‘Phillies Karen’ seen in multiple verbal confrontations after viral home-run ball dispute

Phillies Karen sparked controversy after clashing with fans over home run ball.

The woman dubbed “Phillies Karen,” who went viral after a dispute with a father and son over a home-run ball during Friday’s Miami Marlins and Philadelphia Phillies game, has since been captured in at least two additional confrontations with other fans.

The Phillies ‘Karen’ was captured on camera getting in another man’s face for heckling her after she demanded the home run ball from a child.

The woman marched over to a man in an Eagles jersey and got in his face before she appeared to flip off the entire section.

Completely… pic.twitter.com/FvL7KGn2Jh

— Collin Rugg (@CollinRugg) September 6, 2025

A 50-second video shared on X by Collin Rugg showed the woman engaging with spectators following the initial altercation. In the clip, she approached a man who heckled her, confronted another fan wearing an Eagles jersey, and eventually appeared to make an obscene gesture toward an entire section of the crowd. Rugg described her behavior online as “completely unhinged.”

The situation grew more complicated when internet users misidentified the woman as Cheryl Richardson-Wagner, a Boston Red Sox fan. Richardson-Wagner took to Facebook on Saturday to clear her name, writing: “Ok everyone. I’m NOT the crazy Philly Mom (but I sure would love to be as thin as she is and move as fast)… and I’m a Red Sox fan.”

The viral moment began when “Phillies Karen” confronted a father seated nearby after his 10-year-old son retrieved a ball that had landed close to her. The woman argued the man had pulled the ball away from her after crossing multiple rows of seats, while she insisted it was within her reach.

Footage of the incident quickly spread online, sparking widespread criticism of the woman’s actions. Social media users overwhelmingly sided with the father and child, portraying the woman as aggressive and unsportsmanlike.

While her real identity remains unconfirmed, “Phillies Karen” continues to trend as new clips surface, extending the public debate over fan etiquette at Major League Baseball games.