Spurious drugs case: Pharma association’s acting chief blasts industry, regulator

Published: February 17, 2012
Acting Chairman Pakistan Pharmaceutical Manufactures
Association, Tariq Akram addressing a press conference
at a local hotel in Karachi.

Acting Chairman Pakistan Pharmaceutical Manufactures Association, Tariq Akram addressing a press conference at a local hotel in Karachi.

KARACHI: The spurious drugs debacle claimed another victim on Thursday – the pharmaceutical association.

In a dramatic about-turn, the acting chief of the association turned rogue at an official press conference, and blamed the industry itself, and the licensing authority, for the spurious drugs debacle that claimed over 130 lives in Punjab.

After reading the Pakistan Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association’s (PPMA) official statement, acting chief Tariq Ikram crumpled it up, trashed it, and resigned from his position as the body’s vice chairman.

“I was pressurised to read this statement, which does not include my input,” Ikram said.

“I am done with PPMA. We have to answer to Allah,” he added.

Ikram, whose family has been among the founding members of the PPMA, and associated with it for the last 25 years, also withdrew his company Opal Laboratories’ membership from the body.

As baffled panelists wondered what had happened, former chairman PPMA Dr Qaiser Waheed attempted some damage control.

Waheed said Ikram was hurt for not being allowed to share certain information at a time when the entire industry is being defamed, and has therefore resigned in anger.

Ikram attempted to speak again, but left after the audience suggested he hold a separate press conference.

He later sent his statement to The Express Tribune via email. More factories, less inspectors.

Between 1947 and 1988, the health ministry issued three manufacturing licences for pharmaceutical firms per year – 126 in total – but between 1988 and 2011, a total of 580 licences were issued, at a rate of 26 per year, Ikram’s statement said.

While manufacturing units have increased from 129 in 1988 to 709 in 2011 – an increase of 450% – the number of drug inspectors monitoring these units has barely inched up.

In 1988, the number of provincial drug inspectors across Pakistan was approximately 91 – one inspector per 1.4 factories – while it increased to 263 in 2011 – with one inspector for 2.6 factories.

With the drug regulatory authority being defunct, inspectors cannot enter factories or inspect the quality of manufacturing there.

Pharmacy at every corner

Ikram also blamed the government for registering thousands of pharmacies, majority of whom do not comply with the Drug Act 1976.

There were 20,000 registered pharmacies in 1988 and that number exceeds 78,000 today, the statement said.

The Drug Act 1976 states that each pharmacy must have a licensed pharmacist duly registered with the Pharmacy Council of Pakistan (PCP). Interestingly, only 6,142 pharmacists are duly registered with the PCP.

Meanwhile, several hospitals, including public facilities, do not have registered and qualified pharmacists for managing prescriptions and issuance of medication to patients, the statement said.

Cutting corners

Ikram’s statement said that the cost of setting up a new pharmaceutical factory ranges between Rs500 million and Rs1 billion at present, depending on the plant’s size.

In the past 22 years, hundreds of licences were issued to applicants whose investment may not have even exceeded Rs50 million, the statement added.

To meet operational costs, these factories – with limited capital – cut corners, compromising on quality and standards, Ikram said.

How do regulators expect such companies to cope with the cost of manufacturing and sales in these inflationary years, he added rhetorically.

Training and resources

Inadequate training of drug inspectors and meagre salaries are other areas that need attemtion, the statement said. No trainings were imparted to federal or provincial drug inspectors in 2012, it added.

While the average salary of a federal drug inspector ranges between Rs50,000 and Rs70,000, that of a production and quality control manager at a private manufacturing unit ranges between Rs200,000 and Rs300,000.

A provincial drug inspector in Sindh requires a monthly expense budget of Rs100,000 to Rs200,000 but actually receives between Rs10,000 and Rs15,000, it added.

Spurious drugs

The biggest challenge to the industry is not foreign competition – it is spurious drugs that account for 40% of the total drugs circulating in the market, the statement said.

A host of substandard plants are operating from small cities such as Sukkur and Hyderabad, manufacturing spurious drugs and replicating drugs of the multinational companies, it added.

These black sheep have to be identified and punished, Ikram said, adding that it is difficult due to bureaucratic influences.

He cited an example where a PPMA delegation and Pakistan Chemists and Druggists Association, along with a drug inspector, raided a pharmacy and caught a handful of spurious drugs.

“No action could be taken against the manufacture due to political intervention,” he said.

Ministry’s pressure

When asked why he was pressurised by his association to not reveal this information publicly, Ikram said it feared a government backlash.

The PPMA fears that the health ministry can victimise it, and could even shut down the entire industry in a day by generating fake cases against them.

Talking about PPMA’s role in the entire episode, Ikram said the association cannot audit any manufacturing unit nor can it stop any pharmaceutical factory from becoming a PPMA member.

According to a Peshawar High Court ruling, the association cannot audit any factory at the time of launch.

Additionally, the health ministry has allowed new factories to become PPMA member saying if it has given the licence, how can the PPMA stop it from becoming part of the body.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 17th, 2012.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (13)

  • jagjit sidhoo
    Feb 17, 2012 - 6:37AM

    Mr Ikram seems to be a honest man who has surrendered


  • Feb 17, 2012 - 6:59AM

    The monitors are to be blamed and questioned, as to why this anomoly and what steps have they now taken to check the processes at every stage in a honest, transparent and effective way.They may be made answerable by those who have to answer in turn to their creator


  • Armi
    Feb 17, 2012 - 7:56AM

    All valid facts, irrelevant to the tragedy, however. The deaths weren’t caused by some smaller company whose quality control issues led to contaminated drugs being supplied in the market. Rather they have been caused by drugs manufactured by one of the biggest and most established manufacturer, similar to the one that Mr. Ikram owns. The problem is bigger and more far reaching than simply too much licensing and too few inspectors, although that might be part of the problem. I think that entry of these smaller firms that Mr. Ikram is angry at, threatened the bigger firms, whose scale of production meant that they had to beef up production, increasing costs yet keeping the profits growing, leading to a loss in quality. Trying to keep up with competition may well have led to negligence which caused this travesty.


  • shafqat
    Feb 17, 2012 - 8:42AM

    if sane voices will continue leaving then the number of insane will increase and hence nothing will improve.i request mr ikram to continue his struggle as it is already doomsday scenario,more than 100 deaths and no heads rolling……., astonishing…..


  • Feb 17, 2012 - 9:23AM

    I do not call him an innocent man. He had been in the ministry when all was being done, and carried as has been defined by him. But, it is never late to be sorry than repenting over things. It refreshed mine mind today, something good is happening.


  • A Rehman
    Feb 17, 2012 - 9:33AM

    it should be compulsory for all leaders – the president, PM, MPAs and MNAs to seek medical treatment at their local government hospital. we will witness a dramatic rise in the quality of medical care, hygiene, regulatory oversight etc. And enforcement of all related laws would be ensured.


  • Adnan
    Feb 17, 2012 - 9:43AM

    I wonder if mr Ikram too is paying such a high amount of salary to his QC manager or production manager. As a matter of fact i have not heard about it before. This all seems to me a drama already staged by the association itself.


  • Adam
    Feb 17, 2012 - 9:45AM

    Last ditch effort to rescue the culprit.


  • Adam
    Feb 17, 2012 - 9:50AM

    @shafqat: association will try its level best to save Efroze and this is part of their strategy


  • Jawad
    Feb 17, 2012 - 10:00AM

    One thing I know about Pakistan, everyone has a ‘Cut’…


  • Adeel Ahmed
    Feb 19, 2012 - 10:18PM

    I’m deeply concerned with most of the comments! I wonder if people would ever try to understand the issues?

    I had a talk with Express Tribune on Friday which is not going to become part of any news but ET does and will behave most responsible among other publishers.


  • Adeel Ahmed
    Feb 19, 2012 - 11:17PM

    @Jawad: and @Adam: How do you know these, respectively? And, please jot a down relevance to the subject, please.


  • Apr 4, 2012 - 9:20PM

    @Adeel Ahmed:

    Things are pretty clear, even after lapse of the normal hype media and public outburst what have the concerned done??? nothing everyone is aware what has happened, and what is still happening–but the will is lacking due to reason best known== bear in mind it can be anyone who gets caught to the web so built++So think positively let the poor masses not be fooled. let those who know come forward and help build a better nation???


More in Pakistan