All six men, including the Abdullah Shah Ghazi Rangers personnel, charged with killing an unarmed 22-year-old in broad daylight, pleaded innocence in court on Thursday, telling the judge that they had been falsely implicated.
They said that neither were they terrorists nor had they murdered anyone. They were on official duty at the time and had performed their duty, staying within the parameters of the law.
On June 8, the young victim, Sarfraz Shah, was shot in Clifton’s Shaheed Benazir Bhutto Park. The incident, captured on tape by a SAMAA TV crew, showed what appeared to be the young man pleading to be taken to a hospital. The footage was aired across Pakistan, sparking an outcry. The case is being heard in Anti-Terrorism Court (I) headed by Judge Bashir Ahmed Khoso, who had been conducting day-to-day hearings on the orders of the Supreme Court that took suo motu notice of the case.
In their defence, the Rangers men said that Sarfraz Shah was turned over to them as a dacoit. They said he attempted to snatch one of their rifles, and in the process, shots were fired.
One of the men standing trial, Shahid Zafar, who fired two shots injuring Shah, said that he along with co-accused Afzal Khan gave the victim water and took him to hospital where they remained until he died. He also stated that when the FIR was registered against them, they surrendered voluntarily.
Later, Shahid Zafar submitted a list of three defence witnessess, Colonel Salman of the Pakistan Rangers, the CEO of SAMAA TV or a representative, and Muhammad Saleem, the driver of the Chhipa ambulance that took Shah to Jinnah hospital.
For his part, the driver of the Rangers mobile van, co-accused Manthar Ali, named as a defence witness Alam Zaib, a police official who was allegedly robbed. Co-accused Afsar Khan, a civilian, named Investigating Officer DIG Sultan Khawaja, DSP Altaf Hussain and SIP Nasrullah of Boat Basin as his defence witnesses.
The court asked the accused men to produce the defence witnesses in court on Friday. If the need arises, then any witness can be called as a court witness, the ATC judge said.
Earlier in the day, the judge announced that he was rejecting the request by the defence to summon the chemical examiner and ballistics expert.
Published in The Express Tribune, August 5th, 2011.
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
The murder of this unarmed youth is nothing but a “Fake Encounter Killing”.Today an hon’ble Supreme Court in India has said Police personnel involved in fake encounter killings should be awarded death sentence and hanged.A bench of justices Markandeya Katju and C K Prasad said that police personnel as custodians of law are expected to protect people and not eliminate them as contract killers.“Fake encounter killings by cops are nothing but cold blooded brutal murder which should be treated as the rarest of rare offence and police personnel responsible for it should be awarded death sentence. They should be hanged,” Justice Katju, heading the bench, said.The killing of Sarfaraz Shah, which was indeed very shocking should also be treated on the same lines and the guilty should deserve nothing less than death penalty.
I believe they're about as guilty as it gets but, chances are, in this specific case, they have no hope anyways even if I'm wrong. They're probably not even getting their "fair trial" based on true desire. Their complacent carelessness caught on camera effectively made them good publicity for the judicial system. They'll do it by the book and they'll convict them. That much has probably already been decided. The information the media gets is an important part of their goal, too. The hope shown for them is only there because they want the public to see that they have a fair chance in the system at this point. Next is the conviction to show that the system does work to protect them and the proof that the process does work regardless of any naysayers.
i support rangers.why camera is not always right.i hope v all know incident of sialkot where two brothers were killed.whole nation was sympathising with two brothers including media and later on it was rvealed that both were murderers and dacoits.
Rangers killed him mercilesslly.The judge is on right track.
The whole of the country witnessed the atrocities of the Rangers Personnel, and the TV evidence alone should suffice their guilt. They should be given punishment befitting the crime, or we shall see many more such incidents where the poor citizen will suffer to these so called guardians of the law. I hope justice is not denied as what appears to be the case from the foregoing.
I support the Rangers.
The court will remain silent at least at national interest . The acused may be innocent .?