigrants roaming around all over india to come back home? Every illegal immigrants, wherever (europe,asia,africa...) they are regardless of their country of origin should be send back to their respective country. Period.
@Mirza: please take urdu speaking pakistani from bangladeshi refugee camp
@Ali: "The sufferings of the Rohingyas in Myanmar are not that different from those of shia’s in Parachinar and Hazara in our country."
?Actually it is in a very important way. Shia's in PArachinar and Hazaras did not rape 10 Sunni women. That is what the ROhingyas did which precipitated the retributive violence. I do not support the violence against ROhingyas ut there was some provocation by them while Shias in Parachinar and Hazaras are being mowed down without any provocation whatsoever.
IMPORTANT ALERT!!
Brothers and sisters, as we organize this Jihad, please add the name of Bodos to the list! These tribals are massacring Muslims without any pity! We really can't stand back and watch this tragedy unfold. We need separate funds for Burma Jihad and Bodo Jihad.
I condemn the Rohingya voilence, And agree with the Author, if international community fails to solve this issue immediately,Jihadis may step in Myanmar.
instead of saber rattling, Muslim intellectuals should ponder over the trivia,why Muslims are always a part of problem?
@kaalchakra:
ET, Would you allow me quote Will Durant to shut Kaalchakra's falsehood? You are letting kaalchakra to get away with sheer lies while not publishing my posts with William Durant's comments on "Mohammadan's conquest" of India since 720ad which is considered the biggest genocide of Hindus and Buddhists from north India.
Muslims will continue to be victims until they unify their economic and foreign policies to deal peacefully within their own countries and with others.
@whatta whatta:
So what would be acceptable consequnces of unjust perseuction of just about everyone in Pakistan? What should Shias, Ahmadis, Christians, Hindus and Baluchis do in retaliation of their unjust persecution?
Mujahideen will intervene when states fail to support the helpless. If the Government Officials see no wrong in ethnic cleansing.
Thanks ET again,for making my comments disappear...
@kaalchakra, if how Pakistan treats her minorities is a benchmark according to the Islamic teachings vis -a -vis,ideal treatment of minorities ,i think Muslim minorities round the globe are handled with a kid glove.
Well, I credit the writer who mustered up courage and wrote the story about what so called independent international media and Pakistani media have been shut. We strongly condemn the on going genocide in Myanmar and urge Buddhists to intervene and stop it forth wit. **BE-WARE, Any further suppression and killings would lead you to a deadly consequences.
Those who are saying that it is "ethnic cleansing of Rohingyas" rather than "war on Islam" must realize that it doesn't matter what it is. Jihad is allowed, rather necessary in this situation.
Well, I credit the writer who mustered up courage and wrote the story about what so called independent international media and Pakistani media have been shut. We strongly condemn the on going genocide in Myanmar and urge Buddhists to intervene and stop it forth wit. BE- WARE, Any further suppression and killings would lead you to a deadly consequences.
@Kamran: what? assad not a muslim? so, there is a fatwa declaring alvis to be non-muslims? lage raho ulema, lage raho...
Stop Myanmar violence before jihadis step in
And, Do not step anti Ahmadi, anti Shia violence as the Jihadis have already stepped in ???
Funny Logic- This.
@farazits basically this, its basically that. Your mere words can't really make any difference though. U should already know the power of bullet than ballot. Long live mujahideen in every part of the world who inhale peace from the lives of stinking hypocrites ...
@3rdRockfromtheSun: it is only you who thinks 'Muslims killing Muslims in Syria' ... Muslims don't agree with this idea
whatta whatta
Absolutely. People call this a joke, or may dismiss it as sarcasm, but the objective, undeniable fact is that in all cases in which majority or majority leaders have been damned for injustice against a minority, the oppressor have ALWAYS been non-Muslim and victims have been Muslims. Minor disagreement apart - which family does not have them? - never has a Muslim majority carried out injustice against anyone else, so the talk of jihad is meaningless.
A clear warning to non-Muslims, because I am not afraid to tell the truth: If Muslims live among you and you are unjust to them, you will be subjected to jihad. If you are not sure what justice is or how to serve it to others, you are most welcome to study Islam. Allah sent His last message and system of justice for EVERYONE - Muslims and non-Muslims.
"Regrettably, Pakistan has not offered even the ceremonial lip-service. This pogrom against the Rohingyas also does not figure on the priority lists of our ratings-hungry media, squabbling politicians and spotlight-savvy right wing crusaders..."
What about 16000+ syrian muslims brothers butchred by despotic Asad & co. We decided to abstain from voting on UN resolution. Probably because our 'all weather' chinese friend and saudi masters told us to do so. That's hypocritical, no? Besides, why does pakistan has to be thekedar of muslims around the world? Are we the appointed leader of the entire ummah? Lets worry about our own muslims (shias, barelvis...etc) getting butchered every day by the agency's 'ass/ets'
The point that the author has made it is clear; if you unjustly persecute a community, you are responsible for the consequences. In the nineties, 8000-plus Muslim Bosnian Serbs were killed in by the likes of Ratko Maldic. That indi is facing a trial in the ICJ---however, one will see if he is brought to justice. The precedents are really damning. Thousands of Palestinians have died in their struggle for a homeland since the infitada broke out. These are real cases of oppression too. If the world shies away from these, it is its mistake. Jihadis will definitely step in then to secure whatever position is accorded to them. The perennial lesson: power was and is the only determinant of your stature in real politics.
Amirzada Afridi
May Allah give you sawab, brother, for your noble deeds. In the month of Ramadan kareem, the swab is doubled.
Khyber Agency :Dear Naveed Hussain sab, many Facebook User,s complained on pakistani media persons that not Reported Burma violence but You are write about Burma Muslim,s so I saluot you and i share it on Facebook page...
The persecution of the Rohingya is a gruesome fact that cannot be ignored, but when you use pictures of Buddhist monks helping earthquake victims in China, with the caption "Buddhist Terrorists Slaughter Muslims in Burma" it only hurts the cause's credibility.
Don't ask why non-Muslims have to be unjust, and say that if they were just there would be no Jihad. Human beings are unjust, and that's it. When Al Qaeda came into Iraq after the Americans invaded, under the banner of Jihad, they cut off heads everywhere they went, cut off people's fingers for smoking, shot them for shaving their beards, and killed the children of adults who questioned them. This is why the Iraqis of Al Anbar ended up turning against Al Qaeda and side with the US Marines to drive the "Jihadists" out of their cities in 2007.
@Naveed Hussain
Dear author,
As a senior jourmalist with a national editorship of a reputed newspaper like ET to boot, I expected a little more background check from you. This whole thing in Myanmar has started with 'rape and murder of 9 or 10 women from the majority community by some miscreants from the minority community. The point is that, 'when that happend you didn't come with an op-ed'. To clarify, I must say that I don't believe in or support retributive violence.I mentioned the unfortunate incident involving those women, hoping it will make people think twice before taking the high moral ground.
@kaalchakra: one enjoys your sarcasm! @Author: The international community should pressure the Myanmar leaders to get the senseless violence stopped. Inaction would only help radicals and jihadists, who might use the ‘Muslim genocide’ in Myanmar as a rallying call....
How can any paksitani even dream of justifying jihad after what it has done to isolate pakistan in commity of Nations?? Can author warn China too about jihadis taking on the plight of uigher muslims? there is no jihadi philosophy anywhere in Muslim world anymore, except in pakistan. Either society condemns it or it will face its own anhilation.pakistan is indeed treading newer and more dangerous grounds day by day.
@kaalchakra, " If anyone brings any case of injustice by Muslims anywhere, look closely. It is very very unlikely to be really unjustice" So innocent muslim punjabi coal workers killed by muslim baloch people are not injustice by your belief?
Protect the Christians & Hindus in Pakistan before you worry about Muslims in Burma!! Just in case there are any volient jihadi activities in those areas, the Burmese will be as brutal as your big brother China has been with its muslims in Kashi & the rest of its far west...
@Rakesh: pak is already knee-deep in trouble...do not ask them to further slip into it...by taking a posture against china...
kaalchakra : Your posts are the most humourous, satirical and out of the world.
"If you don’t want Jihad, simply be just. If Pakistan can do it, why not your countries?"
Pakistan being just. I havent stopped laughing yet. Anxiously awaiting the next post from u
Reddy Dear
Islam does not allow injustice. If anyone brings any case of injustice by Muslims anywhere, look closely. It is very very unlikely to be really unjustice. Almost certainly, it will be a necessary situation given the context Muslims find themselves in. Second, if in rare cases some instances of injustice are found, Muslims will have no problem fixing those rightaway it because Islam teaches all possible ways to be just. So please be fair, don't drag Muslims into all this injustice business. This is your problem and jihad has been made necessary for that.
If you don't want Jihad, simply be just. If Pakistan can do it, why not your countries?
Burma or Myanmar is supported by its best friend China. That also happens to be best friend of Islamic Republic of Pakistan. How do you explain this? Can Pakistan hold China responsible for massacres of innocent lives in Burma and even in Syria?
A sad day when muslims themselves demonize jihad. Learn the definition of jihad this is exactly whats needed
@kaalchakra, coming from an extremist himself( from your previous track record) bit of nauseating, what do you mean by this "non-Muslims must not give reason for Jihadis to start Jihad" is that mean we are supposed to put up with fallacious,erratic demands of sharia in UK, Denmark...what reason does jihadist have to target Olympics,moreover pakistan not in a position to speak on human rights especially minority rights.
@Truth bites: "f there will not be jihadis among you, you will suffer the way people in Burma are suffering."
So, if there are jihadis among you, you will not suffer...right!
Clash of religions ? Islam vs the rest ?
@Author Bringing religion into the sectarian violence and signaling Jihadi interference is totally uncalled for... Time has come to protect Islam from so called self-proclaimed protectors, the Jihadis (who are biased towards other Islam sects)... Everybody should work towards that and fight democratically against such inhuman acts whoever the victims..
@kaalchakra, coming from an extremist himself( from your previous track record) bit of nauseating, what do mean by this "non-Muslims must not give reason for Jihadis to start Jihad" is that mean we are supposed to put up with fallacious,erratic demands of sharia in UK, Denmark...what reason does jihadist have to target Olympics,moreover pakistan not in a position to speak on human rights especially minority rights.
Bring them on, drones await them.
@kaalchakra:
You justify blasphemy law and attack on Ahmadi mosque, what right do you have to ask others? Let me ask you, why are Muslims unjust so as to earn the detest of the rest of the man kind?
This guys is not making any sense. If there are ethnic problems those should be resolved by the people in charge of making it right. Threatening with Jehadis is perhaps the most ludicrous solution I have heard to resolve such issues. And Jehadis themselves are killing other Muslims just look around what is happening in Pakistan. Instead of discouraging those goons, let us not use them as a cure of any problems. This will only make then more ruthless.
No one has to worry, Burmese military will anihilate the jihadi muslims. They are not India or U.S. Their military will anihilate who want jihad agnist Burma, they really don't have democracy. So far they haven't cared about the amensty int'l. So good luck with the jihadi muslims and paki ISI.
why suddenly ET has started spreading Jihadi propaganda against poor people of Myanmar ?
why don;t jihadis the so called gods workers take action against persecution of non muslims everywhere there is a muslim majority ?
why to cry for crimes outside when your own home is a crime zone?
muslims need introspection .
now comes the jihad problem which is not accepted as a problem as people consider it holy work .every religion has problem , no one is perfect . hindus have caste and women discrimination, muslims have hate,jihad and women discrimination cristians have other problems.
the point is to accept your problem and sooner or later all will be solved .
How does it become a Pakistan's problem? Does Pakistan need to look for more problems because it does not have any of its own? Is Pakistan the super power of the region who wants to see desired govts in other countries? Is Bengal not close enough to look at this next door problem? As far Jihadist going there, great they would move away from Pakistan but it is not going to happen. This is an empty threat and these Jihadists are too busy in killing Muslims in Pakistan, they have no time to go and fight the armed opposition in any other country including Israel or Myanmar.
Dear ET,
aik taraf tu u publish Social media is lying to you about Burma’s Muslim ‘cleansing’ (http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/12867/social-media-is-lying-to-you-about-burmas-muslim-cleansing/) and convince us tht all tht is going on is not true and then u come up with this atricle. Bechari awam politicians ki tarha aap pr bhi yaqeen na karay?
who will give dollars to jihadis in Burma?? they will never go there.
The international community should pressure the Myanmar leaders to get the senseless violence stopped. Inaction would only help radicals and jihadists, who might use the ‘Muslim genocide’ in Myanmar as a rallying call. They are already flooding the social networking websites Facebook and Twitter with disturbing images and hearsay accounts of the violence to build their case.
'The international community should pressurize the leaders of Myanmar' bit sounds fair enough, but is there anybody who will pressurize the jihadis? Why does the title of this piece sound like a veiled threat? Should one expect a proportionate response from nationalistic Chinese, Japanese, Sri Lankan, Thai and people from other Buddhist countries in favor of their fellow Buddhists? If a nation or a people are not wanting or willing to stop the radicals from among them, and see them as an legitimate extension of their geo-political goals, should they then have the right to demand action against their genuine victimization at the hands of radicals from other faiths?
If there will not be jihadis among you, you will suffer the way people in Burma are suffering.
Though I deeply condemn the Rohingya violence. I think we should try to solve this without making this into a Muslim-Buddhist agenda.If Bangladeshis couldnt accept fellow muslims.It means that it is not of regional not religious
For the Jihadis,I've a question...How come none of you have stepped in the Xingjang province to support the Uiyghur Muslims where the govt sponsored slaughtering is anywhere between 1,000 to 30,000???
Stop Myanmar violence before jihadis step in
Pity that you are calling for action viz-a-viz the situation in Myanmar not because of the humanitarian crisis which it is but because of your perceived hatred for Jihad etc.
There are more muslims being killed by their countrymen in Pakistan than in Myanmar. The situation with the Rohingya is unfortunate, but trust people like the writer to portray it as an ethnic cleansing of muslims - part of the relentless search for opportunities to classify muslims as victims to justify the existence and motivation of your jihadis and extremists; unnecessary since they don't need real cases of genocide as the system is perfectly capable of cooking up stuff at a moment's notice (there is currently a blog on this subject with illustrative content - pls do take a look). Also, the argument that this is being done to discredit Aung San Suu Kyi is fatuous as the entire world knows that she is just a minority party leader and member of parliament with no decision making powers.
Imran Con
Let me ask you since you spoke of the 'cause for most dislike for Muslims'.
Why do non-Muslims have to be unjust? If they were just, there would be no Jihad.
This is what I have always said - non-Muslims must not give reason for Jihadis to start Jihad. If they do, they can't blame Muslims or Islam. Simple logic, somehow people will do anything to avoid facing it.
Saying for it to stop before so called "jihadis" step in is not helpful in the slightest. You do realize those "jihadis" are the main cause of most dislike for Muslims, right? The first sight of them is likely going to make it even worse. Not only make it worse. Also give them a type of justification to raise the level of violence against them. You'll be able to make them look like good guys right up until the time they start their own brand of depraved violence, then most sympathies will end up being lost in the cross fire.
Naveed - Understandable. But let me ask you this. Other than reading news of this unfortunate event and sympathizing with the victims, what can common people or even politicians in Pakistan do? Does Pakistan even have the political clout to take on other country when it is itself mired in so many internal problems of discrimination against minorities?
A little rich this protest coming from Pakistan, don't you think? Seen the treatment of minorities in your country lately - I don't see hordes of Hindus / Christians calling for a 'religious war' against Pakistan - or Sudan, Indonesia etc where the majority treatment of the minority is less than stellar. And as you indicated, this was triggered by an act of the members of the Muslim community - similar to an instance in your eastern neighbour, where the subsequent rioting led to the deaths of many from both communities. Without condoning the violence from either side - why is it only the Muslim community that goes up in arms at the slightest of provocations? Muslims are killing Muslims in Syria - where are the calls to march to Damascus?
It’s basically ethnic violence but people here portray it as Islam vs. Buddhism; but ideological battle against Buddhism makes little sense, so they have brought in the ‘Zionists media’ and ‘Christian West’ which is deliberately silent because of ideological reasons!