TODAY’S PAPER | November 17, 2026 | EPAPER

PTI fails to secure relief from constitutional court

PTI fails to secure relief from constitutional court


Hasnaat Malik November 17, 2026 3 min read
The Federal Constitutional Court building. Photo: File

ISLAMABAD:

Imran Khan's PTI once again failed to get any relief from the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) which on Monday allowed the Peshawar High Court (PHC) to entertain all writ petitions except those related to K-P emergency and detention of PTI workers under the MPO.

The FCC on November 5 suspended proceedings before the PHC in cases instituted under Article 199 of the Constitution on or after October 12, the day the federal government imposed emergency and governor's rule in the K-P.

After the emergency, authorities deployed armed forces in K-P in aid of civil power while also detaining hundreds of PTI workers and leaders under the MPO—the Maintenance of Public Order Ordinance.

In the wake of the FCC order, the PHC refused to entertain all writ petitions filed under Article 199 of Constitution. Superior bars especially Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa Bar Council (KPBA) which is led by pro-government group strongly reacted to the move and started condemning the FCC order.

Subsequently, the provincial bar approached the FCC seeking amendment to its November 5 order.

An FCC division bench, comprising Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq, on Monday took up the bar's petition and amended its November 5 order allowing PHC to entertain all writ petitions except those filed against imposition of governor rule, emergency and MPO.

It also allowed the KPBA to become a party in this case.

PTI Chairman Barrister Gohar Ali Khan and Sardar Latif Khosa were also present during the hearing. However they did not succeed to get any kind of relief from the FCC. During the hearing, Gohar requested the FCC to allow the PHC to hear petitions challenging emergency and governor's rule.

However, the FCC ignored his plea and adjourned the hearing for an indefinite period.

Talking to the media after the hearing, Gohar expressed disappointment at the FCC decision. He said they had approached the court with a request to allow the PHC to decide the pending petitions so that it could first determine the questions of their maintainability and jurisdiction.

He said the bail applications of other individuals detained under the MPO should also be heard. Whenever a person's liberty is deprived under any law, they must have a substantive right to seek justice and a judicial hearing, he added.

"Keeping people in jail while depriving them of access to a judicial forum for seeking justice amounts to a violation of fundamental rights," he said. Gohar again urged the FCC to hear these matters at the earliest and provide justice to the affected individuals.

Some lawyers believe that usually a court itself decides its jurisdiction.

Earlier, K-P authorities in their report requested the FCC to maintain its November 5, restraining the PHC to entertain all kind of writ petitions filed under Article 199 of the Constitution.

K-P advocate general submitted that the ground security assessment revealed that threat vectors, terrorist syndicates, and internal disturbances remain fluid, volatile, and deeply interconnected across all districts of K-P

"The underlying security threats that necessitated the invocation of emergency powers and military deployment have not yet been sufficiently eradicated or mitigated," the report said.

The K-P authorities stated that in view of the persistent security environment and the severe public safety risks associated with any premature vacuum, they have formally resolved and reported that the continued deployment of the armed forces in aid of civil power remains strictly indispensable across the entire province of K-P without exception.

"Consequently, the Provincial Government does not intend the withdrawal or de-notification of Armed Forces from any district or area at this juncture," the report added.

Since the establishment of the FCC through 27th Constitutional Amendment, the PTI is struggling to get substantive relief from the superior courts.

The party faced first setback when the present government transferred three judges from different high courts to the Islamabad High Court (IHC). Subsequently, one a transferred judge became the IHC chief justice and later the PTI did not get substantive relief from the high court.

When the Supreme Court directed the government to shift Imran Khan to Al-Shifa International Hospital for medical treatment on August 18, the FCC became active and summoned record of that case.

When the PHC started releasing PTI workers detained under MPO, once again the FCC restrained the high court to entertain writ petitions filed under Article 199 of constitution.

COMMENTS

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ