No car parking for temple

Published: April 16, 2012

KARACHI: Karachi has a population of 21 million, which at the time of Partition, was slightly under half a million. At the time, 51 per cent was Hindu and now this figure is about 1.45 per cent. The community is doing all it can to preserve 50 temples in different parts of Karachi — the number was over 450 before Partition.

The Ratneshwar Mahadev temple in Clifton, adjacent to the Jahangir Kothari Parade, is a nationally-known temple, and is visited by Hindus from all over Pakistan. The car parking of the 150-year old temple has been converted into space where a seasonal flower exhibition is held by the city government. The flower show, however, takes place only in March-April. Besides this, the parking space is not used for any other purpose. In addition, the temple’s entrance has been demolished. Every year, a grand mela of Lord Shiva is held for three days, which is attended by 25,000 people daily. In addition, every Monday 5,000 people and on all other days around 1,000 people visit the temple.

With no parking available within a one-kilometre radius , the attendance at the temple is decreasing. Parking vehicles on the road side can result in heavy fines and in some cases vehicles have even been stolen. We, the Hindus, the largest religious minority of Pakistan, demand that the temple’s parking be restored and its entrance area designated as temple property. Safeguarding religious property is the duty of the government and is required under Pakistani law, UN resolutions and the vision that Mohammad Ali Jinnah had for Pakistan.

Kalavanti Raja Menghwar

Published in The Express Tribune, April 17th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (3)

  • A Peshawary
    Apr 17, 2012 - 1:43PM

    What a shame no body has commented on this. Perhaps it pertains to Hidus, if it was case of mosque, church or coffee house of scholars it would have been the most read letter. Even the champions of human rights and civils society activitist or also silent on it.

    A Peshawar


  • Shamim Sagheer
    Apr 17, 2012 - 2:50PM

    The writer has genuinely pointed out to a serious problem facing the hindu minorities. He is well justified in requesting for a solution to the problem. Here I would like to correct him by adding that parking problem is faced by the people everywhere be it mosques or shopping mall or even hospitals, there is no discrimination. The temple is located in the clifton area where charged parking hasd been introduced by CBC Clifton Board Cantonement at many places. It would be worthwhile to approach them for assistance and resolution. I am hopeful that the problem can be solved as it is not a big issue especially when the parking space already exists.


  • Shakir Lakhani
    Apr 17, 2012 - 10:19PM

    I can’t believe that 51% of the population of Karachi in 1947 comprised of Hindus. Can the writer prove this?


More in Letters