A fresh maelstrom struck Pakistan’s already turbulent relationship with the United States on Thursday when a US Senate panel voted to cut aid to Islamabad by a symbolic $33 million ---- $1 million for each year of jail time handed to a physician on charges of helping the CIA find Osama bin Laden.
Hours before, the Foreign Office had called on Washington to respect its court’s decision to imprison Dr Shakil Afridi on charges of high treason.
The Senate Appropriations Committee approved the amendment to the $52 billion US foreign aid budget in a 30 to zero vote in a sign of growing outrage here over Afridi’s conviction.
The mammoth appropriations bill, which includes a total of $1 billion in assistance for Pakistan, will go now to the Senate floor after passing out of committee on Thursday. It also includes a provision calling for a 58 percent cut in aid for Pakistan if Islamabad does not reopen supply routes frozen since US air strikes that killed 24 Pakistani soldiers in November.
“He is not a spy I can tell you,” said Dianne Feinstein, the Democratic chairwoman of the Senate Intelligence Committee. “He should be praised and rewarded.”
“If this is how Pakistan is going to treat a friend and hero. I don’t know about these funds,” Feinstein said.
Foreign Office briefing
Earlier, the foreign ministry reacted to US condemnation of Afridi’s sentence. “I think as far as the case of Mr Afridi is concerned, it was in accordance with Pakistani laws and by the Pakistani courts, and we need to respect each other’s legal processes,” Moazzam Ali Khan told reporters.
Afridi was found guilty of treason, sentenced to 33 years in prison and fined 320,000 rupees ($3,500) under an archaic tribal justice system that governs Pakistan’s semi-autonomous tribal belt since British rule.
Chicago summit
The foreign ministry spokesperson also sought to play down hype over Pakistan’s participation in the recently held Nato summit in Chicago.
“We did not go with any expectation. We went there because we were invited by Nato because Nato feels that Pakistan has an important role to play in ensuring enduring peace and stability in Afghanistan,” he said.
Pakistan was invited to summit at the last movement with a hope that it would formally announce the lifting of six-month old ban on Nato supplies passing through the country. However, talks appear to have stalled on issue of a US apology and an additional transit fee Islamabad is seeking to impose on the Nato trucks.
Afridi ‘weak and depressed’
Shakeel Afridi is in poor health and under medical watch, officials told AFP on Thursday.
Afridi is being held at the central prison in Peshawar and was twice examined on Thursday by doctors who found him “weak, depressed and complaining of a bad stomach”, a senior health official said.
“Afridi was first examined by a team of local doctors, then another team of senior doctors visited him in jail,” the official told AFP, requesting anonymity as he was not authorised to talk to the media.
“Doctors prescribed some medicine, which was immediately provided. He will remain under medical observation inside the jail.”
A jail official said Afridi was being held in a private cell with extra security, with paramilitary and commandos deployed outside.
Earlier on Thursday, jail official Samad Khan said Afridi was in poor health and being kept away from other prisoners to avert any danger to his life. (With additional input by our correspondent in islamabad and AFP)
Published in The Express Tribune, May 25th, 2012.
COMMENTS (50)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@VINOD: .its not about running away,its about ensuring the survival of the race,just in case a destructive narrow minded neighbor decides to use nuclear. we have the ability to return and re establish to defend the name of Pakistan,the Jews did the same or are you going to call them coward too. its a strategical guarantee also to keep the remittance coming in for the times of need .
@VINOD: ” there are more Pakistanis living internationally around the planet,then in Pakistan” ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ CNN to Gilani: one thirds Pakistanis want to leave Pakistan Gilani: Whats stopping them?
@mujahid:You say " there are more Pakistanis living internationally around the planet,then in Pakistan" What a thing to be proud of. In fact this is a shame that because of the conditions in Pakistan most of the people run away.
@rp: thanks a million we don't need aid,it is a blessing in disguise to help us to help ourselves also it gives us the chance to live in dignity. we are not native red Indians that can be ,. wiped out of the face of the planet ,there are more Pakistanis living internationally around the planet,then in Pakistan
Give the Garbage back Any way the Aid never reached the common man and would only pay rich consultants
It's okay, we ought to make up for this $33m with the $5000 per container we're gonna charge NATO
The US should keep doing this as it fits their true face.What a great day it will be when they decide to leave Pakistan as a punishment to us. USA PLEASE GO AWAY, pay your debts and never come here again.
us is using so called aid to pile up pressure on every issue.To improve pakistans bargaining position and to protect its interests pakistan should stop taking aid.The aid amt is not more than 3 percent of gdp.Why accept pressure for peanuts???
@Factcheck Better check your facts Factcheck. You said Pakistan only eaned enimity with neighbors!!! which neighbours? How many wars have we fought with Afghanistan? How many with China? & how many with Iran. Yes if it comes to India, that is a country obsessed with regional power. Its territorial conflict in Kashmir, Arunachal Pradesh, Bangladesh & support of Tamil tigers in Sri Lanka proof my point & yet you blame Pakistan for that. I think you have never been to Afghanistan or Pakistan. Their people share the same culture, as soon as American influence in Afghanistan ends, Pak-Afghan relations will be back to normal.
Thanks our politicians for humiliating us in the name of aid..
@FactCheck:
Pakistan will never achieve have sovereignty until it decides to play fair in the international community of nations.Spot on. The INTERNATIONAL community. Not the US...the issue is not terror or aid or OBL. It is to make Pak surrender and make it an ally like Saudi Arabia or Taiwan. One who does everything the US wants and is a partner(along with India against China) That is as of yet not acceptable for Pakistan. However, if the US would have been an all weather friend Pak could ditch China and embrace the US.
An US embargo and no terror in Pak is way better then US friendship and wars and terror. Pakistan is without a shadow of a doubt fine without US "cooperation". In the last 30 years the superpower keep invading Afg..and that automaticaly leads to trouble in Pak.
Things should be peaceful in 2 years. Looking forward to it.
@Freedom Seeker: In case you don't know, Pak is already charging US and NATO for using the supply route. Also, Pak gets paid handsomely for having refugees from Afghanistan.
These funds go straight into the pockets of people whom you love so much ! (Hint: these people have stars pinned on their shoulder lapels.)
@Freedom Seeker:
Yep, US is worse off than Pak. May be Pak should consider giving aid to the US.
reading all the comments one gets a feeling that people are emotionally charged and refusing to seethe truth. It is not the court it is the state that has put charges of treason against the doctor. Analyse how has he committed treason by helping to catch a terrorist whom the state was also searching. he has not passed the information to an enemy country but to your best allay a friend of last 60 years and brothers in arms in the fight against terror.
@Malik:
You can be assured that it will not go below ‘zero’. Now you can plan Pakistan’s survival on that basis.
Not a pretty picture is it?
Only 33 years...It was indeeed quite lenient sentence for the agent of other countries spy agencies. Should have awarded 85 years sentence. After all, our pakistani girl Afia siddiqi was given 85 years on flimsy grounds. Please make sure that the traitor is not let off for american money or pressure.
@Abu Umar:
Afia Siddique is US citizen. She could hold dual citizenship but when she pledged allegiance to the US, she became US citizen and there is ample evidence to prove her activities were agaist the US.
You Pakistani’s know how to pick a baseless and useless fight in which you do not have a leg to stand on. Moreover Afia Siddique went the entire gamut of the US legal system on appeal after appeal and lost every one of them.
There are kangaroo courts everywhere, not just in Pakistan. Hopefully Afridi's appeal will be heard and will get a fair trial before a higher court!
@Saim Baig:
Pakistan will never achieve have sovereignty until it decides to play fair in the international community of nations. At the moment your reputation on all fronts are being questioned and you all are experts in pouring more gasoline in the fire.
One day your FM says Chicago was a resounding success and few days later FO spokesman says we didn’t go with any expectations. What you people do not understand is US Senate and Congress holds the purse strings and the POTUS can’t do much without their support.
Pakistan has lost it all with the US Congress and repairing it is going to take very long time. What you people don’t realize is that, after 2014, when US pulls out there is going to lot more pressure is going to put on Pakistan just to make sure you guys doesn’t mess up the fragile democracy in Afghanistan.
In the 67 years of your existence, the only thing you have accomplished is enmity with all your neighbors and in the past 30 years you have successful alienated rest of the civilized world.
@Muhammad Yaqub:
Goverment of Pakistan has billion of dollars income. The survive easily. Its worse for people perhaps.
No matter how much aid they take away,the amount we recieve is still free. We sholuld be happy for that.
This sentence is well deserved and shows traitors of the nation not to bow for US dollars. Dr Afridi probably acceptepted money to work for another nation! We absolutly cannot allow that in Pakistan!
@Waqas They are traitors too!!!
As a citizen of Pakistann every one has a moral duty to inform Security Agencies of Pakistan about any murderer , terrorist information that one have. If one informs security agency of another country eventually causing interference in the country's borders ( no matter how much good it brings to the world ), the person will be in breach of its citizenship code and will be called a traitor.
What is the status of the court ? He had no lawyers to aid him !!!
Haha. What Dr. Afridi did, certainly was treason. But what Musharraf and Zia did was treason too. Niether did Dr. Afridi get his proper day in court to record his statement, nor will Musharraf ever be punished in court for his crime. Long live Pakistan. I agree that after what he did, we are probably better off.
Well done US, carry on regardless, since it is an appropriate time to teach Pakistan a good lesson which was long due.
Americans are bankrupt. Their own infrastructure, health, education etc are in desperate need of funds. So better for Pakistan to start to charge American and NATO for their services and use of infrastructure rather then depending on aid. Even this so called aid stays in papers and don't come to Pk in real.
Why does everything have to boil down to money and aid. Everybody knows our governments cannot survive without money and aid !! Will someone find an answer to this convicted doctors problems like they did in case of Raymond !!
And by the way if U.S was so happy with this guy, they should have picked him up prior to the raid. This all sympathy & aid cut campaign is a drama from U.S only to put Pakistan on the back foot in front of the international community. U.S just used Dr. Shakil as bait. After all its the history of U.S to create traitors & ditching them when task assigned to them is done.
Another Raymond Davis drama.
This is now bordering on farce as the US-Pak relationship is now based more than 'threats'. It now seems that with every episode where Pakistan and US don't see eye to an eye, Islamabad would be told how much cut in aid it risks. Where will it end?
He' s in poor health? At least he's not paralysed like those who will contract polio as a result of the mistrust his activities have smeared over the eradication campaign.
I really like the diplomatic skills and diplomacy used by Americans to pressurize the Pakistani Government or it is simply a publicity stunt to move the general populations focus to this topic leaving behind the electricity, water, gas, fuel, inflation issues the citizens of this country are facing.
The US should cancel all Pakistani visa's as well and cancel market access to Pakistani goods and services - they need to show Pakistan that killing terrorists is a good thing NOT a bad thing
@Saim Baig and what about those who helped Osama?! It was too a violation of Pakistan's sovereignty
I am willing to go to jail for one year in return for 1million.
Guess, I'm not important as Afridi.
Instead of these stupid cuts, USA should wage a war on Pakistan.
We can just ask all-weather friend to help us.
Bring it!!! We wont let him go!! Take away you aid. How can Pak & US be friends, when the one who put the sovereignty of our country in danger is U.S backed. People of Pakistan don't consider U.S an ally to begin with. Its the politicians whose government is assured by the U.S.
So he was THAT important for the Americans? And then they claim to not have agents in Pakistan!
This aid comes with so many strings attached and then they want us to remain sincere with them all the time. Keep cutting the aid , we will be cutting the cooperation as well.
pakistan needs more aid cuts
Government should publish the evidence against Dr Afridi. The courts should not be carrying out justice based on public sentiments. I believe he still has the opportunity to appeal in the High court and then in the Supreme Court. The key thing is that it should be clearly demonstrated through evidence that Dr Afridi had the knowledge that he was working for CIA and not an NGO and secondly, he knew his professional actions were used to determine a the identity of a declared terrorist. Considering that Pakistan is a UN member state abiding by its resolutions and bin Laden was a declared terrorist. It is impossible that US could have told Dr Afridi about their intentions and invasion plan. There must be some trained CIA operative working under the guise of an NGO manipulating Dr Afridi. Unfortunately thousands of people work for NGOs in Pakistan and by this harsh decision can be automatically liable for their innocent actions as treason.
Now its US Senate vs Pakistani Parliament ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Earlier it was SPY vs Spy
Great. Please cut the remaining aid too and spare us.
Too little.. $33m should be cut every month. Pakistan should offer an apology to Dr Afridi and he should be released with dignity.
What is with the number 33??
Fully endorse this decision!!!