Sindhi sub-nationalism goes violent?

Published: May 27, 2012
Five gunmen got into the bus and opened indiscriminate fire on the passengers before fleeing.

Five gunmen got into the bus and opened indiscriminate fire on the passengers before fleeing.

No one missed the similarity between the bus massacre on May 25 in Benazirabad and the one that took place in Kohistan, Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa some months earlier. Five gunmen got into the bus and opened indiscriminate fire on the passengers before fleeing. According to one witness, the gunmen said that they were taking revenge for the murder of Jeay Sindh Muttahida Mahaz leader Muzaffar Bhutto, whose body was found in Hyderabad on May 22, 15 months after he had gone missing. Another witness said that the gunmen “chanted slogans that they had avenged the May 22 attack on the Awami Tehreek rally in Karachi”. No group has claimed responsibility for the carnage but the police say that the Sindhudesh Liberation Army, an insurgent group, had scattered their handbills on the spot where the killings took place.

The Sindhi nationalist groups have denied their involvement. The firebrand leader of the Awami Tehreek, Ayaz Palijo, who had led the Mohabbat-e-Sindh rally in Karachi, said at a news conference that “This [killing] has been carried out by local agents of the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), the CIA and RAW”, the last two names clearly a sarcastic reference to well-known police ‘diagnosis’ of violence they cannot figure out.

Another Sindhi nationalist leader, Dr Qadir Magsi of the Sindh Taraqqi Pasand Party, said that the killers were the same “who had orchestrated the recent killings in Karachi and dumped Muzaffar Bhutto’s body in Hyderabad”. The Jeay Sindh Qaumi Mahaz leader said that “the killings were a conspiracy to undermine our peaceful political struggle” and demanded a commission of Supreme Court judges to probe the incident and the attack on the Mohabbat-e-Sindh rally in Karachi.

Sindhi nationalists have been seen as pacifists but the latest incident of violence might have opened a new phase, which may be an emulation of the overall level of violence found across the entire length and breadth of Pakistan in general, and Karachi in particular. The MQM has always been the target of nationalist opprobrium but the ongoing ‘collaboration’ of the PPP — the popular party that steals the nationalist thunder among voters — and the MQM could have triggered it.

Sindhi sub-nationalist demands have ranged from greater cultural, economic and political rights to political autonomy, to outright secession from Pakistan and the creation of an independent state. It has clashed with another sub-nationalism centred on “Muhajir Suba”, which the Sindhi nationalists claim has been instigated by the MQM.

The nationalists have reacted to two recent murders of their leaders. This could be quietened down through negotiations or it could be the beginning of a violent change in the Sindhi nationalist movement. It is a grassroots movement with classical local charisma against the ingress of alien populations into the region. Its primordial appeal affects all parties in Sindh: both the PPP and the MQM have a stance on the Kalabagh Dam that measures the depth of the nationalist appeal.

Democracy takes care of these anthropologically-oriented movements through participation and representation. The movement of alienation in interior Sindh was fostered by long periods of undemocratic military rule and its accompanying policies, and today the passions have been fanned again by the breakdown of the state through terrorism and the rising level of violence. The national economy has broken down under unrealistic policies adopted in Islamabad and Rawalpindi in two respects: the internal politics of party conflict at times referred to as ‘long march’, and the regional honour-based policy defying the international community which could have helped in Pakistan’s economic bailout at this delicate juncture. By doing this, the ruling elite has tilted in favour of the terrorist groups that have made governance nearly impossible in Pakistan and threatens its neighbours as well as the world at large.

Published in The Express Tribune, May 27th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • Asif khan
    May 27, 2012 - 12:39AM

    It’s tragic the way the passengers were separated according to ethnicities and the ones whose ID cards showed they were from punjab were singled out and shot dead.This ethnic cleansing will only lead to weaken pakistan even further.Killing in cold blood innocent civilians who happened to belong to the wrong province is highly condemnable.The govt. instead of dragging its feet must take prompt and strong action against the terrorists involved in this vicious attack.


  • Nasery
    May 27, 2012 - 12:04PM

    Jaisi karni waisi barni, the same game was played in Afghanistan by the pakistani and irani governments in the early 90s with dividing the afghan population into pashtoon, tajik and hazara to kill each other in the name of ethnicity.


  • mansoor
    May 27, 2012 - 2:25PM

    I think, Tribune is also one of the mainstream print media of Pakistan according to Talat Hassan in his program he defined the role of Pakistan’s mainstreamed media English and Urdu newspapers, channels and publications which a thousand and hundred miles away from the realities of the incidents and accidents or being so-called policy and news headlines decision makers who also dilute and manipulate the news of Sindh and Sindhi People. And he has clearly defined what is mainstreamed media of Pakistan.


  • May 27, 2012 - 6:31PM

    I think this game is played by MQM nd the witneses were been bought to share there vultions to media that sindhis are behind it


  • Ali
    May 27, 2012 - 6:56PM

    How are these movements anthropologically-oriented? At least editorials should be free of such errors.


  • Liberal
    May 27, 2012 - 7:08PM

    ET-Sub-nationalist is wrong word. It is nationalists. Whatever is happening in Pakistan is result of our short-sighted foreign and local policies. We promoted terrorism and religion to save this country and this this same, religious extremism , is going to kill this nation.
    There should be proper inquiry for bus firing and rally firing and responsible should be punished. If this is not possible than people can’t do anything for this State.
    Only who held power most of the time in last 65 years can reply for it.Recommend

  • black and white
    May 27, 2012 - 7:38PM

    ………….we have been living in the mode of denial over last 64 years, which cost us Bangladesh and is now exacting it’s revenge in Baluchistan! the denial is that there are no sub-national groups and our religion is the sole basis of our nation hood. this denies the existence of Punjabi, Sindhi and Bengali nationalities which are more than 5000 years old. this denial was later complicated by the uneven distribution of the development benefits in the country, which was distributed along the ethnic lines. instead of equitably developing the entire country, we limited the development to Karachi and some regions of Punjab, leaving behind the rest of the country in the medieval times. this was further complicated by the repeated murder of the political elite of the under developed regions – this was simply waiting to acquire political logic to throw the entire country into an inferno, given the fact that above litanies of discrimination were accompanied by our location in the hostile neighborhood! we need to massively move to recognize the federation as multinational; recognize the cultural, resource and developmental rights of the provinces; and take a oath never to disrupt the poltical process in the future under whatever designs and motivations!


More in Editorial