Certifiably sick

The government and armed forces have failed miserably in eliminating extremism and non-tolerant behaviour.


Zahrah Nasir February 28, 2012

Picture this: A stereotypical Talib of the illiterate kind, perched on a rocky border outcrop, rocket launcher aimed in the direction of an approaching drone, while a suave, suited, clipboard and pen wielding apparition of ‘modern’ man standing at a wary distance, methodically works through a list of specially-prepared questions aimed at ascertaining whether or not the Talib is suffering from a treatable mental illness or whether he is irredeemably insane.

The scenario, at least, in the mind of Senate Chairman Farooq H Naek, is not as farfetched as it sounds. While addressing the inaugural ceremony of the second day of the ‘13th National Psychology Conference’ at the International Islamic University in Islamabad some days ago, the honourable gentleman said: “Psychologists should strive to eliminate extremism and non-tolerant behaviour from society” which, in some circles, at least, is tantamount to publicly and finally admitting something that everyone knows — that the government and armed forces have failed miserably in this respect.

Mr Naek stuck his neck out even further in explaining, quite seriously, that the manifold reasons lurking behind increasing levels of psychosocial stress include violation of human rights, in addition to social, political and economic injustices. Let’s face it, as Senate Chairman he, for one, is certainly in a position to know the relevant symptoms of government induced-illnesses which — or so he claims — are to blame for increased incidents of aggressive behaviour, suicide, terrorism and global frustration and putting it bluntly, he is damn well right!

The types of psychosocial stress Mr Naek highlighted are not, however, liable to mysteriously ‘disappear’ in the manner that far too many outspoken nationalists have done over recent years. Nor will it blow away — like journalists exposing truths that the government and agencies prefer to keep well and truly hidden, beneath the filth encrusted carpet of power — simply by dispensing cocktails of ‘happy pills’ to those perceived as proven or potential offenders. The causative issues underlying psychosocial stress will not evaporate if, and when, ‘offenders’ are relegated to a precariously hazy survival in a drug-induced fairy land, over which an evil dwarf presides.

Raising the study of psychology and making it a “compulsory subject” in certain institutions, as was also suggested by Mr Naek, with the future intention of being able to release battalions of corrective psychologists on the nation, is no way to control government-created problems either. Unless, of course — and it is always possible — the construction of Soviet-era style Gulags is to follow, so that anyone brave or audacious enough to stand up and speak out can be summarily certified as an insanely dangerous menace to a ‘safe’ society and thus, be ‘legally’ removed for the foreseeable future.

Come, come Mr Naek; the nation is far from being as sick as the government would have everyone, including the global population, believe — the situation, to any person lucky enough to retain an ounce of common sense and be unafraid to use it, is, quite obviously, the other way around!

Published in The Express Tribune, February 29th, 2012.

COMMENTS (6)

V. C. Bhutani | 12 years ago | Reply It is hopeless to expect that things will improve unless you first diagnose the ailment accurately. The problem was aggravated by ZA Bhutto when he compromised with extremist/Islamist elements. Not to be left behind, his executioner Ziaul Haq, the mullah in uniform, proceeded to do one better by giving society such a heavy dose of Islamization that society never recovered its breath thereafter. Besides, none of his successors had the courage or the far sight to reverse the trend. It should be clear someone of even the meanest intelligence that it is the education system that is inherently responsible for making people what they become. Much of the education is imparted in madrassas. In other schools too, there is a staple diet of obscurantism that is rammed down the throats of students. Additionally, it is apposite to remember that a society develops with its own efforts and by reference to itself, not by blaming others for its ills and assuming and hoping that problems will go away. No one in the world is a sworn enemy of the people of Pakistan, or the society of Pakistan, or the State of Pakistan. It is in schools that tomorrow’s citizens are reared. Give them sound education and not merely eternal doses of Islamism, and shariat. They need to be put through a modern and liberal course of teaching and not merely sermons that can only produce a mindset locked in medieval and outdated lore. Someone needs to arise who will abolish the madrassas with one stroke of the pen and put in their place modern schools with curriculum designed to produce open minds. V. C. Bhutani, Delhi, India, 29 Feb 2012, 1750 IST
antanu g | 12 years ago | Reply

it has become fashionable in pakistan to blame everythlng evil on government and armed forces.the question is what the so called intellectuals are doing in this regard instead of criticising?

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ