Transgender rights

Transgenders being enabled to vote in elections is a much-needed step.


Editorial November 20, 2011

The Supreme Court’s recent directive that transgender persons be provided with National Identity Cards to enable them to vote in elections is a much-needed step that could lead to the integration of the third-gender community into the broader population.

In Pakistan, attitudes towards transgender persons vary wildly, which is both a consequence and a cause of their convoluted official status in society. Revered, loathed, feared, appreciated and desired in turn, the average transgender person faces discrimination in every sphere of life as a result of their loosely administered rights. Members of the third gender community state that police protection, employment opportunities, fair inheritance and access to health care and justice are systematically denied to them. These cultural attitudes are so pervasive that any attempt to change existing practices by increasing awareness and educating the population will take far too long to work. The only way to ensure that transgender persons are treated fairly is to codify procedures and introduce those clauses into the legal system — something that legislators must push for, especially in light of the Supreme Court’s directives.

Although the transgender community’s struggle is just beginning, their being given the option to identify themselves as either male transgender, female transgender or ‘Khunsa-e-mushkil’ on their ID cards is a positive step, as the ability to freely declare personal affiliations and opinions is the hallmark of a progressive society. Unfortunately, even though this right is being extended to the transgender community, other marginalised communities in Pakistan, namely religious minorities, are still discriminated against despite the existence of laws meant to protect them. Where the implementation of law is poor, it follows that all weaker members of society such as children, women, the elderly, and religious and ethnic minorities, will be in a position of danger.

Published in The Express Tribune, November 21st, 2011.

Facebook Conversations

COMMENTS (8)

MAD | 9 years ago | Reply | Recommend

@Acorn Guts:

I assure you i know what the Difference is. However most of these are what you would call transvestite rather than transgender. I trust you know the difference between the two terms?

Ali Khan | 9 years ago | Reply | Recommend

Hijras are physiological males who have feminine gender identity, wear women's clothing and play feminine gender roles.

These are simply men who like to dress like women. Some are voluntarily castrated. This is peculiar to South Asian society.

These people should be discouraged, not encouraged. You don't often find crossdressers walking the streets of London, for example.

VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ