HRCP slams discriminatory ban on Ismaili butchers in Chitral, warns of threat to pluralism

Commission notes that the region has long been admired for its tradition of inter-communal harmony


Asif Mehmood May 23, 2025

Listen to article

The Human Rights Commission of Pakistan (HRCP) has voiced serious concern over what it describes as sectarian discrimination in Chitral, following a decision by the local administration in Garam Chashma to prohibit Ismaili butchers from supplying meat in the area.

In a strongly worded statement issued on Thursday, the HRCP condemned the move as a violation of the constitutional principle of equal economic opportunity for all citizens, regardless of sectarian affiliation.

The commission noted that the region has long been admired for its tradition of inter-communal harmony and warned that such one-sided measures risk inflaming sectarian tensions and inciting violence.

"Undermining fundamental rights due to religious pressure sets a dangerous precedent," the HRCP said.

"This threatens not only the livelihoods of a marginalised community but also the very fabric of pluralism in Pakistan."

The rights watchdog called on the district administration to fulfill its constitutional duty to treat all citizens equally and to ensure that administrative decisions are based on law and fairness, not appeasement.

Any failure to act impartially, the HRCP warned, could deepen existing divisions and further erode public confidence in the rule of law.

The statement comes amid growing concern from civil society over increasing intolerance and discriminatory practices targeting religious and sectarian minorities in various parts of the country.

COMMENTS (3)

Shamsuddin Shah | 2 weeks ago | Reply Human Rights Commission Supreme Court of Pakistan is requested to take notice of this unlawful act of district administration and take explation from DC Chitral who can not tolerate the pressure of few extremists and imposes ban on Ismaili butchers.
Dr Mir Baiz Khan | 2 weeks ago | Reply It is reassuring that the HRCP has taken a clear stand against the discrimination by the local administration in the Garam Chashma valley in Chitral prohibiting Ismaili butchers from supplying meat to the local population. This unfair and irresponsible behaviour of the administration resolves nothing except aggravating the situation and damaging the communal harmony. Ismailis in Garam Chashma valley like Ismailis globally believe in peaceful coexistence with all people. In the valley the Sunni population is and has always been very small and was never discriminated against and lived in peace and harmony unfortunately for the past few decades they have been bullying the Ismailis on the strength of their overall majority in Chitral. The authorities must protect their rightful interests and should not come under the pressure of the troublemakers.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ