US drone attacks in Pakistan: UN backs probe into civilian casualties

I see indiscriminate killings, injuries of civilians in any circumstance as human rights violations, says Navi Pillay.

Afp June 07, 2012

ISLAMABAD: The UN human rights chief on Thursday called for a UN investigation into US drone strikes in Pakistan, questioning their legality and saying they kill innocent civilians.

UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay made the remarks at the end of a four-day visit to the country, where US drone strikes have on average targeted militants once every four days under US President Barack Obama.

Islamabad is understood to have approved the strikes on al Qaeda and Taliban targets in the past. But the government has become increasingly energetic in its public opposition as relations with Washington have nosedived.

"Drone attacks do raise serious questions about compliance with international law," Pillay told a news conference in Islamabad.

"The principle of distinction and proportionality and ensuring accountability for any failure to comply with international law is also difficult when drone attacks are conducted outside the military chain of command and beyond effective and transparent mechanisms of civilian or military control," she said.

She said the attacks violate human rights.

"I see the indiscriminate killings and injuries of civilians in any circumstances as human rights violations."

The UN human rights chief provided no statistics but called for an investigation into civilian casualties, which she said were difficult to track.

"Because these attacks are indiscriminate it is very, very difficult to track the numbers of people who have been killed," she said.

"I suggested to the government that they invite the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Summary or Arbitrary Executions and he will be able to investigate some of the incidents."

She said UN chief Ban Ki-moon had urged states to be "more transparent" about circumstances in which drones are used and take necessary precautions to ensure that the attacks involving drones comply with applicable international law.

"So therefore I stress the importance of investigating such cases and ensuring compensation and redress to the victims."

Washington releases few details about its covert drone programme in Pakistan but on Wednesday US Defense Secretary Leon Panetta described them as self-defence and promised that they would continue to target al Qaeda in Pakistan.

UN raises concern about Pakistan rights record


The United Nations voiced concern Thursday over allegations of "very grave" rights violations and forced disappearances during Pakistani military operations against insurgents and militants.

Independent watchdogs have accused Pakistani security forces of mass arrests and extra-judicial killings in the southwestern province of Balochistan.

"I am concerned by allegations of very grave violations in the context of counter-terrorist and counter-insurgency operations," Pillay told a press conference at the end of a four-day visit to Pakistan.

"These include extrajudicial killings, unacknowledged detention and enforced disappearances."

She said disappearances in Balochistan had become "a focus for national debate, international attention and local despair" and urged the government and judiciary to investigate and resolve the cases.

She said she regretted not visiting Balochistan and the southern province Sindh, where hundreds of people have been killed in political and ethnic clashes in Karachi this year, without explaining why she had not gone.

"I called for investigations of all this and compensation for victims and of course I am very concerned about what steps can be taken to protect people from these kinds of attacks," she said.


Dr.A.Tewari | 11 years ago | Reply

Yes responsibilily of the death of civilians 100% lies with U,S. administration . But in case of Pakistan that can be compunsated as BLOOD MONEY as per Shariya law . They also do not deserve to be delt with UN Law as they do not respect this international body . They hanged Bhutto despite of UN apeal for relaxation . Now US is doing the U

Shah ji | 11 years ago | Reply New York Times published a set of articles last week detailing how Obama classify civilian deaths as Terrorists. Obama argues that the deaths of all "military-aged males", whether there is proof or not, must be defined as Terrorist Killed Any women or children who killed are not considered civilian casualties they are considered Terrorists because they were in the same area. White House believes that civilians death in the past 10 years of war are in, and I quote, "single-digit". Yes, maybe 5 or 6. How did U.S. become so immoral?
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ