Analysts sceptical of PPP, PML-N ‘impractical’ manifestos

Observers argue manifestos lack substance and fail to address pressing realities of Pakistan

The electoral manifestos recently unveiled by Pakistan Muslim League Nawaz (PML-N) and Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) just two weeks ahead of the general elections have left political analysts and observers unconvinced.

Critics argue that both parties' manifestos lack substance and fail to address the pressing realities of Pakistan, adding that they rely on promises without offering concrete implementation plans.

Chief Editor of The Express Tribune, Naveed Hussain, giving his insight on Express News’ talk show "Experts", moderated by Dua Jamil, expressed disappointment with the manifesto of both parties deeming them impractical.

In a satirical tone, Hussain remarked about the PML-N's electoral manifesto, saying that it is so comprehensive and detailed that it may prove challenging to read within the limited time left before the elections.

ن لیگ کا منشور قابل عمل یا الفاظ کا گورکھ دھندہ ؟ تجزیہ کار نوید حسین کا اہم تجزیہ@MuhammadIlyaspk @RanaAamirilyas @navidjourno @Duaakanwal1 @itsmeayazkhan @s_faisalhussain pic.twitter.com/N7hSddkxIX

— Experts (@express_experts) January 27, 2024

“We should not forget that before the 2018 elections, a more detailed and comprehensive manifesto was also given by PTI, which later proved futile,” he added.

Hussain also scrutinised the points of the manifesto concerning the willingness to amend the Constitution and foster friendship with arch-rival India. He highlighted the need for a two-thirds majority for constitutional amendments, expressing scepticism by stating, "I don't even see that any party will be able to get even a simple majority."

While citing the statement made by Chief of Army Staff (COAS) General Syed Asim Munir, in which he ruled out the possibility of a better relationship with India, Hussain asserted that friendship with the neighbouring country is not possible in present regional scenario.

Regarding PPP's manifesto, Hussain believes it is attractive on paper for people but not workable, highlighting the need for a stable economy before any significant achievements can be made.

Group Editor Express News Ayaz Khan, concurring with Hussain, raised serious questions about PML-N's claims made in the manifesto, particularly regarding the ambitious goal of providing 10 million jobs in five years.

 

ن لیگ نے اپنے منشور پر عملدر آمد کرنے کے لیے کیاپلاننگ کرلی؟ سنیے تجزیہ کار عامر الیاس رانا نے بتادیا@MuhammadIlyaspk @RanaAamirilyas @navidjourno @Duaakanwal1 @itsmeayazkhan @s_faisalhussain pic.twitter.com/z5DEShimCg

— Experts (@express_experts) January 27, 2024

Khan also criticised the party's stance on the agriculture sector, accusing Nawaz Sharif of contributing to its destruction during his previous tenure.

He expressed disappointment with the policies of former finance minister Ishaq Dar, suggesting that his return would not lead to an economic revival.

Comparing PPP's manifesto to PML-N's, Khan applauded the introduction of the hari (farmer), mazdoor (labourer), and youth cards. He believes that these cards, similar to the health cards issued during Imran Khan's tenure, are attracting more people.

Express News Karachi's Bureau Chief, Faisal Hussain, countered Khan's stance for the implementation of PPP's proposed cards. He emphasised the importance of spending funds on education, health, technical skills, and the establishment of factories to uplift the nation.

سیاسی حکومتیں عوام کو کیسے "فقیر" بناتی ہیں؟ تجزیہ کار فیصل حسین نے بتادیا@MuhammadIlyaspk @RanaAamirilyas@navidjourno @Duaakanwal1 @itsmeayazkhan @s_faisalhussain pic.twitter.com/XdmMzueYA3

— Experts (@express_experts) January 27, 2024

Faisal criticised political parties for neglecting substantial investment in national development, prioritising fame over progress. He expressed doubt about the feasibility of their manifestos, citing insufficient resources to fulfil their promises.

Bureau Chief of Express News Islamabad, Amir Ilyas Rana, holds a contrary opinion to his colleagues, expressing confidence in the PML-N manifesto and believing it will bring visible change to the country.

 

ن لیگ کا ایک کروڑ نوکریاں دینے کا دعویٰ ، تجزیہ کار ایاز خان نے بڑے سوال اٹھادیے@MuhammadIlyaspk @RanaAamirilyas @navidjourno @Duaakanwal1 @itsmeayazkhan @s_faisalhussain pic.twitter.com/r6rK9oIAZp

— Experts (@express_experts) January 27, 2024

Rana cited the achievements made by PML-N during its previous tenure and criticised the performance of PTI, claiming it failed to implement its manifesto.

Conversely, he notes PPP's historical failure to enact its manifestos, regardless of their content be it was roti (bread), kapra (cloth), makan (house) based manifesto or subsequent ones.

Senior journalist and analyst Khalid Qayum highlighted the economy as the top issue and questioned how both parties plan to reduce inflation by 10% in one year amid significant circular debts in the energy and gas sectors.

 

ن لیگ اور پیپلزپارٹی کے منشور میں سب سے اہم کیا ہے، سنیے تجزیہ کار خالد قیوم سے@MuhammadIlyaspk @RanaAamirilyas @navidjourno @Duaakanwal1 @itsmeayazkhan @s_faisalhussain pic.twitter.com/a6utmvAXAD

— Experts (@express_experts) January 27, 2024

Qayum doubts the extent of relief that will be offered amid the formidable economic challenges engulfing the country.