Sarfraz Shah case: Defence rests case following driver’s testimony

The court will hear the final arguments from both sides on Monday.

Zeeshan Mujahid August 07, 2011


Two months ago, six Rangers personnel were caught on camera shooting a man in Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park and apparently allowing him to bleed to death. On Monday, all the talking will be over as the lawyers will present their final arguments.

Judge Bashir Ahmed Khoso, Anti Terrorism Court (ATC-I) Karachi division, will hear the prosecution and defence’s final arguments in the Sarfraz Shah murder case on Monday after defence closed its case on Saturday.

The defence examined its fourth and final witness - the Chhipa Ambulance driver, Muhammad Saleem. The witness told the court that he has been a volunteer driver for three years. While he was unable to recall the exact date, he remembered the details of the day clearly. At about 15:45 pm, he was summoned to Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park, Boat Basin, Clifton via a message on his wireless set. He reached the site within the next five minutes. Saleem told the court that he saw three or four Rangers personnel and a young man lying on the ground, critically injured. “I took out the stretcher and transported the injured into the ambulance,” he testified. “Two of the Rangers men accompanied me to Jinnah Post Graduate Medical Centre where the injured man was received for treatment and I left.”

Special Public Prosecutor Muhammad Khan Buriro passed up the opportunity to cross-examine the witness and the defence asked the court to close their case.

The court adjourned further proceedings and asked the prosecution and defence lawyers to submit their final arguments till 1 pm on Monday after which the judgment is likely to be reserved.

Once again, the defence may raise the issue of jurisdiction in a last-ditch attempt to have the case moved from the ATC to a sessions court. A week ago, the Sindh High Court (SHC) put its foot down against transferring the case to an ordinary court, despite the defence’s insistence that there was no ‘terrorism’ caused by the incident. Syed Sarfraz Shah was killed on June 8 after he was turned over to the Rangers by Afsar Khan who was also implicated in the case. The entire episode was filmed by an Awaz TV channel cameraman. The prosecution feels that the clip, that spread like wildfire, left people shocked and terrorised putting the case in an ATC’s jurisdiction.

Published in The Express Tribune, August 7th, 2011.


Saiful Haq | 11 years ago | Reply

The murder of this unarmed youth is nothing but a "Fake Encounter Killing".Today an hon'ble Supreme Court in India has said Police personnel involved in fake encounter killings should be awarded death sentence and hanged.A bench of justices Markandeya Katju and C K Prasad said that police personnel as custodians of law are expected to protect people and not eliminate them as contract killers.“Fake encounter killings by cops are nothing but cold blooded brutal murder which should be treated as the rarest of rare offence and police personnel responsible for it should be awarded death sentence. They should be hanged,” Justice Katju, heading the bench, said.The killing of Sarfaraz Shah, which was indeed very shocking should also be treated on the same lines and the guilty should deserve nothing less than death penalty.

Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

Most Read