The Commando and his spin quacks went several better, thinking it was a boy’s game in the park. “Give us the addresses and telephone numbers of Mullah Omar and his Shura in Quetta and we will go after them, snigger, snigger.”
We were soon sniggering on the other side of our faces for, in the event, the Quetta Shura was not only shown to have been present in Quetta over many, many years through statements on record by respected Baloch parliamentarians (who actually gave their exact locations in the city), none other than Defence Minister Chaudhry Ahmad Mukhtar actually said that military action had “degraded” the Shura.
As for Bin Laden, May 2, 2011 when that terrorist was taken out, is too recent; the layers of egg spread all over the arrogant faces of the senior commanders of our Deep State too thick to have been washed away; the indignant screams and squeals of the TV anchors of the Ghairat Brigades too loud for us to forget in just one year. Yes, the Americans (and the Afghans let us not forget them!) were spot-on, and yes we got our just deserts.
Let me here repeat something I always say when writing about the shenanigans/the ineptness and the incompetence of our Deep State: even though, I and lay people like I, have nothing whatever to do with what it does or does not do, going its mad way despite our protestations; and even though any Pakistani with an iota of sense would be appalled at its antics, I have to, sadly, use the collective pronouns ‘we’ and ‘us’ for we are all Pakistanis. Would that the Deep State cease and desist immediately if not sooner.
There is no hope of that anytime soon as Pakistan sinks deeper into the mire engineered by the boys: witness the mounting acrimoniousness in the relationship between our country and the United States upon which we depend for all of our sophisticated weapons, and money to oil the wheels of our military, and which quite literally keeps our skewed economy, in which the major part of our budget is allocated to defence and to debt-servicing, afloat.
As evidence, even a cursory glance at the Salala incident in which American helicopter gunships attacked the outpost and killed 24 Pakistani servicemen, and its aftermath, will tell you just who calls the shots and how clumsily. I was in Washington DC at the time and remember well the first Pakistani reaction in which we admitted in so many words that it was possible the Americans were fired on first from a position lower than Salala but abutting it, by terrorists/insurgents/whoever.
Witness: On PBS’s flagship programme, Judy Woodruff asks questions of the well-known author Shuja Nawaz who is considered ‘close’ to Pakistan’s security establishment: “Shuja Nawaz, to you first: There is a late report, late this afternoon the Associated Press reported that — quoting defence officials as saying perhaps, this was a case of mistaken identity. What is known at this point?
“Shuja Nawaz, The Atlantic Council: At this point, all that we know is that there was a firefight, perhaps in the border region, and that the Afghan forces asked for support. And it was US air support that came in and went and hit the targets, two of them. Both were Pakistan military posts.” For details please go to:
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/world/july-dec11/pakistan2_11-28.html
Then the Ghairat Brigades and their handmaidens barged in and took over what was a delicate situation at a most fraught time. From the then shooting-from-the-hip ‘spymaster’ (why, oh why do we call these people ‘masters’ of anything at all when all they can do is stomp into a situation that requires delicate and gentle and diplomatic handling?), to the paid propagandists of the Deep State, Paknationalists and their ill-read ilk who feed on people’s fears, we were regaled to much self-righteous indignation and Ghairat-laden diatribes.
Which deteriorated into the present most serious stand-off, not only with the United States but also with Nato and soon with the United Nations itself. Despite which, I have to add, we don’t know whether we are coming or going, our great strategists saying one thing one moment and then contradicting themselves and falling over themselves the very next.
Consider the most recent statement of the Peshawar corps commander as printed in this newspaper of record: “Why do they raise their fingers toward Pakistan? It is shifting the blame on to others”, talking about the United States project in Afghanistan. He then defends “the government’s dealings with North Waziristan-based militant commander Hafiz Gul Bahadur who has signed a nonaggression pact with the government”, and in the very next breath says: “Something has to be done, and it’s in the offing, North Waziristan is the only region we haven’t cleared. It should be done as early as possible”. Leaves you cross-eyed and gasping for breath, doesn’t it reader?
Mark my words: If the Secretary of State has herself signalled that Zawahiri is in Pakistan the Americans have a bead on him already, and they will take him out whenever it is politically expedient. Remember, this is an election year.
Let us accept that our country is now caught in a most serious, almost existential crisis. Let us accept that we are virtually the pariahs of the world, our country known as the ‘Ground Zero’ of terrorism; let us accept that we are some of the most hated people in the world. Let me, therefore, make a call I have often made to all the stakeholders: the people; politicians; the Deep State and its commanders; to each and every Pakistani, that there is no way but one.
And that is that we cleanse ourselves of the poison that is terrorism; of the cruelty that is religious and ethnic intolerance, and of the abomination that is covetousness of another’s territory. More than anything, let us rid ourselves of jingoism.
Published in The Express Tribune, May 11th, 2012.
COMMENTS (38)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@DB NATO supply embargo has had little effort on US operations in Afghanistan.
After the OBL incident, the GHQ has tightened the security by a great deal. This time, it may not be possible for the U.S. to carry out as successful an operation. Foreigners are scared to even visit Pakistan. Foreign tourists, journalists, geologists, aid experts, diplomats and doctors are kidnapped and killed, sometimes, by videotaped beheading and others get the message. The Red Cross recently shut down its 1,000-man strong operations after Dr. Dale's killing. Under what cover the American spies can now operate in Pakistan? Zawahiri appears to be perfectly safe.
The effects of the closed NATO supply route are in full display judging by this hurried manic article from US State Dept.
Addition to the last paragraph.........and let us rid ourselves of shameless 'sell-offs'
spot on yet again, Mr. Shafi! a very brave article. as Meekal Ahmed said, watch your back!
You never fail to impress calling spade a spade and putting things so well and so succinctly for all to see..
You are a master in highlighting in simple words the grand delusion and self denial of khakis and its agents chasing the nirvana that is in fact a quick sand..
You have taken a leadership position amongst the bunch of writers that are either unable to narrate things so aptly or are too scared to appear on the radar, lest they face Saleem Shahzad's fate.
Your sane voice which is far more louder than all other voices put together will get noticed and if nothing else, would definitely make your readers more aware of our precarious situation.
Well done.
Regards Haris
I'm a Pakistani Pakhtun whose nation has suffered beyond description in this Establishment's never ending strategic games. Sir, your articles about establishment always hit the spot and God bless you!
Jingoism make our militiary personnel richer and richer (and the rest of us 180m poorer and poorer). If you were in charge of a business that made you richer and richer, would you let go of it?
Just now I read that the 65 per cent of our country has a mobile phone. That means the economy is now booming. How can such a country be in bad shape ?
I don't believe a word of what this article says. You are looking at the glass as half-empty !!
@Parvez: What politics! does pakistan have politics r political leaders,those who do politics r not in the media ,politics is centerlized in panjab and panjab interests, every policy is made under panjabi influence and interests,the only wayout is to gave liberation to nation living in panjabistan colony,the world will be more saffer thanever.
"And that is that we cleanse ourselves". How true it is and how difficult it is to implement. I suspect that it might consume the whole country before being carried out. It is too late.
The problem is the problem of who will guard the guards?
A fantastic article. My blessings to the Author.
KS Sahib, I salute you for your openness and no nonsense approach to the worst problem of terrorism. I think there is an easy solution and that is for us to stop lying and start telling the truth. However, truth is the last thing that comes out in Pakistan. Yet sadly enough the majority of naïve Pakistanis continue to deceive themselves and refuse to face the facts. When the tombs and shrines are not safe at the hands of terrorists, who can feel safe?
Pakistan is having its throat squeezed, not by the Americans though. Public is mad not at those who are squeezing its throat but at the Americans. When hate takes over logic and reason cannot but be a casualty.
Elsewhere in your paper is a report accepting a non-apology apology from the US.
Pakistan has reached the point of no return. The ISI and the army have already created an atmosphere of religious fervour and extremism where the US/NATO are considered anti-Islam and anti-Pakistan. While they may be able to tone down the rhetoric for the short term, they can't undo the damage they have done.
It is a given that this country must now endure decades of instability and violence. It doesn't matter any more whether/when the US leaves Afghanistan. We have destabilized them, and in the process ourselves. Having hounded out the minorities, or kidnapped them and forced their conversion, we have now turned on ourselves and our sects must continue the bloodshed and strife. A lot of Pakistanis, civilians and soldiers, will pay for the wrongs of our intelligence and security establishment.
Rightfully said. How do we about it? Firstly, we speak the truth. Seconly,we accept responsibility of our actions. Thirdly,accountability of actions. Fourthly, get competent reliable people in. When and if the Army and it's agencies decide to do it,it will happen. They gave us shaukat followed by gilani. Mcannot even live in this country without security. Such a secure nation he left behind.
Back to establishment. Oh lord regurgitation break for only one week. Hmm although they ruined the zoo. !!!
Of course you were in Washington DC. Feeling important trashing your own countrymen while overseas? I wouldn't put that beyond someone like you.
@ashar: Major will make a fine spokesman for the U.S. State Dept. or the Pentagon. Many of his articles appear to be scripts handed to him by ...
Well, to each his zone.
@Balance Sheet. The accounting equation analogy maybe correct - may explain why Pakistan is perceived as having deficit equity.
These guardians of staus quo ,aka military mulla media,are the the biggest beneficiaries in this land of pure.and the biggest looser are the masses, they will continue to eat grass for the protection of their homeland.These guardians of status quo will protect this heaven from within and from outside for their own intrests ,not for for this poor volk not at all,civilians institutions are too weak to bring a fundamental changes one should forget it.The fundamental change can only be brought by the powerfull institution i.e the military as,diamond cuts diamond.As logic says,it will come suddenly.let us pray for this change to happen as soon as possible and let us also pray with as little blood shed as possible.
Articles like this go to show that all Pakistanis aren't bad. It's common sense to know that but, whenever it's said, it's usually an empty claim by someone where it's never reflected in their character/opinions leaving plenty of room for lack of acknowledgment.
And all this fake bravado is about to end. NATO supply line would reopen and US would concede nothing. Our trump card turned out be a joker
May be he would be in USA ...
Well Mark my words. Americans have signed a Deal With Afghan Forces and they have given them Authority of Night Raids. An ordinary Brain thinks why this is so and the answer is for the next time raid in Pakistan Afghan Forces will come and Since Our Security Establishment is in Denial so This time There will be an Operation Against Zawahari on Pakistani Soil but this Time Afghan Forces Will be upfront in Night Raid along with American forces....... and it will be a Slap on Our Security Establishment that they will not be able to wash out this disgrace for a Longer time in Future.
Excellent, Mickey.
Watch your back!
Good luck and safety to the author and his fellow stallwart Pakistanis who have the courage to actively resist and challenge the present culture of jingoism, extremism and intolerance. The civilized world is with you, and will owe you a huge debt of gratitude if you are successful in your efforts to reform Pakistani society!!
Do you have a duel nationality, Major?
Sir it is better that the Deep State acted on its own before Americans took away yet another evidence like they did after 02/05/2011 operation. And my gut feeling says this time our next "hero" is going to be picked up from near another premier institute of war studies, maybe somewhere near Shura neighborhood in Quetta.
Mickey, as always yours is a voice of sanity.
Kamran Saheb,
It's always a pleasure reading your write ups. An excellent anayslis once again. I was waiting for that after reading the Corp Commandar Peshawar's statement the other day. Somethings can't change which is a pity!
Excellent, as always Kamran sahib! Keep up the good work.
Always great to read your articles. What you suggest in the end paragraph needs to be done without doubt but only a strong credible political force that is willing to take charge can do this. Seeing what we have .........need I say more.
excellent as always. Bravo.
It appears that the Deep State makes policies based on the accounting equation:
Assets = Liabilities + Owner's Equity (terrorists/militants/ (pariah status/suicide bombings/ (losing large tracts of NWFP and freedom fighters) economic & military sanctions) and Kashmir to terrorists)
The Deep State should visit LUMS and take a course in basic accounting, otherwise the above equation will quickly turn into an inequality, with the right hand side much greater than the left hand side.