Rally in Lahore: Fiery Shahbaz sets tone for anti-govt movement

Punjab chief minister calls for a ‘Tahrir Square’ in every city in Pakistan if the president does not resign.

Abdul Manan October 28, 2011


Shahbaz Sharif addressed the Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz (PML-N) rally in Lahore with an unequivocal demand for President Asif Ali Zardari to resign.

(Read: PML-N rally - Go Zardari go rings out in Lahore)

The Punjab chief minister said that corruption had reached unprecedented levels and the people of Pakistan were fed up – and that his party would not rest until its ongoing movement against the Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP)-led coalition government was complete.

Shahbaz was in a fiery mood as he rallied party workers. Evoking anti-government unrest in Egypt earlier this year, Shahbaz said that if Zardari failed to step down, his party would “make sure there is a Tahrir Square in every large city of the country.”

He even went as far as asking the crowd to start rationing their food, because, after Moharram, which ends in mid-December, his party would lead a nationwide protest and might have to “live on the roads.”

The PML-N, in power in Punjab but in opposition in the centre, called the protest to increase momentum for popular support for elections in 2013. Some reports have it that the party wants fresh elections before the Senate polls scheduled for March next year.

However, while PPP was the target, there are also suggestions that the rally was called suddenly to counter another rally that will be held in Lahore on Sunday by a party that is gaining tremendous traction in urban Punjab – Imran Khan’s Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf.

“Step down Zardari and hand over your money otherwise we will hang you here,” Shahbaz said, as chants of “Go Zardari, go corruption, go load shedding” echoed around the crowd.

In patches, there was a carnival feel to the protest. Workers danced to party songs, and toy lions – the PML-N’s symbol – were held aloft to cries of “Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif.”

The party’s senior leadership was in attendance, but only Shahbaz delivered a speech, addressing the gathering which stretched from General Post to Bhati Chowk, a distance of almost two kilometres.

According to party sources, the opposition leader in the National Assembly, Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan, drafted Shahbaz’s speech and encouraged the use of derogatory words against Zardari. Shahbaz was also planning on announcing a date for mass resignations from assemblies by his party members. At the eleventh hour, however, it was decided to leave this decision to Nawaz Sharif, who will outline his party’s policy on November 3 in Faisalabad.

Shahbaz laid on the accusations thick and fast against the president.

Shahbaz pointed to the “massive attendance” as proof that the nation is ready for a showdown and will only rest after “Ali Baba and his 40 thieves” have been deposed from power.

He also defended allegations of corruption from within his own provincial government: “I will not lie that corruption still exists, but I promise you that I have eliminated corruption from the top level of the Punjab government.”

Attendance figures disputed

The PML-N had tasked MNA Hamza Shahbaz Sharif with ensuring an attendance of at least 100,000 people at the rally. Despite his efforts over the past two weeks, which included addressing up to four gatherings per day, the estimated numbers were well short of this figure.

PML-N’s MPA Rana Arshad claimed that over 90,000 turned up, while journalists were divided, with figures ranging from 30,000 to 45,000.

There were also claims that the party had attracted far fewer locals than hoped for. Although the PML-N specifically targeted the citizens of Lahore, more than 50% of participants were from outside of the city, according to some intelligence agency reports.

Government officials from the city and Punjab districts also attended the rally – though some who spoke to The Express Tribune said that they essentially had to out of fear for their jobs.

Confusion among the crowd

The rally officially got going when Hamza Shahbaz arrived at the front at 5pm, three hours later than the scheduled time. After getting into a huge truck, however, Hamza failed to attract the majority of party workers, who were waiting for Shahbaz Sharif to lead the rally.

Shahbaz, though, had other ideas, and avoided the rally procession, preferring instead to arrive at his podium from back stage. Many at the rally were not even aware that Nawaz Sharif would not deliver a speech, as he was in Turkey.

Published in The Express Tribune, October 29th, 2011.


MarkH | 9 years ago | Reply

Pointing out that the current government has flaws is an understatement. But PML-N are being record breaking fools. If they oust the current government and intend to keep it a democracy(though it's a stretch to call it that now anyways), the long range effects are a big deal and out of all the politicians, Nawaz should intimately know this. The moment PPP gets removed, you will have sealed the fate of the system to never work. It means people will find it perfectly reasonable to oust everyone even over petty disagreements. Including the ones running these very rallies to oust PPP if they come into power. I haven't had all that positive opinion of MQM with those Karachi incidents factored in. But, right now, all political parties in this instance should look at MQM's reaction as it's the most intelligent thing to come out of Pakistani politics in a long time. People need to look at the whole. You're supposed to be critical and hard to please because it keeps everyone in check when the human flaws surface. But, it's not supposed to be personal. If you make it personal, you have automatically made it a matter of emotions rather than logic and reason which are the things most successful governments rely on using. Emotions are some of the most illogical things the planet has to offer and Pakistan itself is probably in the top 3 countries that have been effected by disasters caused by emotions running wild. At least make a bit of effort to learn from past mistakes from time to time. It is extremely necessary for people to be able to speak their mind in the government without fear of losing their job. They will shy away defensively from confronting important issues as a form of self preservation and their actual job description includes confronting issues. These rallies in the form of calling for removal of the governing body are actually crippling any chance of working together enough to tackle even just one of those demands that are being made. You're digging your own graves here. (metaphorically)

Sajjad | 9 years ago | Reply

Rally for change, rally for IMRAN khan...sharifs are old fashioned and ppp have no clue what's going on...a new way forward is the only way forward....PTI will show their imence support that will sweep the pml off their feet on the 30th oct.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ