Change of guard: No solution in Afghanistan minus Pakistan, says Mullen

Relation with Pakistan not where it needs to be says Obama. New JCSC General Dempsey old class mate of Kayani.

Afp September 30, 2011

WASHINGTON: There can be no solution to the conflict in Afghanistan without Pakistan, the outgoing Joint Chief’s of Staff Committee (JCSC) chairman, Admiral Mike Mullen said on Friday.

"I continue to believe that there is no solution in the region without Pakistan, and no stable future in the region without a partnership," Mullen said at a ceremony where he stood down from the post, handing it over to the incoming chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Martin Dempsey.

"I urge Marty to remember the importance of Pakistan to all of this, to try and do a better job than I did with that vexing and yet vital relationship," Mullen added in remarks.

"Our strategy is the right one. We must keep executing it."

Last week Mullen accused Pakistan of exporting violence to Afghanistan through proxies and charged that the Haqqani network, an al Qaeda-linked group, was a "veritable arm" of Pakistani intelligence.

His comments triggered new tensions with Washington's uneasy ally, Islamabad, with Pakistani leaders closing ranks against US pressure for action against the Haqqanis and refusing to be pressured into doing more in the war on terror.

Mullen also told Dempsey at the ceremony at Fort Myers in Virginia that "his biggest challenge is going to be Afghanistan" where more than 100,000 American troops are due to hand over responsibility for security to Afghan forces by the end of 2014.

The challenge would be "in seeing this critical transition through to its completion, in making sure that the security gains we have made are not squandered by the scourge of corruption or the lack of good governance that still plagues the country," Mullen said.

Mullen retires from the US military after 43 years of service.

US-Pak relation not in the right place: Obama

President Barack Obama in a radio interview said that the United States will continue to push Pakistan to do more to curb militants based in its border regions while maintaining intelligence cooperation with Islamabad.

"We've been very firm with them about needing to go after safe havens inside of Pakistan, but we've tried to also preserve the intelligence cooperation that we've obtained that's allowed us to go after al Qaeda in a very effective way," he said.

"There's no doubt that the relationship is not where it needs to be and we are going to keep on pressing them to recognize that it is in their interest -- not just ours – to make sure that extremists are not operating within their borders," added Obama.

Speaking at the ceremony, US president Barack Obama reminded US military and the world the lengths that it would go to against its enemies. "We will be determined, we will be deliberate, we will be relentless, we will be resolute in our commitment to destroy terrorist networks that aim to kill Americans," a steely Obama said after an air raid in Yemen killed Awlaqi Friday.

(Read: Radical US-born cleric Awlaqi killed: Yemen defence ministry)

General Martin Dempsey takes over from Mullen

General Martin Dempsey on Friday took over as the US military's top officer from Admiral Mike Mullen.

Dempsey has led soldiers in combat in Iraq and is keenly aware of the growing strain on the force after years of war.

An Irish-American who taught English literature to cadets at West Point, the 59-year-old graduated from the same class at the military academy as another four-star general, David Petraeus.

Until now, Petraeus - who rose to fame as commander in Iraq and had stepped down as chief in Afghanistan to take over the CIA - had largely overshadowed his former classmate.

As commander of the 1st Armored Division in Iraq in 2003-2004, Dempsey oversaw tanks and troops that fought insurgents led by Shia cleric Moqtada al-Sadr, pushing the militia out of southern cities.

In his new job as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Dempsey's two combat tours will help shape how he advises the president as the United States wraps up its mission in Iraq and begins to withdraw some of the 100,000 American troops in Afghanistan.

"One of things he'll bring to the job is current experience in the wars that we're in," said David Barno, a retired lieutenant general and senior adviser at the Center for a New American Security.

Dempsey takes over as chairman at a time of turmoil in the Arab world and growing pressure on the defense budget, with the Pentagon bracing for cuts and a possible scaled-back force.

Unlike the outgoing chairman Admiral Mike Mullen - a reserved figure with a soft-spoken manner - Dempsey is an extrovert with an irreverent sense of humour and a penchant for singing in public.

Proud of his working-class roots in New York and New Jersey, Dempsey's favourite tune is Frank Sinatra's rendition of "New York, New York," which he belts out with gusto in unabashed performances captured on YouTube.

Dempsey finds an old acquaintance in his most ‘vexing’ challenge

Apart from Petraeus, Dempsey had another prominent classmate as a younger officer.

At the US Army's staff college in the 1980s, Dempsey got to know a Pakistani officer, Ashfaq Kayani - now Pakistan's powerful army chief who has clashed with the United States in the aftermath of the raid that killed Osama bin Laden.

Dempsey is known as a thoughtful, independent-minded leader who shuns formalities and goes out of his way to hear from junior officers, said Barno, a friend and former colleague.

At Central Command, Dempsey was "known for going to the back rows of the auditorium when he was giving his morning updates, asking junior officers what they thought," Barno said.

He has "an ability to feel the soul of the organisation, to really feel what young soldiers and young leaders are going through and to connect with them in ways better than almost anyone I know," Barno told AFP.

Steeped in US strategy on the Middle East having served as a deputy and acting chief of Central Command, Dempsey likely will focus much of his time on potential threats arising from the political earthquake shaking the region.

Formerly in charge of training and doctrine, Dempsey worked to ensure the Army absorbed the lessons of a decade of counter-insurgency warfare, and warned his superiors that the long-running wars have undercut training efforts and jeopardized the health of the force.

In describing his time in Iraq, Dempsey has stressed the importance of restraint, with troops moving in carefully instead of blasting away indiscriminately.

"In terms of precision, at no time did we work our way through a city building by building or room by room," Dempsey once said in an interview.

"If we did go in on the ground, we penetrated, attacked the militia and then moved back out to minimize the risk of being seen as creating excessive collateral damage or prolonging suffering needlessly."


Tony C. | 9 years ago | Reply The Pakistan Government may not be perfect; what Government is? However, Admiral Mullen is the last person they should listen to for advise on the Afghanistan conflict. The Americans, for whatever misguided reason, decided ten years ago to attack the Taliban. Now, with the most sophisticated weapons of war, a trillion dollars later, an untold number of dead, and seriously injured, American, European, Afghan, and Pakistani people all their efforts have been to no avail. It is becoming quite obvious that the Americans will be going home, shortly or later, just the way the British and Russians did before them. I do not think anybody knows what the Taliban solution is, but U.S. Techniques are not working. They have not worked in Palestine, Korea, Vietnam, and Iraq, the long effects of Libya are not clear, and Afghanistan is a total wreck. Nobody knows how the Taliban will react to diplomacy, because nobody has tried it. American and British policy appears to be: "if in doubt drop bombs". It only antagonizes their perceived enemy even more, but they never learn. Pakistan is in a difficult position. They need to strengthen diplomatic ties with the Taliban, but this is difficult when the Americans are still about. The Taliban would be aware of Admiral Mullen's outrageous statements in regard to Pakistan's relationship with with the Taliban. The bottom line for Pakistan is that the Taliban will still be around when the Americans are long gone, whenever that is. It may difficult for Pakistan to mend fences with the Taliban, but they are probably the only ones who can do it, at least within Pakistan. The only advise anybody could give Pakistan is; "do not get too involved in the Afghan conflict, now, and when the Americans have gone".
66 | 9 years ago | Reply

People need to relax here. All he said was that to stabilize Afghanistan, Pakistan needs to be involved in a partnership. Pakistan is very weak financially to act cocky for too long. The US economy is in recession but can still function without Pakistan but the Pakistani economy is currenly highly dependent on the US. Pakistan as a nation has lost the trust of the world after Osama Bin Laden was found in Pakistan and more importantly the ease with which the whole debacle was swept under the covers. Pakistans continued denial that terrorists are not present in the country and that their is no institutional support from parts of the military and establishment will never be believed.

Pakistan is perenially living taking on more debt to meet its balance of payments and just refinance its existing debt. All along the govt. continues to spend more than it earns. The strong language will win over people domestically but in most likelihood be costly given the precarious financial situation. If Pakistan thinks it can out muscle the US it is largely mistaken. Pakistan can develop into a very strong nation but the mindset of people must change and they must accept reallity. If Pakistan wants to be accepted as a global player it will have to get rid of extremists otherwise it will be too busy wasting time and resources on petty disputes. Using extremists (who want to live in a medieval society even when peaceful) as leverage will never work in the long run and will lead to many internal problems and prevent growth.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read