TODAY’S PAPER | November 19, 2026 | EPAPER

'Come to your senses': Bilawal advises govt to 'calm down' and hold a 'debate you started' on provinces

Bilawal responds to criticism from Defence Minister Khawaja Asif


Web Desk November 18, 2026 6 min read
A visual of Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari in a interview to a private news programme. SCREENGRAB

Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari responded on Wednesday after a day's worth of volley from government officials over his critical remarks and advised them to "calm down" and to proceed forward with the "debate you started" on the issue of more provinces and a referendum to solve the deadlock.

The remarks come after Defence Minister Khawaja Asif hit back at Bilawal earlier in the day over his criticism of the government and calls for a "political reset", questioning his moral standing to lecture others while pointing to the PPP's 18-year rule in Sindh. Minister of State for Interior Talal Chaudhry and Health Minister Mustafa Kamal also criticised Bilawal over his remarks.

A day earlier, Bilawal had called for a "political reset' to restore public confidence in state institutions, urging the government to revive dialogue with opposition parties, including the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), and end political victimisation.

Read: Bilawal stirs political storm with no-holds-barred speech

The PPP scion, speaking in a private television channel talk show, "Faisla Aap Ka", reiterated that the economic woes brought about by regional conflicts had dealt a crushing blow to the masses, resulting in “economic collapse”.

Bilawal stated: "We should calm down, and you started a debate, and now you should have the courage to continue it. This debate has not happened in parliament yet, and you decided to hold this debate in front of businessmen. Pakistan is not so weak as a society that unilateral debates take place which everyone else has to accept."

“If someone is calling for a reset, I have a right to give my perspective regarding it,” he stated, outlining that he put forth his views at yesterday’s conference about the nature of the proposed change.

“I was clarifying whether the proposed reset needs to be political, apolitical, democratic or undemocratic in nature.”

The PPP leader said he never backed down from his stance or viewpoint, explaining that he centred his conversation around the plight of the people.

“The elite are oblivious to the dilemma faced by the people of Pakistan in the face of this economic catastrophe. In light of these circumstances, all the political parties should put aside their differences and deliberate on ways to fix the system to give reprieve to the masses,” he remarked.

“We have to restore the confidence [of the people] in our institutions,” he added.

When probed on the need to give such a hard-hitting statement against the government, although he himself is part of the system and has active governments in Sindh, Balochistan and Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa, the PPP scion said, “I do have governments running the said provinces, and I acknowledge being a stakeholder in the system. These are reasons to listen to me. These are not reasons to discard what I am saying.”

Outlining his responsibility as a major stakeholder, he said he had proposed solutions which could be set aside, but at least he deserved to be listened to.

“People should have the heart and the courage to bear and listen to the truth,” he stressed.

Read more: 'Are your hands clean?': Khawaja Asif hits back at Bilawal over govt criticism

“You have observed the current geopolitical scene; at how many more fronts can they [government] lead a war?”

He said that he was proud that Pakistan won the war against India, however, he cautioned that it would be naïve to believe that the eastern neighbour had given up its nefarious designs to hurt the country.

The PPP stalwart said the country was “almost at war” with Afghanistan, “heavily involved with Iran” during the ongoing conflict, battling Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) and Balochistan Liberation Army (BLA) inflicted terrorism as well.

“Then the government decided to fight with Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI), asserted its will to confront Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI) and now that I have spoken the truth, they might as well decide to go to war with me too,” Bilawal remarked, lampooning the government’s approach.

He asked: if the state decided to "fight everyone", who would take the people out of their current misery and economic crisis?

The PPP chairman quipped that people were accustomed to hearing "half-truths" rather than the complete truth. "Yesterday, I probably told a little too much truth, and it seems that it has not been digested."

Bilawal further added that politicians lacked the courage to hear the truth: "There should be enough courage in our society to allow everyone to express their opinion. Everyone has the right to give their views. The reaction from yesterday is further proof that Pakistan's politicians do not have the courage to hear the truth."

He underscored that if politicians did not have the courage to listen to him, "then what will happen to ordinary Pakistanis who have no access to those in power?"

Bilawal said that despite being such a "major stakeholder", no one had discussed the matter of new provinces with him, stating: "The debate began in the summer, and we are now approaching the end of the year. Since then, neither a federal minister, the prime minister, nor any political or other stakeholder has sat down with the President of Pakistan or me to explain why they want to create new provinces or how they intend to do it."

"If someone is going to say that the system has collapsed, does that mean only the PCB chairman has the right to speak about it and explain how and why the system collapsed?", he inquired in an apparent reference to Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi.

Bilawal further asked that if provinces were to be divided, "does that mean only the PCB has the right to speak on the matter while I should remain silent and go home?"

While defending his earlier statement, he said: "Did I ask people to come out and protest or to resist? I suggested that there was a need for a political reset and a democratic reset so that politicians could stop fighting among themselves and instead work together to help the people overcome their difficulties."

Bilawal further highlighted that the government was unwilling to tolerate disagreement. "It cannot even tolerate criticism from Maulana Fazlur Rehman, who has been its longstanding political ally, is a member of Parliament and sits on the opposition benches. He has every right to criticise the government, and it is his responsibility to do so."

He stressed that if only one opinion was "allowed to exist" in society, then any decision that was taken would not incorporate the input of all stakeholders, adding that "democracy requires the courage to tolerate and listen to disagreement."

The PPP chairman also issued a warning that if Sindh was divided through the use of force and coercion, he would not support such a move, adding that there would be "consequences".

"Against my wishes, the law and order situation in the province could deteriorate to such an extent that the resulting unrest and violence would be extremely difficult to contain," Bilawal remarked.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ