Despite the fact that they probably will not be given control of the property, the Hindu community in Peshawar rejoiced at the Peshawar High Court’s (PHC) orders to reopen a 160-year-old Hindu temple.
On September 15, after hearing a Hindu woman Phool Vatte’s plea, a two-member bench of the PHC directed the authorities to open up the historic Goraknath Temple, situated in the centre of the city’s archeological complex of Gor Kattri, for worship. The court also directed authorities to ensure security arrangements at the place of worship, adding that the control of the property would remain with the government.
However, nearly a week after the PHC’s orders, the shrine which has remained closed since partition is yet to be opened.
The temple belonged to Vatte’s husband Pandit Kambhu Ram, who at the time of partition sent an application to the settlement commissioner saying he would not shift to India and would stay in Pakistan and that his land should not be made waqf property, following which an order was issued by the settlement department, Vatte’s attorney Pervez Iqbal told The Express Tribune.
However, he said that the police later asked Vatte for permission to use the temple and its adjacent building for storing explosives, which she granted but had to struggle to regain its possession in 2002. Soon after, the police detained her son Kaka Ram and the Peshawar Development Authority (PDA) locked up the premises.
Pervez alleged that the police took away statues worth millions of rupees, a table estimated to be around Rs10.5 million and gold embellishments from the dome. He said that in 2003 they moved the Peshawar High Court with a petition which was rejected, after which they turned to civil court, where their case was rejected once again and they were told to approach the Evacuee Property Board (EVP). They were unable to go to the EVP due to financial constraints.
“Instead, what we did was, we wrote an application to the Supreme Court chief justice, the PHC chief justice and other functionaries which was when the PHC chief justice turned the application into a petition on a suo motu and allowed for worship to be carried out at the temple,” Pervez said.
The temple is an archeological site and hence, its control cannot be handed over to a private party, Dr Abdul Samad, consultant to the K-P Department of Archeology told The Express Tribune. The Hindu community can perform their worship anytime. However, the keys will not be handed over to them, he added.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 22nd, 2011.
COMMENTS (14)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
@Dilip j. bhatt: thats an economic matter a politition illegaly occupied a plaza in kasur worth 2 crore no body did anything
@geeko:
Maybe you should. And as you are converting everything to its original state, you too should convert to Hinduism, which was the original religion of your forefathers.
You won't see this piece of news in the Indian media.
We should convert it into a Buddhist temple, as it was before, like Indian Hindus do in India.
hummmm thats ok
As the name of article states, this temple is only 160 years old. This place is actually a Buddhist holy site as stated in Tuzk-e-Babri (Memoir of Emperor Babur) and only converted to Hindu Temple during sikh reign.
I appreciate PHC decision for showing empathy and valuing sentiments of hindu community(minority).........but still several religious issues have been cropping up these days in pak.There shouldnt be biasing based on relegion....Sad to read about poor plight of sikhs in pakistan. (http://tribune.com.pk/story/257550/sikh-leader-under-threat-in-lahore/) It's really good on part of pak authorities(Judiciary) that they are realising sensitivity of the issue
Very scary for the local Hindu community - they will be targeted just like the Sikhs in Lahore.
I believe that hindus should be allowed to use this temple but they should never be allowed to "repair " the historic antique structure.
Hindu "leaders" managed to get grants from the politicians and they have destroyed the originality and antiquity of the historic mandir of Gandian Mansehra, which was centuries old and which contains the second biggest Shiv Ling of the Sub Continent.
Repairs should be done by the archaeology department as per requirments of the antiquities act of 1975.
Appreciate PHC Order!
Sad that every issue in Pakistan has to be settled only through Supreme Court. Imagine what will happen if Supreme Court itself becomes corrupt or dysfunctional.
Good for her! Should admire her perseverance. Hope it stays open.