This attack asks a number of questions. First of all, what level of security checks are in place at the exit and entry points of Karachi? I believe the authorities will not be able to answer this question because if you have entered Karachi by road, you would know that there are hardly any measures taken to ensure that the vehicles are properly scanned for explosives, arms, ammunition or other illegal materials. If there is a proper checking mechanism on the exit and entry points of the city, it will be very difficult for anyone to bring hundreds of kilogrammes of explosives in Karachi, unless of course, there is internal involvement, which also cannot be ruled out.
Secondly, how does the security mechanism work inside the city? We only see poor people on bikes and cars being stopped and harassed by the police. Lately, while coming back from a friend’s house, I was stopped on Khayaban-e-Ittehad in Defence (not far from the site of the blast) and the police just needed a reason to harass us. My friend said, “You should get a Prado for yourself now, no one would have the courage to stop you”. And this is true. No one stops a four-wheeler, as they are largely being used by the authorities themselves or the rich and the powerful. This biasness allows for loopholes within the security process. This means the terrorists can employ big and fancy vehicles which will never be stopped for checking and anyone can use such a vehicle for terrorist attacks.
Lastly, what level of intelligence do we have and what is the actual number of crackdowns in a city plagued by bomb blasts, targeted killing of individuals and street crime? How many times do we hear of a successful crackdown where the authorities end up recovering a large number of explosives or ammunition? Unless the intelligence is provided by the agencies to the police and other law-enforcement agencies, the whereabouts of these terrorists will never be discovered and the sprawling metropolis that Karachi is will continue to harbour terrorists.
The police force is feeble because the government hasn’t invested in their training and development. We have a large defence budget; we should also have a considerable budget for the police, Rangers and Frontier Corps so they work more efficiently and take interest in their job, instead of harassing civilians for an extra buck or two.
What concrete steps has the government taken to enforce and elevate security measures in the city and to better equip these agencies? Unless we have a robust security mechanism in place, Karachiites will keep on waking up to more such blasts.
Published in The Express Tribune, September 22nd, 2011.
COMMENTS (7)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
I think it is a four-wheeler/four-wheel drive?
Poor editorial standards:
1) "No one stops a four-wheeler" - all cars have 4 wheels the phrase you are looking is "4x4"
2) There is no such word as "biasness", the correct usage is "bias"
Policemen also died in that attack, you should have at least taken that into consideration before mocking our police force.
The problem lies with these influential people and our government, not a policeman earning 3000 odd Rs. I'm sure if you're hurled with abuse and could risk losing your job you wouldn't bother stopping these people either.
If you really want to see the 'effectiveness' of our police-force try streets adjacent to Bilalawal House.
I wonder if the author and his neighbours pay their fair amount of property taxes to the city of Karachi, or is it limited to the payments to the Defence Housing organization to maintain the society for a previliged area than the expectations for the City of Karachi to provide the level of security that the previliged have expectations of would be unfair.
Could someone write something explaining how the property tax system works in Pakistan and if it is fairly based on property values.