Humanitarian aid: ‘The biggest mistake UNHCR ever made’

Published: December 28, 2011
Refugees returning from Pakistan and Iran find themselves homeless or living in slums under tarpaulin. PHOTO: REUTERS/FILE

Refugees returning from Pakistan and Iran find themselves homeless or living in slums under tarpaulin. PHOTO: REUTERS/FILE

KABUL: It was in 2002 that the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (UNHCR) implemented a strategy for the rehabilitation of Afghan refugees returning to their country. But it was on Tuesday that the programme’s head in the war-wracked country finally described the strategy as the “biggest mistake the UNHCR ever made”.  

Almost a quarter of the population of Afghanistan is made up of refugees returning from Pakistan and Iran. Many find themselves homeless, or living in slums under tarpaulin.

UNHCR’s representative in Afghanistan Peter Nicolaus said the international community had failed to help returnees find a means of earning a living and, therefore, reintegrating into society. “We thought if we gave humanitarian assistance, macro development would kick in.” He added, “We made a big mistake, the biggest mistake UNHCR ever made”.

Nicolaus said only now, 10 years after the US-led invasion and with 5.7 million refugees having returned to Afghanistan since 2002, was the UNHCR focusing more fully on the issue of sustainable reintegration. An international conference including Afghanistan, Iran, Pakistan and the refugee agency is to be held in April to present the new long-term strategy.

“It’s the income that counts, the livelihood. In very simple terms we need to find jobs for the people coming back,” Nicolaus said. “You can build five roads to a village and the farmers will benefit because they can go to the next town to sell their vegetables. But the returnee doesn’t benefit at all. He has nothing to sell at the market.”

Nicolaus was speaking at a distribution centre for vulnerable returnees, who were gathered on the outskirts of Kabul to receive a package of blankets, clothing, tarpaulins, wheat and coal.

The UNHCR is set to help 34,500 families, or 200,000 individuals, around the country as the freezing winter sets in.

But the difficulty of working in Afghanistan was underlined when the Afghan Minister of Refugees and Repatriation Jamaher Anwary stormed out of the centre because there were UNHCR banners on display but no ministry logo.

Hundreds queued for assistance outside the walled compound, clutching the necessary papers that proved they were designated as being in need of help.

“My husband is old and I don’t have money to take him to the doctor,” said Parveen Shah, 56, from beneath a blue burqa, her hands stained with dirt.

Mohammad Tahar, 30, is one of the 3.7 million who have returned from Pakistan. “I’m glad to be back in my own country but we are 20 in my family and we live in two rooms without electricity or drinking water,” the shopkeeper said. “This assistance is nothing for us.” UNHCR provides cash grants for returnees of $150. The money covers transport home and is supposed to help them survive the first few months of their new lives.

Three million registered Afghan refugees still live in exile, but the lack of jobs, food and shelter and the volatile security situation in many parts of the country makes it difficult for those who want to return. Although the rate has slowed considerably, another 66,500 people came back in 2011. But the UNHCR estimates that 40 per cent of all the returnees it has helped since 2002 are “not at all reintegrated”.

“In Afghanistan a quarter of the population are returnees,” said Nicolaus.”This is what the donor community constantly forgets. This has been overlooked and it’s still overlooked. Nobody has taken this seriously. It’s a tragedy”.  He added that they were going to bring this up for the first time in the spring conference. 

Published in The Express Tribune, December 28th, 2011.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (8)

  • Bangladeshi
    Dec 28, 2011 - 1:01AM

    The terrorist US government should pay each family enough so each can have their own house with stable income And even then the terrorist US army deserves to be bombed by the Taliban & cursed by the afghan people for all eternity.


  • Tariq shah
    Dec 28, 2011 - 4:27AM

    The biggest mistake was letting these barbarians into Pakistan…….never seen worse
    People than filthy Afghans……its a nation of beggars and have no pride
    They expect Pakistan to support them.


  • faraz
    Dec 28, 2011 - 11:45AM

    The biggest disaster for Pakistan is this failed state next door


  • Salman Sheikh
    Dec 28, 2011 - 12:00PM

    They forget to mention Invasion in Afghanistan and Iraq war. Why didn’t they charge Bush for genocide?? now we knew that WMD was a lie.


  • Falcon
    Dec 28, 2011 - 12:31PM

    @Tariq shah:
    wow…isn’t it too harsh??? May be we should have helped them build themselves rather than deploying strategic assets in their country…that would have saved the whole cycle to begin with…don’t you think???


  • Tim-bak-tu
    Dec 28, 2011 - 12:46PM


    I would rephrase the failed unthankful state next door! If the article was supposed to bring emotions out of Pakistanis, well I tell you what, educated Pakistanis won’t even move with this peace of text.


  • Chilli
    Dec 28, 2011 - 5:53PM

    US forces killed millions in last decade. They are the biggest terrorist on earth.


  • Paki-Australian
    Dec 28, 2011 - 6:12PM

    All said and done. We still have issue and it’s here to stay – now Pakistan must do all it can to support the beginning of what will be a closer to normal functional society /state. Pakistan & its people must not expect to wash hands & turn their back to Afghanistan. The refugees may return in bigger numbers if they can not feed themselves.

    Best way forward – support Afghans with building a more respectable life, hopefully peaceful and dignified. This will make Pakistan more stable, truly!


More in World