Global order and deliberations at IPRI
.

Last week, we discussed the proceedings of the biennial Margalla Dialogue, themed 'Global Order in Transition', organised by the Islamabad Policy Research Institute (IPRI) on November 10-11, 2026. After a snapshot of the theme's currency and other deliberations at the NDU, this piece will delve deeper into the IPRI proceedings.
The seven key takeaways from the Dialogue and the ensuing debate were published in this space last week. Prof Dr John Mearsheimer was the first keynote speaker on Day 1. A contemporary luminary of stature, the learned professor holds a doctorate (1981) in government from Cornell University. He worked with the Brookings Institution (197980) and Harvard University (198082), and has been a professor of political science at the University of Chicago since 1982, becoming the R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor of Political Science in 1996.
Prof Mearsheimer carries deep influence from Kenneth Waltz, the author of 'neorealism' theory in IR. Classical realists like Hans Morgenthau ascribe global conflicts to political leaders' natural propensity to maximise power; neorealists (or structural realists) look for causes of war in the structure of IR. Waltz's model stipulates that states move towards alliances to contain threats, posed by rival powers, as there is absence of authority above states (supra-state anarchy). The ensuing inter-state balance of power determines the international order. Mearsheimer differs in what he calls 'Offensive Realism', specifying that due to security and survival, states resort to maximise power aggressively. States inherently are in competition to enhance power; and do not cooperate other than during temporary alliances.
Prof Mearsheimer has five core assumptions: a) international system is anarchic, having no supra-state authority to arbitrate conflicts; b) all states have some military capability; c) states find it difficult to fully ascertain intentions of other states; d) states put a premium on survival above everything else; and e) states as rational actors promote their interests. These conditions motivate states to behave aggressively toward each other, to preempt possible aggression. Hence, states enhance military power, assertively protecting their core security interests.
The distinguished professor recognises war as a 'legitimate instrument of statecraft', not always justified. He remained critical of Iraq War (200311). He suggests 'global balancing' rather than 'global hegemony' for the US foreign policy. To him, the US as a superpower should not try and dominate the globe but should selectively intervene when another power tries to dislodge it, or dominates a region, strategically important to the US. He supports the US involvement in the World War II against Nazi Germany and imperial Japan. He notably calls for withdrawal of all American forces from Europe, as no state currently threatens to dominate Europe. His best-selling book, coauthored with Stephen M Walt, The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy (2007), was a courageous attempt to unravel America's unconditional support for Israel.
During IPRI interaction online, Prof Mearsheimer posited that the Trump-Netanyahu duo had assumed that 'shock and awe' from the air would cause regime capitulation in Iran. He pointed out that airpower alone would not cause regime change, unless boots were put on ground. He remarked that the US policy was flawed, and not rescuable, as the damage done by Iran to the US prestige and power in the Middle East was colossal. In continuing hostilities, he insisted, Iran would win and the US would lose. According to him, the US system, sometimes, acts undemocratically domestically.
Analysing the post-Iran-war scenario, the professor said the US might selectively withdraw and not rebuild the bases destroyed by Iran. The GCC and KSA might seek rapprochement with Tehran, ushering in a nuclear race in the Middle East, with Iran and Saudi Arabia vying to become nuclear powers. He acknowledged the difficulty of predicting the future.
Dr Mearsheimer characterised the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks on Israel as Hamas breaking out from the 'Gaza Concentration Camp'. Israel saw an opportunity in these attacks to ethnically cleanse Palestinians through genocide and war crimes. That the US is complicit in Palestinian genocide, having vetoed six UN resolutions, in an unprecedented diplomatic support to Israel. The professor remarked that Israel would try to create a 'Greater Israel' through a lop-sided competition between 7.3 million Jews and an equal number of Palestinians. He was of the view that Israel would militarily dominate Syria, irrespective of Damascus joining the Makkah Agreement.
On the 'Great Power Competition', Dr Mearsheimer acknowledged shift from 'uni to multi-polarity'; and American pivot to East Asia (China) away from traditional Eurocentricity. This, however, according to him, will fully play out once the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East are over. The US policy was driving Russia towards China, and that Russia seems the likely winner in Ukraine. Reverting to his 'Offensive Realism' theory, the learned professor believes that two rival hegemons cannot co-exist, therefore America will do anything it can to stop China from dislodging it. He disagreed with American retrenchment, pointing out that America was incapable of retiring from the world.
On losing war with Iran, Mersheimer argued that one loss does not prevent a superpower from winning the next war, as America won the Cold War under the shadows of Vietnam. Superpowers can and do lose one odd war, like the Soviet Union in Afghanistan. To him, possessing power and projecting power are different things. He surmised that US is 'addicted' to war, unlike China which fought the last war in 1979 (Sino-Vietnam).
On Pakistan's strategic environment, he does not see the current changes in the global realignment bringing any significant implications for Pakistan or its relations with India, describing the two countries as destined rivals. However, evolution of the Sino-US competition, he concluded, would impact Pakistan's options from the present state of 'balancing' relations with Washington and Beijing to potentially taking sides. Currently Pakistan remains shielded from the US pressure due to Washington's commitment in wars, and its strategic overstretch. He notes that India is not and will not be a Great Power because of its comparative poverty. Besides a large human resource (population), wealth creation is another essential pre-requisite, among other things, to become a Great Power. Pakistan should, therefore, endeavour to create wealth.
On Indo-US relations, he believes India matters to America for challenging China militarily in the mountains, and through maritime power in the Indo-Pacific Region; and the US has interest in keeping good relations with both India and Pakistan. (Continued)














COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ