Pakistan

National Assembly: Nawaz’s military courts remarks ‘misconstrued’

Chaudhry Nisar says party chief was ‘just referring’ to a decision of the past.

Qamar Zaman January 05, 2012

ISLAMABAD:

A day after facing criticism by political rivals, the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) clarified in the National Assembly on Wednesday that its chief Nawaz Sharif’s statement regarding the establishment of military courts in Karachi was ‘misconstrued’.

“PML-N will not support any military court either in Karachi or Swat. We do not support even military operations,” said Leader of the Opposition in the NA Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan.

During his visit to Karachi on Monday, Nawaz said that he had established military courts to improve the volatile law and order situation in the country’s financial capital and would do it again.

“How can we talk about military courts while being in the opposition,” Nisar said, while recalling that in the past the PML-N government had abandoned the idea of military courts after a decision by the Supreme Court.

Nisar said that Sharif was just referring to a decision of the past when extreme circumstances led his party to take the extreme step of establishing military courts in Karachi.

He censured Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani, who had described the PML-N chief’s comments as double standards, and said that instead of criticising Nawaz, the premier should have clarified his statement regarding Osama bin Laden’s presence in Pakistan.

‘No support for new provinces on lingual basis’

The opposition leader also criticised a resolution submitted by the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) for the creation of Hazara province.

“A party which has no representation in the province has no right to propose a division,” he said. “The PML-N supports creation of new provinces if it is not on lingual basis,” Nisar added.

Nisar said that new provinces cannot be created overnight but the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) had nothing else to ‘lure’ voters with in the next general elections. Later in the day, Ahsan Iqbal of the PML-N made an attempt to persuade the MQM and the Awami National Party (ANP) to stop supporting the PPP government.

“Let’s join hands to dislodge this government and I assure you the support of all 92 members of my party,” Ahsan added.

Meanwhile, Religious Affairs Minister Syed Khursheed Shah blamed the PML-N for the energy crisis in the country, saying the party had terminated projects of the PPP government in early 90s. “Why did the Supreme Court not take suo moto notice of this issue as it does not hesitate to take action over lies?” he questioned. “I am not scared of a contempt of court notice since we have sacrificed our judiciary’s independence,” he added.

Published in The Express Tribune, January 5^th, 2012.

COMMENTS (4)

Nadeem | 12 years ago | Reply Since the last four years, Nawaz Sharif’s stance has been anti-military intervention and pro-democracy and so it is disappointing to hear him talk about the reintroduction of military courts, which is indicative of a u-turn vis-à-vis his pro-democracy stance, perhaps to justify what he had done in Karachi in the past. A statement as retrograde and undemocratic as this — that too coming from someone who has maintained a principled anti-military stance — has provoked a reaction of castigation and anger in the National Assembly. Prime Minister Gilani also expressed shock at the comments made by Nawaz Sharif and termed them a reflection of his ‘double standards’, and that for the purpose of curbing violence in Karachi, the Rangers had been deployed in aid of civil power. The sheer embarrassment and discomfiture of the PML-N is evident from the fact that the party has backtracked from its leader’s statement saying that it was misconstrued, as it was merely a reference to the past to explain why such an extreme step had to be taken. Leader of the Opposition Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan has also said that his party would not support any military court either in Karachi or Swat, and that they had given up on the idea of military courts after the Supreme Court ruling in the 1999 Liaquat Hussain case. These assertions by Chaudhry Nisar appear to be nothing other than frantic attempts of the party to control the damage caused by Nawaz Sharif’s initial statement, which was obviously referring to both the future and the past.

Savaira | 12 years ago | Reply

It seems as though Nawaz Sharif’s anti-military and pro-democracy stance is only skin-deep and the fact that he audaciously spoke his mind about bringing in military courts has only exposed his authoritarian state of mind. Having come a long way in politics and at this critical juncture with elections approaching, Nawaz Sharif must exercise better judgement in choosing his words. He must learn from his mistakes and not try to revive the tried and failed policies of the past. Rather he must change his approach and bring it in line with modern day needs, which include strengthening the existing justice system and law-enforcement agencies.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS

K. Salim Jahangir | 12 years ago | Reply " He is too contumacious."

K. Salim Jahangir | 12 years ago | Reply No,this amounts to misrepresenting the fact,his remarks were clear & explicit.Say, Nawaz committed a mistake & takes his words back,but who will convince him to do that?

Replying to X