The latest sad news is that in Mali’s ancient Unesco-protected city of Timbuktu, salafist followers of al Qaeda have attacked mausoleums of mystic saints, the same way the Taliban have attacked the tombs of Sufi saints in Pakistan. This has happened in the wake of similar attacks in Egypt and Libya last year, both having gone through the ‘pro-democracy’ Arab Spring in recent times. Replying to the Unesco’s appeal to stop destroying the tombs, the extremist vandals have said: “We are subject to religion and not to international opinion. Building on graves is contrary to Islam. We are destroying the mausoleums because it is ordained by our religion”. Their organisation, Ansar Dine, is made up of militants of various nationalities, including Malians, Algerians and Nigerians.
Another extremely violent offshoot of al Qaeda, called Boko Haram, has wreaked havoc on Nigerian Christians. Last week, too, a Somalia affiliate, al Shabaab, launched coordinated attacks on churches in northern Kenya. Gunmen killed 15 Christians and wounded over 40 in separate attacks on two churches in a town bordering Somalia. In February this year, al Shabaab announced its merger with al Qaeda, which was followed by a statement by the Muslim Youth Centre that it had now become part of al Qaeda, in East Africa.
Indonesia, once known to be moderate in its thinking, also seems to have become prone to violence and intolerance. In May this year, a church was attacked by a mob in Jakarta, which hurled stones, bags of urine and death threats at the congregation. Since then, local government officials in the province of Aceh, in Sumatra, have closed at least 16 churches, citing lack of permits. In 2007, it was noted that in the previous three years, there were 108 cases in which churches and other places of worship were damaged, forcibly shut down and, in some cases, even demolished by extremist groups in violent and indiscriminate attacks.
The delicate political balance between Malaysia’s ethnic and religious groups was rocked by a series of attacks on churches last year, after a high court ruling stated that a Catholic weekly, The Herald, could use the word ‘Allah’ in its Malay-language edition, overturning an existing ban. The supposed fear in Malaysia is that Christians are plotting to convert Malays, who make up some 60 per cent of the population and, under the constitution, must also be Muslims. So sensitive is the issue that the high court was forced to suspend this ruling.
In Pakistan, too, al Qaeda’s partners seem to be growing. The ‘announced’ followers of al Qaeda are the Tehreek-i-Taliban (TTP), the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi (LeJ) and the Jundullah. The TTP, now spread around the country and concentrated in Karachi, targets Sufi tombs; the Jandullah attacks Shias in Iran; and the LeJ kills Shia Hazaras in Quetta. Everywhere, from Africa to the Far East, nations with Muslim majorities seem to be veering towards intolerance and fanaticism. Pakistan is in some ways a good example of this because of the location of al Qaeda’s leadership in the region. It is also present, in force, in Yemen and is inspiring killings in Iraq.
Al Qaeda is looking for a state that it could run with enough internal revenue to launch its global jihad through terrorism. Only Pakistan qualifies because it is internally weak, externally isolated and politically fragmented. The political parties are back to their old tricks of toppling each other’s governments and most Pakistanis seem to be unmindful of the fast-shrinking writ of the state.
Published in The Express Tribune, July 3rd, 2012.
COMMENTS (32)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
it has always this way for the last 1400 years. sorry.
What is the opposite of 'extremism'?
Is it Liberalism? Isn't that equal to Modernism? And isn't secularism also modernism?
So, how can folks, who oppose any modern interpretation of a religion ever be secular or non-extreme? How can a religion defined in 7th century, be relevant in 21st?
If folks don't have the guts to say core of religion isn't the same as practice of religion, then how can they ever become modern?
Islam will remain 'extreme' as long as it won't permit new interpretations and amendments as time passes.
'Extremism grips the Muslim mind' is not a surprise. They are known to have a short fuse.
Question: How to make these extremists secular????
Answer: Give them work permit visa to US,EU or Canada and hear them sing praises about secularism,right to religious freedom and human rights...
While the rest of the world, particularly non-Muslim nations, are excelling in fields of science and arts,thereby contributing to the common cause of humanity, the Islamists terrorists are in parallel honing their intellectual prowess to evolve scientific methods of butchering vulnerable communities in as efficacious a manner as possible.
Scary, really scary. Wake up folks.
Nothing new. Just try living in any country with a Muslim majority.
The religion of peace did you say? Hurts doesn't it, but I do not mean to insult, However when the moderate majority does not speak up against the extremist fringe, it is seen as a tacit acknowledgement and acceptance of the extremist point of view by the rest of the world - and then it is termed as Islamophobia. It is high time to realize the world is not out to "get you", and that other faiths have an equal right to exist and prosper.
There are extremists among other faiths too, but they are largely marginalized and ignored by the mainstream majority.
Very well written ! It is time to look into yourself before it become Islam vs others
The next logical question is why are a followers of a certain Religion alone than others with greater or equal number of followers?
What do you expect, when Pakistan has an established MO (modus operandi) of issuing passports to known terrorists, letting them travel across asia, then subsequently claim it to be 'fake passport' if they get caught in other countries??
What do you expect, if no serious player of terror ever gets punished in Pakistan?
Why would world respect anyone travelling on Pakistani passport? Most countries will assume it to be a stamp that you are a terrorist unless proven otherwise!
Only problem? propose any-solution or be part of it
All true. Unless a movement of reformation is launched; I see worse to come. Martin Luther reformed the Christian faith in Germany and now Christians have learned to live peacefully with other faiths. WE have to interpret Koran in more liberal ways. You cannot expect ordinary person to hear extremist views in mosque and behave differently in real life.
I would like to thank all those Pakistani readers who thanked this editorial. If there is such thing called "hope" from this madness, it rest on sensible people like you. It is not sufficient if you just denounce the extremism, you should denounce it in the name of Islam, because perpetrators do this in the name of "pure Islam". Now, kaalchakra will come and poison the lively debate by calling for an Islamic "rule" as a solution. So, an "Islamic rebuttal" will preempt such "non Islamic" claims.
I think the author protrays the problem well but does not attempt to find the root cause .I think there is a global wave of violence like diseases coming in body at times .World war 1 and 2 happened over superiority of race and nation states attempting to dominate the other and finally settled in a global order after much blood shed. Now its religious wave of violence starting in muslim religion and attempting to dominate the other sects of same religion or different religion. I hope this will subside in a decade or two .When some western nation start provocating Hindu gods or goddess or their rituals may be some RSS wing might start the next wave ? .Who knows ?.Hope it does not happen!.
The latest sad news is that in Mali’s ancient Unesco-protected city of Timbuktu, salafist followers of al Qaeda have attacked mausoleums of mystic saints When you set fire to some thing else, you are also burning yourself to the ash.....
I agree with the author 100%. The whole idea of AQ, which follows the most violent strain of any religion known to mankind, moving into Pakistan itself to take over the state to spread its idealogy. The AQ mob has studied Pakistan very well, its religious inclination and bigotry, (started as NonHindu and fuelled by Pak army and establishment) and decided to move in from the AFpak border. The whole idea of camping and inciting US into this mess itself is for AQ to move into the badlands with Pak support. Unless pakistanis read the whole scenario well and take corrective action, violence will spread far and wide with its epicentre in Pakistan. The rest of the world will not keep quiet and Pak will suffer immensely if editorial like this are not listened to.
@Ejaaz: Well said! Bravo.
Extremism grips the Muslim mind. So, what is new? it has always been that way and history is filled with acts of bigotry against the nonbeliever. The minute we Pakistanis shake organized religion out of our hair, that is the day we progress.
@Ejaaz: Well-spoken Ejaaz. Some other examples of weakness : no real protest against forced conversion and marriages of Hindu girls, oppression of Ahmadis including desecration of their places of worship under court orders, ongoing target killing of Hazaras, the DPC blatantly holding large public gatherings where they incite hatred, ability of terror outfits in North and South Waziristan to stop anti-polio campaign, the audacious Bannu jail break, ongoing Karachi target killing and how an operation had to be abandoned after protests in Lyari, TTP attack on TV station for not giving adequate footage.. Each one of these is a sign of growing intolerance and of the state ceding its sovereignty to powerful non-state actors.
The conclusion of the article left me suspended in mid-air. I expected the author to conclude by providing some reasons or his theory to explain this grip of muslim intolerence across the world - but it suddenly veered to Pakistan and abruptly concluded in two sentences just repeating what everybody knew. What happended author?
Once again a great editorial by ET and very timely as well. There is no doubt that a war is going on in Muslim countries in general and Pakistan in particular between mainstream and extremist Muslims. Your conclusion is right on target and it is Pakistan that the terrorists are focusing. With so much hospitality and acceptance of fanatics and extremists in our society coupled with the hatred toward everything Western from democracy, freedom to way of life. It is a fact that all high value terrorist targets were found in Pakistan in safe havens and in no other country. There cannot be a safer or more hospitable place for OBL and mullah Omar to be situated than Pakistan. It is about time that common citizens decide whether they are with these extremist terrorists or with mainstream Muslims? Pakistan’s future is in the secular liberal democracy and not in theocracy and tyranny of Zia like govt.
With the "Religion of Peace" being the fastest growing religion in the world, God save the rest of us.
You forgot to add Maldives. The second day after Islamist captured the power, they destroyed centuries old Buddhists and Hindu relics preserved in Museums terming those as sign of kufr.
@Waqqas Maalik Wattoo: Good job showing everyone the reason Pakistan is weak. People like you.
@Waqqas Maalik Wattoo: Exact Al-Qaida answer
Excellent article..its time for introspection...we muslims dont realize it but we r plunging into the Al-Qaeda trap...n ur right that Pakistan is a hot favourite because of our obsession with religious zealots...the state tolerates such behaviour of extremists because it believes that they r the ones who would be ruling Afghanistan once Nato leaves.... the fact is that Al-Qaeda uses texts from Quran especially the interpretation of Maududi n thus people hold onto their words...
Time is running out
@Waqqas Malik Wattoo:
The editor is giving evidence of extremism causing havoc in many different muslim countries, and there are more muslims being killed and beheaded by other muslims in Pakistan than in any other country, and all you can think about "WoT of US". And now TTP is US funded? Let us hope we are still strong enough to resist the extremists. When they can behead Pakistani soldiers in FATA and not a single peep of a protest from any leader of Pakistan, that tells you that everyone is afraid of being target for killing if they say anything against the taliban. Our corrupt suo moto obsessed PCO CJ cannot find any problem with the red masjid extremists challenging the state and awarding them free choice land, and not a single party or leader raises any objection. These are not signs of strength but fear, abject fear. Murderer of Taseer is still around and no case is being heard against him. Taseer's son is still kidnapped and held for ranson in FATA. Asiya, the poor christian woman, is still in jail for blasphemy and no one is hearing her pleas or case. These are not signs of strength of the state but abject fear by the leaders of this Land of the Pure.
@Waqqas Maalik Wattoo: Thanks! You just proved the editor right.
Totally irrational approach by editor, and conclusion was predetermined. Pakistan isn't inertly weak at all, fabric of our society is still strong enough to resist Al-Qaida or any other extremist threat. Pakistan only needs to leave WoT of US, and then target US funded TTP terrorists.