You’re subservient, or you’re mistaken - PM tells military

Says if army believ­es it is a state within a state, it is unacce­ptable.

Zia Khan/sumera Khan December 23, 2011

ISLAMABAD: In one of the most audacious speeches by a sitting prime minister in recent memory, Yousaf Raza Gilani on Thursday unexpectedly let loose a barrage of accusations and reservations against the country’s all-powerful military establishment.

First at an exhibition, and later on the floor of the National Assembly, Gilani not only voiced concerns over ‘conspiracies being hatched against the incumbent government,’ he questioned the credibility of the armed forces over the Osama bin Laden (OBL) debacle that resulted in questions being asked on the global stage about Pakistan’s sincerity in battling terrorism.

The premier, in a direct reference, hit out at the military establishment, and said that a “state within [a] state will not be acceptable,” referring to the military’s dominance in the country’s affairs.

Fears of ouster

The day started early, and aggressively. “Conspiracies are being hatched to pack-up an elected government,” Gilani said at a photographic exhibition at the Pakistan National Council of the Arts.

“[Whether] we remain in the government or in opposition … we will continue to protect the rights of the people,” the premier said.

The thrust of the prime minister’s blitz, however, was reserved for the National Assembly floor.

“If the army considers itself a state within [a] state, then it is unacceptable,” Gilani said while responding to a point of order raised by Leader of the Opposition Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan.

“We will have to come out of this slavery. If we remain subordinate to this system, then there is no need for parliament,” Gilani said.

OBL’s visa

The premier set out to clear that there are no sacred cows, and that the intelligence agencies cannot absolve themselves in the OBL debacle.

“We are being asked by the judicial [Abbottabad] commission about issuance of visas (to Americans). But I want to ask how Osama bin Laden lived here for the past six years? On what type of visa was he living here,” Gilani asked.

Up next, he took on his own admission of weakness – the defence ministry’s response to the Supreme Court wherein it claimed that military’s operational matters do not come under its domain.

“If they say they are not under the ministry of defence, then we should get out of this slavery,” Gilani said. “Then this parliament has no importance, this system has no importance, then you are not sovereign.”

After pathos, Gilani resorted to logos.

“They are being paid from the state exchequer, from your revenue and from your taxes. All institutions are subservient to parliament, and we have made them accountable to parliament”, the premier said.

His conclusion was terse. “If somebody thinks they are not under the government, they are mistaken. They are under the government and they shall remain under the government, because we are the elected representatives of the people of Pakistan.”

‘We defended you’

Gilani reiterated past events where, he said, the government stood by the armed forces at the bleakest of hours – over a storm of American pressure after the OBL raid, the Nato attack at border posts on November 26, 2011 and the 2008 Mumbai attacks.

“The democratic government has always emboldened and motivated the image of security forces on all issues,” the premier said.

Realising the sacrifices of our soldiers for the cause of the country, the government raised their salaries by a hundred per cent, he added.

The ire was directed not just at the military, though. Gilani also addressed the judiciary, reminding the judges that he ordered their release moments after his election as prime minister, and his government reinstated them to their offices later.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 23rd, 2011.


Observer | 9 years ago | Reply

The comments are so typical of a country which has never known true democracy. People are up in arms to protect the fair name of their armed forces. Please understand Gilani is not defending his government or is a cry of warning to the country that democracy may be at peril here. Give democracy a chance guys. Even before it can take proper root we have a dictator replacing it and demolishing every democratic institution. Elected government - good or bad - is the only alternative to giving the nation's future a chance. Giving the army a more bigger role than protecting the country's borders and allowing it to encroach into politics, is a sure recipe for disaster as your own history has shown. We got to learn from history sometime. I am an Indian and wish Pakistan all the best.

Paki-Australian | 9 years ago | Reply

PM is right in saying, all state institutions including army and intelligence services serves the people of it's country. That's democracy!

However, unpopular governments sometimes do not complete their term, that too is democracy !

All I wish for is an honest Govt! I doubt PPP, PML or Imran Khan could deliver on this. This makes me very sad.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ