India's growing Sikh problem

Modi's 'Hindutva' policies spark Sikh separatism, leading to Trudeau's bombshell on Nijjar's killing.

Listen to article

The Indian government headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi is not willing to concede that the Sikh agitation inside the country as well as outside is a reaction to the rise of extremist Hinduism in India. Modi has adopted 'Hindutva', the Hindu mode of governance as the governing philosophy of the nation he leads.

Under Modi's prodding, India has gone back centuries before the time the country was invaded first by Muslims who came crossing the mountain ranges in the north and established Islam in India.

They were followed some centuries later by the British who crossed the oceans as traders but then established their dominion over India.

Prime Minister Modi has now governed the country for more than ten years and will be in office for at least another five years. He wants to erase this history and bring back Hinduism to India. He wants to change the name of his country from India to Bharat.

This is the context in which he sees the activities of Sikh separatists as mostly gang-related, a chaotic mix of extraction, trafficking in drugs and score settling.

According to one interpretation by a group of journalists writing for The New York Times, the Sikh "criminal masterminds often operating from abroad, take advantage of economic desperation in a state where farmers are crushed by rising debt and many youths lack employment or direction - problems compounded by a feeling of political alienation in minority Sikh communities." The reference is to the state of Punjab on the border of Pakistan which used to be called the "bread basket of India".

Resentment against the rise of Hindu extremism was expressed in early 2023 by Amritpal Singh, a young Sikh who walked around Punjab portraying himself as the new prophet of Khalistan.

When his supporters attacked a police station to free one of their detained accomplices, authorities ordered Singh's arrest. A new prophet of Sikh grievances was thus born. But there are some in the Sikh leadership that had good working relationship with the members of the ruling Hindu party.

Among them was Amrinder Singh who was the chief minister of Punjab in 2018. He met Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and gave him a list of 10 to 12 Sikh Canadians whom he labeled "mischief makers".

He had publicly declared several of Trudeau's cabinet ministers as Khalistan sympathisers, including Canada's first Sikh defense minister, Harjit Sajjan, who was a member of the delegation that Trudeau had brought with him on that Indian visit.

The Sikh problem came to the attention of the world in a way that India and its prime minister would have least expected. The Canadian prime minister in a speech on September 17, 2024 at the Canadian national assembly made an allegation that proved to be a bombshell.

The prime minister said that the Indian government may have been behind the assassination of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, 45, who had migrated to Canada and acquired Canadian citizenship. He was born in the city of Jullundur in north Punjab. He married in Canada and had two sons.

Nijjar had become active in the 770,000 Sikh Canadian diaspora and was leading those in his community who were working for the session of the Indian state of Punjab and become an independent country to be called Khalistan.

In a complaint recorded in 2018, India's premier investigative agency that goes under the acronym RAW - Research and Analysis Wing of the Ministry of External Affairs - accused him of "conspiracy and planning to carry out a major terrorist attack in India".

It also alleged that he planned to violently attack gatherings of the nationalist right-wing organisation Rastriya Swayamsevak Sangh, the RSS, which is the basis of support for India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

Trudeau's speech followed weeks of behind-the-scenes contacts with allied nations over the killing alleged to have been carried out by two men who were reported to belong to RAW. Nijjar was visiting Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara where he was the president.

The temple was located in the city of Surrey in the Canadian province of British Colombia. After attending a meeting in the temple, Nijjar walked to his car parked in the parking lot and started his drive home when his way was blocked by a car that had two hooded men who had been waiting for him.

They jumped out of the car and fired sixty bullets at Nijjar who was killed instantly.

The Canadian government expelled an Indian diplomat identified as the senior intelligence officer at the Indian embassy in Canada. While not openly accused of having orchestrated Nijjar's assassination, the Trudeau administration was clearly pointing its finger at India.

These moves sent relations between the two countries tumbling toward their lowest point. India reacted by expelling a Canadian official from the embassy in New Delhi. Weeks before the statement by Trudeau, he had asked its Western allies including Washington to publicly condemn the killing, but the requests were turned down.

The Canadian request landed Washington with a tricky problem. "We have been in close contact with our Canadian colleagues," a senior Statement Department official said on September 19 in a press briefing. "We're quite concerned about the allegations. We think it is important there is a full and open investigation, and we would urge the Indian government to cooperate with the investigation."

To put the Nijjar case in the right context, it would be useful to address, albeit briefly, the history of Sikhs in India and the world outside. With a population numbering between 25 and 30 million, Sikhism is the world's fifth largest religion.

The community is made up of an ethnoreligious group that was formed in the late 15th century in the province of Punjab by Guru Nanak, the first of a series of 'gurus'. The term Sikh has its origin in the Sanskrit word 'sisya' which means a disciple or student. Strict followers of the religion must always have uncut hair covered by a turban. Guru Nanak was succeeded by nine gurus.

Their selection often led to bitter disputes in the community. To prevent that from happening repeatedly, the community decided to make Granth Sahib, the sacred scripture of Sikhism, as the tenth guru who would rule in perpetuity.