It is easy to blame this disturbing scenario on the sheer volume of ‘incidences’ which occur on a daily basis in one part of the country or another. Still easier is to blame it on whatever circumstances happen to be prevalent at the time. Yet, there is absolutely no denying the fact that ‘man’s inhumanity to man’ is now taken with the proverbial pinch of salt, a shrug of the shoulders and a ‘So what? The victims were strangers to us so it’s none of our business or concern’.
That the victims were Mohajirs, Sindhis, Punjabis, Baloch, Pathans or Kashmiri etc is always pointed out as if someone’s ethnicity is the root cause of whatever unfortunate occurrence has brought them, dead or alive, to public attention –– the fact that they were/are Pakistani citizens rarely enters the equation at all. This underlines just how selfish and unpatriotically insular our society has become. It could well be a multifaceted, highly contagious case of ‘follow my leader’, in that people have blindly followed the bad examples of the endless parade of self-serving, insatiably greedy, corrupt and ridiculously arrogant so-called politicians they have allowed –– yes ‘allowed’ –– to hold the reins of power over the last few years. Or, maybe they learnt this behaviour elsewhere but it came to manifest itself as it is indisputably present and thriving.
Violence begets violence, corruption begets corruption and so on down the line until, as in all ‘civilisations’ they get so afflicted that they get lost in the annals of history or of more recent ilk, they either implode or explode with the same result. Provinces or countries as a whole, fragment into oblivion with, perhaps, just a few tattered remains blowing in the winds of time to indicate that they were once real and not a figment of collective imagination.
If this is what the Pakistanis want, and given the way they are acting, day in and day out, their wish is going to come true –– sooner rather than later.
Published in The Express Tribune, March 22nd, 2012.
COMMENTS (9)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
This is the nation that PAK wanted and now has.
@Falcon: I think it is the english media.our less educated people are more loyal to the country as they have no where to go. secondly our affluent and more educated people are infected with a disease called " Pakistan bashing" which is thier favourite pass time. They have a very low self esteem. and suffer from masochism i.e Deriving pleasure from self inflicted wound. they are unable to find any thing good about Pakistan.
I always held that the silent majority was in fact the indifferent majority
Today humanity is suffering from an erosion in human values. Definitely some countries are worse than others but the root cause of many problems is the inroad made by Consumerism and subsequently GREED. Today people are respected by the weight of their wallets, not the quality of their Deeds. Earning money by hook or by crook is the new age mantra.
@Solomon2: I think it is both but more can be attributed to Urdu. There are multiple factors at work. We have multiple developments that are happening at the same time; terrorism, institutional wars, rapid media growth, and shrinking economy. All this means that sensationalism has taken the front seat because of the specifics of media business model at the time when we are going through the worst phase of our nation on other fronts. This has pushed people into a state of shock, self-hatred, denial, and conspiracy theories. From the people I know, the happy ones are those who keep away from news. Others feel helpless not knowing what to do. Still others feel they have to survive in this 'perceived' jungle by stepping over skulls of others (metaphorically). A more responsible media strategy would have been to give more coverage to nation builders with solutions as compared to traditional politicians and criminals who keep hogging the waves for most of the air time.
This trend could be a product of Pakistani people's experience of Pakistani reality - a famous, popular and influential former prime minister is murdered in a public place in broad daylight but the many investigations get nowhere in four years even though her widower and her party have been in power during this time.
@Falcon: " I say also because of the very hopeless and pessimistic attitude media has given to people."
Is the Urdu media better or worse than the English?
It's called desensitization
Good article. Let me connect few dots here. My observation has been that is partially due to confusion, partially due to very sad entrenched belief that 'it can't be us, its our enemies involved in this' (conspiracy theory version), partly due to de-sensitization by sheer occurrence of so many events, partly inability to focus on these issues because every one is struggling with life in their own terms, and may I say also because of the very hopeless and pessimistic attitude media has given to people. The last point is specially important because people fight for something when they have hope and when everybody is busy slaughtering that very hope through their version of 'pragmatism', people give up the fight for others because survival for their own selves and their families becomes the first priority in the jungle.