First off, prepare yourself for the absolute horror of seeing acid attack victims on screen. We’ve all seen photographs of Fakhra Younus and other women who have suffered acid attacks, but it’s nothing like the impact of seeing them on film, talking about their ordeals, relating their stories, weeping tears of pain and frustration at their circumstances. The physical damage of their bodies is almost outdone by the emotional and spiritual damage of their minds and souls. The moment Zakia, one of the women featured in the movie, came on screen, facial skin burned away, lips askew, one eye completely fused shut, everyone in the audience gasped. There were many points in the film where I had to look away because what I was seeing was too much to bear. But their voices continued to ring in our ears, and I had to bring my eyes back to witness them again and again.
The movie is strung on a narrative that seems simple at first. Two women, Zakia and Rukhsana, have been burned with acid by their husbands. Dr Mohammad Jawad comes from the UK armed with advanced plastic surgery techniques in order to help repair their faces. In the meantime, Zakia fights a court case against her husband, who has been threatening her and her family, while Rukhsana is forced to go back and live with her husband’s family, even though they have taken away her access to her daughter. The Pakistani parliament considers and passes a law making acid attack a heinous crime in Pakistan.
Because the film ends with a positive outcome for Zakia and a somewhat hopeful outcome for Rukhsana, I had wondered before watching Saving Face whether or not it was a fairy tale that offered a feel-good story of redemption in order to please its viewers. But I’m glad to say this isn’t so. The narrative is straightforward and linear, which is absolutely necessary because the entire subject is so complex; the simplicity of the narrative’s trajectory serves to highlight, not whitewash, that complexity. It considers the issue of acid attacks from all angles: the medical, cultural, societal, and legal aspects. But the filmmakers stay out of the frame of the camera, allowing the women and the other characters in the movie to speak in their own words about the impact of the attacks on their lives.
I had also wondered whether the figure of Dr Mohammed Jawad represented a white knight sort of saviour, flying in with technology from the West in order to save the blighted women of the East. I’d heard rumblings that he was a chauvinistic figure who treated his patients with insensitivity and condescension. This, too, is untrue; I saw nothing but his warmth and compassion throughout the movie, and his offhand humourous — sometimes inappropriate — comments were characteristic of doctors who use dark humour in order to deal with the monstrous suffering of their patients. It’s the way they maintain a professional distance from the people they’re trying to help.
But most important of all, Saving Face does not portray Rukhsana or Zakia as complete victims. Yes, they have suffered one of the worst physical ordeals imaginable, but they have survived it, and they are fighting back. I was astonished by their faith, their courage, their unwillingness to succumb to the temptation of suicide. Both women travel far distances to reach Dr Jawad, they stay strong for their children, they maintain relationships of equality and partnership with the doctor, the lawyer who’s fighting Zakia’s case, the women of the Acid Survivors Foundation. They are resolute in blaming their husbands — false forgiveness is not for them — but are determined to fight in order to create a better future for themselves and their children. I salute their courage and the dedication of those who help them in their fight.
Their stories, and the images and sounds of Saving Face all work together to create a rich tapestry that provokes not just an emotional response, but an intellectual one. I came away from the movie understanding my country much better than I had when I went in. Pakistan is full of misogyny and patriarchy, but there’s a better Pakistan struggling against that one to emerge, one that wants a modern society with no place for the ancient cruelties, for criminals who escape without punishment, for women to take their place alongside men as equally valued members of society. The women of Saving Face, the issue of acid attacks and the greater issue of domestic violence, and the struggle to raise awareness and bring about change in the law and in societal attitudes towards women are the crucible in which a better Pakistan will be born one day. And the women of Pakistan are the ones who will lead the charge.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 17th, 2012.
COMMENTS (24)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
jimmy, the prostitution in Pakistan is not the true prostitution because a few women are forced by circumstances to indulge in this illegal acts. In India and in West prostitutes are true prostitutes because they freely enjoy being prostitutes and they are encouraged to do so for reason of not learning Islamic lessons.
@kaalchakra: r u such an idiot: u r speaking as if pakistan has no prostitutiom..every country in the world has a dark underbelly...pak is no exception.....atleast in the west there are very strong laws...to protect these women from such men...but in pak tell me where is yr law tht protects women..sorry but west provides far better security and rights.....in pak no one is save...iam nt surprised many pakistanis migrate like rabbits to the west when they get the chance...afterall they are treated like dogs in their own country !!
John B has only pointed out the truth that women have very little political influence to change anything in Islamic history or countries. What is making people so upset?
John B's comments above is very close to what is in every foreigners mind because of this documentary that reveals the negatives of our society....thank you for giving us this Oscar and destroying the image of Pakistan even more. and by the way...there are cases of acid attacks in the UK as well...but they don't produce documentaries that highlight the negatives...and try to win Oscars...
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1221077/Katie-Piper-Acid-attack-victim-bravely-shows-face-disfigured-boyfriend-Daniel-Lynch.html
Emancipation of women is not a matter of religion or country. Women have not been treated fairly throughout history, many exceptions notwithstanding. India has a dubious distinction of being the world's worst killer of females in the womb. The following video on the subject made me feel ashamed as an Indian.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NG3WygJmiVs
@Mirza Education should include proper Islamic education for both girls and boys. Islam does not teach to raise suicide bombers nor advocates destruction of schools , unlike these idiots have been doing with perversion of islam
every 1 in the comments talking about how islam gave women rights. yes islam did but do u people ACTUALLY give women their rights? people rights in books are just words. such rights are no use to women as long as not implemented. you guys should work on implementing them socially by lets say letting your female family members get educated, stop labeling women, stop categorizing women such as pathan aurat or panjabi aurat does not do this or that. I am a muslim, I know what rights i have in islam but will the society, i am living in, ever let me use my rights ?
@faraz: Sir, what I am trying to say is women are not treated equal from the beginning. With limited resources familes ignore daughter's education compared to sons. That is all, this mindset must change if we want to bring about any change. All resources should be spent on education of little girls. Educated mothers usually do not raise suicide bombers. Thanks and regards, Mirza
@John B - grow up, don't tie every other thing with Islam, read some more books, its not fair to be judgemental on Pakistan and Islam just by reading one book.
Saving Hearts Saving face may be a great documentary baring the trauma of acid attack victims but who will bare the attack on the hearts of women by the acid tongue of pakistani men Their dubious double standards and womanising attitude and religious bigotry brings tears to their women who cry in silence within their hearts.Its worse than throwing acid on their faces...as the wounds made by acid may be healed but the wounds made by an acid tongue can never healllll bitterly crying for these miserable souls.
The first time I heard of acid attacks when dukhtarane millat used them to enforce proper Islamic attire in Kashmir. A few women surely suffered for not following proper guidance, but the effect on society, overall was great. Of course, it has nothing to do with Islam but may be part of the local culture.
@Mirza: Remind you that it's a culture in same localities that women serve men first and then eat themselves. Why make it an issue? As far as educating women is concerned, I'm all for it!
I don't agree with you! The sole purpose of this movie was to deface Pakistan. Where in the world aren't crimes? The west and so called developed world in infested with even more horrible crimes against humanity. Just taking out one issue and judging 200 million people from that is just a pathetic attempt to make poor image of a country even worse.
There is only one solution to the acid attacks in Pakistan as the society stands today; the perpetrator should also be subjected to acid burning of the face.
I think we dont want to see such movies which are the full off terrible scenes. It will paste in our minds and desperate our souls and our souls will take direct effect from it.
Every boy has to bound himself or herself in his or her boundary before acting this action which can ruin the life of any body . It is not a talent to make film on the victims, the talent is you create something which is your passion, in ur mind, in ur heart and after seeing that every body feel haapy and may pray for u.
The only way a meaningful improvement in the plight of women can come is due to true education of women. Educated women raise educated and broadminded sons and the society as a whole benefits. Unfortunately a rich country like Pakistan spends most of its money on hundreds of nuclear weapons, over half a million army with the most expensive toys and very little on the uplift of civilians. It is a must for the West to give only economic and civilian aid in the areas of education for women and their healthcare with full oversight. Women’s lives start with eating the leftovers and stale bread while the males enjoy fresh food. Women eat only after all the males are finished eating. Of course there are many exceptions but these are our old traditions and culture that needs to change. Education, education and education are the three most imp things.
The disfigured faces are not nearly as heart wrenching as the souls of those murderous men who perpetrate these crimes, and of those religious fanatics who justify them.
@John B:
Spare us your shortsighted ramblings. This has nothing to do with Islam.
thats the real picture of or society.. a degenerated, unhealthy, twisted and dangerous place
John B.,
For your information, Islam was the first to give women any rights, first to declare them equal, light years ahead of others. Even today, Pakistani women are freer than Western women who have to engage in all kinds of degrading things including prostitution.
@John B: Not even going to all the Islamic history, where women in hundreds were religious teachers (see Mohammad Akram Nadwi's biographies of eight thousands women specialists in hadiths), but even if you just consider Pakistan youve heard of some Benazir Bhutto. You can't just throw sociological mantras about Islam, as if every other part of the world we see matriarchy anyway.
They are already leading the change (e.g Musarrat Misbah from Depilex Smile Again).
bina:
i hope you are right and these instances of good over evil prevail. it would be a shame if these efforts are made on titanic.