Punjab Assembly committee to take up complaint against Chinoy

Standing committee to take up matter as first case.

Abdul Manan July 19, 2012


The provincial assembly decided on Thursday to refer to its Standing Committee on Women’s Development to probe the allegations that Sharmeen Obaid Chinoy did not fulfill her commitments to an acid attack survivor.

The house decided to summon all stakeholders in the matter to the committee’s next meeting.

The PA session resumed on Thursday at 12:08pm instead of the scheduled time of 10am and was chaired by Speaker Rana Muhammad Iqbal Khan.

Sajida Mir, a Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) member rose a point of order and asked the speaker to form a committee to probe the allegations against Chinoy.

She said Rukhsana Bibi had reconciled with her husband and they were black mailing Chinoy.

Sheikh Alauddin, a Unification Bloc member, on Wednesday had moved an adjournment motion claiming Chinoy had promised Rukhsana Bibi Rs3 million, a home in Multan and free plastic surgery for her face to work in the Oscar winning documentary, Saving Face. The house had expressed sympathy with Rukhsana Bibi and suggested that she move a court.

Mir said, “I appreciate the house’s position but I want to ask: who will punish Rukhsana Bibi’s husband for throwing acid in the first place?”

She then suggested the house form a committee to probe the matter. She said she supported Chinoy’s decision not to provide cash to the woman since it would be used by her husband.

Law Minister Rana Sanaullah agreed that the matter should be referred to the standing committee.

Speaker Rana Mohammad Iqbal Khan forwarded the matter to the committee. When some opposition members said the committee had yet to meet, Sanaullah said a notification would be issued soon and this would be the first matter it takes up.


Three bills, including The Punjab Motion Pictures (Amendment) Bill 2012, Punjab Metro Bus Authority Bill and Punjab Zakat and Usher Bill were introduced in the house.

They had been referred to standing committees concerned a month ago and had been cleared.

Mujtaba Shujaur Rehman, the minister for education, answered questions regarding the department.

The Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability (Amendment) Bill 2011 was passed. The ammendment exempts police officials from proceedings under the law.

Rai Shahjahan, a PPP legislator, said police should not be spared from investigation under the PEEDA act. Rana Sanaullah responded that police officials had complained that the PEEDA had a lengthy process while police had its own disciplinary laws in the Police Order 2002.

The speaker then prorogued the 39th session for an indefinite time period at the opposition’s request.

Published in The Express Tribune, July 20th, 2012.

Correction: In an earlier version of the story, the first paragraph was running a grammatical error. The error has been rectified.


Sa | 11 years ago | Reply

She is so insensitive that she used a sick person for her advantage and did not share the gains with her.

Kamran Ali | 11 years ago | Reply

People here call her american agent or the person from western world etc. They do so, because they are driven by such assemblies, and they should better research it by themselves as what the truth is all about. We should see the cause for which she made a documentary and that cause is rampant in Pakistan. People sitting in the assemblies maybe are the main perpetrators of such crime and because they are afraid of conviction, they are trying to attack the maker of documentary.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ