Tax split to widen informal economy
Separate sales, income tax officers will weaken checks on evasion: think tank

An independent economic think tank has faulted the government's decision to separately administer sales tax and income tax collections, saying the move will weaken a critical link in checking evasion and could increase the share of the informal economy.
The Policy Research Institute of Market Economy (PRIME) on Wednesday commented on the government's decision last week to reverse a 17-year-old reform, which at the time had been dubbed a US-style reform, of merging the collection of income tax, sales tax and federal excise under the Inland Revenue Service. The 2009 move aimed to provide tax-related services under one roof and have a single taxman handle a company's sales tax and income tax matters to avoid duplication and evasion and facilitate compliant taxpayers.
However, last week, the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) separated the sales tax and federal excise duty and the income tax departments within the Inland Revenue Service, said PRIME. The FBR posted Dr Muhammad Sarmad Qureshi as the first member of sales tax and federal excise duty and Muhammad Anwar as chief of these taxes. A separate stream of officers will also be posted from next month to operationalise the new administration mode.
PRIME said the FBR justified the move by stating the new structure would address the sales tax revenue gap, noting the FBR reported a 1.7% reduction in domestic sales tax in the last fiscal year compared to a 17% increase at the import stage. However, it said the division of tax departments would carry a cost for taxpayers, as a company's turnover appears on both its income tax and sales tax forms. "A firm that hides sales to lower its sales tax is also hiding income. When one officer handles both, catching the first exposes the second. Separate officers break that link," PRIME said.
The FBR has undergone multiple phases of reforms over the past many years and took billions of dollars in loans. But nothing could succeed in increasing its tax-to-GDP ratio to 15%, which remained stagnant at 10.3% of GDP during the past two fiscal years.
PRIME said the separation of collection would increase the burden on compliant taxpayers. Manufacturers, importers and distributors already in the net will face two commissioners, two sets of notices and two interpretations of the same transaction. However, businesses outside the tax net will be immune from these effects, it added.
PRIME said the unification of administration mattered because the process reduced the incentive for non-compliant businesses to enter the tax net, according to the think tank.
However, tax authorities believed that under the unified regime, taxmen were not focusing enough on sales tax collection, which in turn contributed to a low effective sales tax rate and widespread evasion.
The institute argued that every increase in the cost of being a registered taxpayer widens the gap between the formal and informal economy. "Any business considering entering the tax net will now have to weigh the fact that it must report to two officers, which makes compliance more complicated than staying unregistered, where no compliance is required." The reform risks complicating compliance for the very businesses the FBR wants to bring into the tax net, it added.
Taxpayers already absorb frequent changes in tax rules. They now face uncertainty over who administers those rules as well, said PRIME. It said weak domestic sales tax collection is a product of fragmented value-added tax more than the organisational chart. Goods are taxed at federal and services at provincial levels, each with its own rates and returns, while exemptions and statutory regulatory orders break the chain further, said the think tank.
A harmonised value-added tax (VAT) on goods and services, with a unified lower rate and few exemptions, would do more for collection than another layer of administration, it added.
However, the World Bank has extended loans to convince both the federal and provincial governments to merge the sales tax returns of goods and services, but without a reasonable rate of success. The institute said everyone in the chain has to register, invoice and declare. Revenue leaks if one unregistered or non-compliant link breaks the chain. An FBR review revealed that the decline in domestic sales tax is concentrated in electrical energy, cotton yarn and natural gas. These are sectors where collection moves with consumption, output and energy prices, factors that lie outside the FBR's administrative reach, it added.
"Reassigning officers will not change them," said PRIME.
Chairman FBR Rashid Langrial recently conducted tests of tax officers to gauge their knowledge of the sales tax.
Reportedly, very few officers can be trusted to decide a case on their own. About 15 of 150 officers could pass sales tax orders on their own signature, and 14 of 143 could pass income tax orders, according to the results compiled by the FBR and leaked to the media.
Of the 139 officers who took both papers, only four could do so in both taxes. About half the cadre in each tax, 65 in sales tax and 72 in income tax, could prepare a notice or an order.



















COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ