Memogate case: Citizen’s letter prompts notices to president, ISI chief
Fresh notices were subsequently issued to the respondents, which include President Asif Ali Zardari, Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani, Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) Director General Ahmed Shuja Pasha and former ambassador to the US Husain Haqqani.
Shafqatullah Sohail, a Pakistani residing in Canada, has been made party to the case after Chief Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry converted a letter written by him into a human rights petition.
In a letter to the chief justice, Sohail argued that the government was out to sell national interest and posed a grave security risk to every citizen if the controversial memo’s contents were proved true. It would, he contended, mean that the government was least concerned about the interest of its own people and, instead, upheld “the interest of other nations or enemies of Pakistan.”
“This is an anti-state act. How come a person involved in this matter sits in a key office of the country and continues as the supreme commander of the Pakistani forces,” Sohail wrote. “Our national security is at stake now and politicians are just making fun of each other by asking so-called committees to probe the memogate affair,” the letter said.
“The committees will delay the outcome rather than (doing) justice,” the letter further said. Sohail said he feared for the life of his family members because he felt that the government could invite “enemies to kill us”.
James Jones’ testimony
The Supreme Court also placed on its record the testimony of Gen (retd) James Logan Jones, former US national security adviser. Jones said he was submitting his affidavit on the request of former ambassador to the US Hussain Haqqani.
Jones, who claims he handed the memo to the then-chairman joint chief of staff Admiral Michael Mullen, said he believed the memo was not credible and that Haqqani had nothing to do with it.
Published in The Express Tribune, December 18th, 2011.
COMMENTS (32)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Ch Allah Daad: May Allah give you guys courage also to stand up on your own issues. A person sitting thousand miles away is raising your voice but you guys are sitting in drawing rooms watching shows. May Allah bless you.
@Mr. Honest: Agreed that the maxim of law is that everyone is innocent until proven guilty. When was Mr. Husain Haqqani found guilty that the Supreme Court put him on the ECL?
What would be done if several letters came in from abroad that their relatives were in the PPP and felt unsafe while Iftikhar Chaudhry was the Chief Justice?
This is a very serious issue. Let the court investigate and decide. Why are they so afraid of this issue being investigated in the supreme court if they are innocent anyway???
Anyone is innocent until proven guilty and convicted in a court of law, so the govt. should fully cooperate with supreme court instead of telling them that this issue is out of the supreme courts jurisdiction. By objecting to court they are also opening the way for military.
One only wishes that some Baloch were US or Canadian citizens so the SC would hop to their simple application like a lower trial court. We have no problems at home that is why we are entertaining all memos and letters from Norht America especially if they are against the elected govt and for blind support of Army rule.
Politicians are always made fun of, all over the world, but Supreme Courts are not. However, with actions like these, I'm afraid, there won't be any distinction left between politicians and Supreme Court.
@Nadir: Illogical and absurd analysis on your behalf
“My family members are in Army and all family members are in Pakistan so I feel insecure from this government as they can invite our enemies to kill us,” the letter stated.I think this idiot mistakingly sent this sponsorship letter to supreme court of Pakistan, instead of Supreme Court of Canada.
This is dangerous, self-distructive and ridiculous decision. At a time, when the country needs sanity from these wisemen, they propose absolutely opposite. Tariq Bashir USA
“There may be times when we are powerless to prevent injustice, but there must never be a time when we fail to protest”
Normally courts dismiss such petitions on ground that petitioner is not a directly effected party but not in this case. Hmmm. What's going on?
Is SC serious to take such dramatic letters? This is very fishy. Some game is probably going on underhand.
No need to railroad this serious matter. Accountability is the need of the hour and Pakistan's SC needs to stand tall and address this for the sake of the Nation!
I have exactly the same concerns as Shafqat! Thanks supreme court!!
INSHALLAH we will overcome our problems!
The petitioner living in Canada should first emigrate to Pakistan and only then can he show his concern about Pakistanis!!!
When will Pakistan get over such a type of nonsense and when will the apex court act like a court and not as mama jee ke kutchery?
This is a serious matter and needs to be take very very seriously! The letter should be taken absolutely seriously . . . .someone has to speak out!
Judges are on adventurism. Let see how far they go. If they want to do something for the nation then pls do justice with our any fear and pressure. Also try to do some actions against anti government/Terrorist/Extremist parties. thanks.
The Honourable Court is making a joke of itself. How can a letter reflecting an almost juvenile level of maturity, dripping with emotional overdrive and superficial nationalism be taken so seriously by such an august body? Is this the level of their judicial and intellectual acumen? Or is the court now clutching at straws, in the aftermath of Gen. Jones's affadavit? Sad, very sad.
Baber awan did pres conference that Supreme court is not authorized to hear this petition. Now matter is clear, this memo is violation of basic human right of citizen of Pakistan. As security of live and property is basic human right and through this memo , Govt is denying that basic right.
@Ahmad: @Imran:
Law is silent when it comes to listen common people cases.
Same old tamasha
Now PCO Judges take up a request of a Canadian Citizen following an American Citizen. How about listening to the Pakistani common citizens as well.
It is ridiculous,,
It is ridiculous....
Will Kamran Shafi's letter also be converted into a petition?
Great work shafaq ullah may god bless u.
Wow! Now our Supreme Court moves into overdrive on the basis of a letter. I guess a letter that paints Zardari badly moves them into action, while all those letters written on behalf of missing persons hasnt led to anything. Where exactly in the letter did it i"nvite our enemies to kill us". Is America now a declared enemy? If so Mansoor Ijaz is an American citizen and this whole episode is because of him! Amazing how the presumption of guilt is enough. This entire letter is based on circumstantial "ifs".