Donald Trump jokes about being next pope ahead of conclave; Here's why it's not canonically possible
Photo: Reuters
U.S. President Donald Trump drew headlines on April 29, 2025, when he joked with reporters outside the White House that becoming pope would be his “number one choice.” The comment followed the death of Pope Francis at age 88 due to a stroke, and came as the Catholic Church prepares for its upcoming papal conclave.
When asked about the next pope, Trump declined to name a preferred candidate but described Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York as “very good.” Senator Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) continued the humour online, posting on X: "Watching for white smoke… Trump MMXXVIII!”
I was excited to hear that President Trump is open to the idea of being the next Pope. This would truly be a dark horse candidate, but I would ask the papal conclave and Catholic faithful to keep an open mind about this possibility!
The first Pope-U.S. President combination has… pic.twitter.com/MM9vE5UvzbWhile clearly intended in jest, the idea sparked discussion about what it takes to become pope
Catholic canon law stipulates that only a baptised male Catholic is eligible to become pope. In practice, the role is almost always filled by a cardinal under the age of 80, elected by the College of Cardinals during a conclave. If the elected person is not already a bishop, he must be ordained immediately. The position also presumes deep theological training, active ministry, and strict adherence to Church doctrine..
While raised Presbyterian, Donald Trump has since stated he is a non-denominational Christian. He has never been part of Catholic clergy, nor is he involved in Church governance.
The papal conclave to elect the next pope begins on 7 May 2025, with 135 eligible cardinal electors expected to attend. No American has ever been elected pope, and Cardinal Dolan is not viewed as a leading contender.