The government has placed no restrictions on Jamaatud Dawa collecting animal hides after the Eidul Azha sacrifice. The group says it has set up a hundred camps for hide collection in Lahore alone.
Jamaatud Dawa calls itself a charity group and denies having anything to do with militancy, but many of its leaders and workers were formerly part of banned group Lashkar-i-Taiba (LT). The United Nations proscribed JD as a terrorist outfit after the Mumbai attacks in November 2008, which are said to have been carried out by LT.
The Interior Ministry on Saturday issued a list of 31 banned organisations, as is traditional before Eidul Azha each year as a reminder that these groups must not be allowed to collect donations in the form of animal hides. The latest list renews the ban on LT, but excludes JD the group was included on the previous such list.
The list included three organisations (Khuddamul Islam, Islami Tehreek and Millat-i-Islamia) that, like the JD, are believed to be old banned outfits operating under new names (Deobandi militant groups Jaish-i-Muhammad and Sipah-i-Sahaba, and Shia outfit Tehrik-i-Jafria Pakistan, respectively).
Shahid, a member of the JD information department, said that the group was operating roughly a hundred camps in Lahore under the name JD or the Falah-i-Insaniat Foundation (FIF). The FIF has also advertised in newspapers for the donation of animal hides. He said the camps had not been disturbed by law enforcement agencies. “I’ve checked with our camps around the country and there has been no harassment by law enforcement agencies,” he said. “We are helping flood victims and running various other charities. We have nothing to do with militant activities.”
Punjab Law Minister Rana Sanaullah agreed, saying there was “no justification” for restrictions on JD or FIF from collecting animal hides. “They are not on the list of banned outfits,” he said. “No militant or jihadi organisation is allowed to function or collect hides.”
Allama Zubair Ahmed Zaheer, a member of the Council of Islamic Ideology and a Jamiat Ahle Hadith Pakistan leader, said the government was giving “undue favour” to “some militant organisations”.
“It is clear discrimination,” he said. “It shows that such militant organisations follow the government’s agenda and function with its support. No religious party should have the right to make lashkars or wage so-called jihad. How will the government stop militant groups from functioning when it is giving them a free hand to collect funds?”
Maulana Amjad Ali, a member of Khuddamul Islam, said the inclusion of his group on the list and the JD’s exclusion was discrimination against his “peaceful” organisation.
Published in The Express Tribune, November 7th, 2011.
Correction: An earlier version of this article had mentioned the Mumbai attacks to be in November 2009. This is incorrect. The error is regretted.
COMMENTS (59)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
His true profile doesn't lie in helping the flood victims, from where he gets the money and things to help others, it is the government of Pakistan and others who paint him as "hatim Tai" if he is so kind to the people of Pakistan why dont we select him as our President and Mr Edhi as Prime minister.all the problems of Pakistan will be subsided and it will be a"jannat".
@Mard-e-Haq: Care to tell us how many times RSS, VHP etc came into Pakistan to kill its citizens?
@Mard-e-Haq: Did the organisations you mentioned sent anyone to Pakistan to kill innocents? How about that for hypocrisy on your part?
All terrorist organizations have a humanitarian front. They are involved in charity work and show the people the good work they do. However many of these organizations support terrorism. They channel a hugh chunk of their donations to fund militancy. These militants then go and blow up our friends, neighbours and country men. Men women and children. Please be very careful who you give your charity to.
@Ahmer Ali:
Answer this :-
Who welcomed Americans with red carpet ? Who offered air bases for the NATO ? Who said 'you fire drones, i will face it in the assembly' ? Who begged to the then US ambassador for Presidential post ? Who is playing a double game with the name of non-NATO ally ? Who is begging for loans and handouts from US ? Who is most worried about Afghanistan than their own country ? Who is funding the madrassa's which are producing numerous suicide bombers ? Who is responsible for numerous terrorist activities in AfPak which you call fake ? Who to blame for the state now Pakistan is in ? - Its persons like you with corrupt mindset, which always blame others for their ill.
@Musthaq Ahmed: Hi Musthaq - first of all you will find very few Hindus who support the RSS which is perceived to have extreme right wing ideology - an anathema to most Indians. Second is that RSS has never sent armed militants to any country or held prayers for any global terrorists. So I think the comparison is rather weak. You guys need to wake up and smell the coffee.
The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly is to fill the world with fools.
When secular extremist NGO's collect hides and spread their perverse ideology, ET has no problem.
But when an Islamist Charity is doing good for the country, an uproar arises and the liberals, who only mash buttons on a keyboard to bash Islamists and dont do anything for calamity affectees, became enraged.
Hafiz Saeed has done good work, and I encourage and support that. Of course the indian trolls here will stay mum on the fascism of RSS or Shiv Sena. Or even the Gopalgarh massacre.
@riz:
Why doesn’t SC punish these parties if SC has any evidence? After all it’s the courts who can punish anyone not the government or anyone else. SC should also remember those parties who committed Gojra and attacked SC itself when punishing such parties.
@ashok sai: @American Desi: What about USA's and NATO's wild and insane beasts whose have killed and are killing many innocent muslims in Afghanistan on the name of fake terrorism and now after facing the most worst defeat in war against Taliban/Haqqani network despite having most modern war equipments and technologies US' leaders are begging and seeking help from the Afghanistan's neighbor country Pakistan and Saudi Arabia to solve this the most core and burning issue through negotiations.
why does tribune not publish articals on parties collecting animal hides, who are declared by SC having military wings------- even western mdia acknowledged JUD services for flood effectees??????????
I believe JD is indeed strongly connected to terror but it made me smile to read the sheer hypocrisy of Indian commentators here. What's the action being taken against Bal Thackeray, RSS, VHP etc?
Just about every corporate executive knows that the biggest obstacle to Mumbai's quantum leap is the Shiv Sena.
However, these outfits in India pale into comparison to the sheer flow of terror and mayhem inflicted on Pakistan by jihadi charities and organizations.
@Sajjad Sarwar: Did you say "fighting for Islam"? Why would you say that? There's nobody attacking it in the first place! Muslims must get over this persecution complex. If at all your religion is being attacked, it is by the same people who are supposed to preserve it. You're fighting your war on the wrong front.
@Salman:
"Who is ET to term JuD as terrorist group yet ? **Why they speak language of Americans or crap Indian media all the time ?"
Could that be because the "language" of the American and Indian media is the truth?
This is good I too have Given money,there are many poor people and JUD does good work for people all over pakistan As for LET allah gives them money to free Kashmir
@adam:
Yes, and when they don't get enough dead bodies, they kill people. Now I understand their motives..
See the light, my friend. Open your eyes. The proof is all around you...
@Sajjad Sarwar:
There. JuD's own supporters accept JuD are committing violence.
@Babloo: i liked the term.... Ministry of denial & accusations
Ministry of denial of accusations has denied that JuD is a terrorist organization. Chapter closed.
Isn't Hafiz Saeed wanted for investigation in India for the Mumbai attacks and the same guy who held prayers for OBL? And he's head of this charity organization? Yea....nothing suspicious here..../sarc
And Rana Sanaullah is the same guy who stood with the sectarian extremist militants from Jhangvi, who also lied about the Punjab government stipend given to suspected terrorist Malik Ishaq while in jail being a court order? Yup, feel confident that the government is transparently cracking down on extremists..../sarc
Denial No 1. OBL is not in Pakistan.
Denial No 17654 JuD is not a terrorist organisation.
And counting......
@First drink, don't think: No proof of guilt isn't proof of innocence. Past actions and affiliations are enough to come to an obvious conclusion. It just means they did it well enough to not end up behind bars. Though that's not saying much. If you want to commit a crime and get away with it, Pakistan is the choice destination for all.
Just because someone says "there's no proof of my guilt" it's not the same as saying "i'm innocent."
Jamat-ud-Dawa is the only Jamat who are fighting for Islam. They are the peoples who are doing Jihad. They are fighting for the rights of Jammu Kashmir, I think Jamat-ud-Dawa Should be free in Pakistan.
@zafar: I agree with you Zafar. I notice that Tribune unjustly favours and tilts upon anything which supports Amercian or Indian causes(s). This is the problem with the Western Meida that they are biased through and through and never tell the whole truth and Tribune being an English paper looks like is follwoing the footsteps of Western Media, just quoting little lies spread by Western Media outlets. I will seriously recomend for every reader to read the book called "Web of Deceipt" by Mark Curtis. It will thoroughly expose Western Media stances and doctorine. I personally not a fan of Mullash but there is no proof this organisation is terrorist; they are if India said so???
And you wonder why the World has a poor opinion of you?
While liberal, secular and nationalist leaders of ANP and PPP are killed the terrorist mullahs are thriving in Pakistan. Nice way to be a member of peaceful community of nations.
@Drone-Acharya: Even if the proof stares in your faces, commonsense will not prevail as this is today's Pakistan, where only Duplicity, Deniablity, Blame Games, Rampant Corruption and last but not least Conspiracies are the only commodities that matter !!!!! Its a sad state of affairs.
The Mumbai attack was in November 2008, not 2009. Please fact check.
@Jameel some people have the tendency to continue blaming others to cover up their laziness we are one of them and so are you.
JuD is a banned organization, banned by the UN.
"Where is the proof that Osama is in Pakistan?" "Where is the proof that Hafiz is a terrorist?" "Where is the proof that..." I just hope common sense prevails. Even after all this mayhem in Pakistan the citizens are still in denial, it would appear. Good luck with that.
@zafar: RSS an extremist Hindu organisation too engages itself in social welfare activities . Do not throw cover to a force bent upon dismantling Pakistan and make the neighbours in east and west happy.
Just because America and West is saying that JuD is terrorist group, it doesnt mean its true. They were in courts when america accused them for terrorism but Pakistani courts under the free and independent judiciary last year.
While running a good news site, it doesn't mean your every story will stand on facts. Total biased article with no investigation and just a mockup kichery of words.
JuD is far far more away from these accusations. Yes if it says no to America then it is its own democratic right. I hope we being your readers could report your fake stories.
@jade:
Bombay attack was an act of charity?
Unfortunately if PML-N comes to power in next elections this man from JuD will be given highest civil award and perhaps also recommend him for Noble Prize.
You guys are so gullible I almost feel sorry for you. Almost. Because that level of gullibility almost takes conscious effort and extremely selective blindness. But, I'm not going to bother elaborating as I'm quite sure I've done so once before in the last article involving this group and the flood.
@ashok sai: why dont you put bal thackeray behind bars for preaching hatred and causing terrorism in Pakistan?
This is not a big deal, JD has got a business to do, they trade hides of animals and dead bodies of human beings. They trade skin, hides and dead bodies, regardless of the nationality, religion, faith or color. They appreciate volunteers to sell their bodies to be used for the good cause against humanity.
Jamaatud Dawa is a charity organisation, feeding thousands in Pakistan, anti Pakistan forces trying to ban all charity organisations in Pakistan to make it Somalia or Uganda etc..
You can't just declare an organization a militant one unless you have proves for that. Hafiz Saeed, has repeatedly said that he is ready to face an international trial and he is ready to appear before United Nations. There are no proves against them and if you don't have any proves you can't ban or limit anyone.
Who is ET to term JuD as terrorist group yet ? Why they speak language of Americans or crap Indian media all the time ?
Come on, not every religious organisation is a terrorist group. Do you suggest, all of us should stop practising anything related to Islam?? e..g charity through JD??
Our ruling elite use these religious extremists to perpetuate the ideology; Divide and rule
@Zafar - Of course they are doing all good things.. helping people who are in need.. all good humanitarian things... they will have to... as their organization is under microscope... it is the easiest way to become saints after training and funding militants.
@zafar:
A terrorist organisation is a terrorist organisation. If they are trying to fool people by pretending to have changed into a humanitarian organisation it’s because of US pressure to to take action against them. In fact it’s easier to collect funds for nefarious activities under the guise of humanitarian efforts.
@Shahid: so what are they???
MR, Tanveer! At least do some research before doing any pertinent story, you did not know that they have been involved in welfare deeds in Sindh and KP. you are giving a political touch in your story discarding humanitarian and socially touch...you must have mentioned what do they do with such donations.
biased journalism...is this the right title for the article. JuD has set up thousands camps for flood affectees and helping them more than UN and Government of Pakistan.
This is an even greater gift to India than MFN status. Thank you Pakistan.
How Pathetic! We deserve the situation we find ourselves today.
Politics makes strange bed-fellows.
They ain't militants!
Pakistan got its Anna Hazzare.. Well pretty close to it ;)
really unfortunate.
Fight on terrorism marches on! What a charade?! How can Pakistanis to have any kind standing in the world Community? It helps to have a third rate thug as law minister