The news of the attack made headlines the next morning. We were informed that in the battle that had lasted nearly four hours and had come to an end only when Nato troops intervened, at least seven people were killed and three terrorists had blown themselves up. Although the media reported a sense of chaos and panic, no one picked up on the fact that even at a time when the only thoughts, for the Afghan forces at least, should have been the security of the hotel and the safety of guests, the latent tensions between Afghanistan and Pakistan managed not only to rear their ugly head but also to threaten the life of at least one unsuspecting Pakistani.
I met Umar a few days after he returned to Pakistan. His appearance at that time was more harrowing than his story. When I asked him what was the one thing about his ordeal that he would always remember, he replied simply: That the Afghans hate us!
I was struck and intrigued by his answer. He told me that in the confusion following the attack, he had been separated from his Farsi-speaking colleagues. Alone and afraid, he crawled nearly 100 meters on his stomach amid shelled cars and corpses, finally taking refuge under an old Corolla. It was dark and he could not see much. Umar closed his eyes and recited the Kalima, believing that this was the end.
However, it was the security forces and not the terrorists that discovered Umar. Thinking himself to be safe, he told them that he was a Pakistani. It appears that was a mistake. The officers immediately pinned him to the ground, stole his dollars and his cell phone and would not release him despite the shouted explanations of his Farsi-speaking colleagues who had managed to escape the compound.
After several minutes of this torture, a vehicle arrived to take away some injured Afghanis. The official detaining Umar, perhaps finally taking pity on him, told him to make a run for it. Although he was afraid that he would be shot if he did run, Umar decided to take the risk and nearly collapsed when he made it to the van.
He passed a difficult night without any medical aid, but in the morning luck favoured him and he ran into the Pakistani ambassador and the foreign secretary in the hotel lobby. When he told them what he had been through they not only arranged medical care for him but also promised to take up, at the highest level, the treatment meted out to him by the Afghan security officials. It was an off the record remark by a Pakistani official that was perhaps most telling: We are paying for having supported Pakhtuns and the Taliban especially now that the Farsi-speaking are back in power! When will we learn, I wonder?
Published in The Express Tribune, July 20th, 2011.
COMMENTS (25)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
It is over eight years now since I have been working in Afghanistan. my projects are mostly in the Tajik and Hazara country where i enjoy a very good relationship with the locals. I don't remember feeling insulted by anyone in these areas during the last eight years. they do some times complain through, when GoP openly pushes for a dialogue with Taliban, but with the Pashtoons it is an entirely different story. I always face a very hostile and discriminatory attitude from Pashtoon in Kabul or on the way through Torkhum to Peshawar, if I ever travel there, which i rarely do the last three years now.
There are two very visible signs of this hatred you can feel while traveling in Afghanistan and without talking to people.
First is at the Torkhum-Jalabad road built by FWO. Pakistani flag and the word Pakistan is painted black on every single signboard or are broken.
Second is the hundreds of busses that Pakistan donated to Afghanistan a couple of years back. these buses where bearing the flag of Pakistan and Afghanistan on both sides with a goodwill message of "Long Live Pakistan- Afghanistan Friendship" in the Pashstoon regions the Pakistani flag and the word Pakistan is washed with paint but if you go to Bamyan all the buses carry the goodwill message where ever they go.
I agree with the comment! when will we learn?
These Kabuli Farsi speaking Afghanis are just Indian puppets. They are taught hate by their Indian masters so why should you be surprised. They are taught from childhood that all of their problems are due to Pakistan. Even when they kill each other in crime, they blame it on Pakistan because they are taught this by Indians. But funny thing is that the moment there is trouble there in Afghanistan, they run and cry to come to Pakistan. We are silly to let them keep coming to Pakistan. Now is the time to shut the door by building a big fence between Afghanistan and Pakistan so they cannot enter into our country.
It's our own policies of trying to colonize Afghanistan through our lovely creatures "Talib", we never supported the realy majority of Afghanistan, the Afghans/Pashtoons, we just supported Talibs and thats backfiring. Afghans/Pashtoons don't hate us, they just are too hurt by what we did to them. and please lets come out of this nutshell that we supported Pashtoons there, we did not, we supported the talibs, who have nothing to do with Pasthoons except for killing them
"We are paying for having supported Pakhtuns and the Taliban especially now that the Farsi-speaking are back in power! When will we learn, I wonder?" The article was brilliant till this last sentence appeared. The actions of the ISI sending proxies to cause violence in neighbouring countries has brought misery not only in Pakistan(30000 lives) but in the region at large. Honestly, Pakistan is the most hated country in Afghanistan who resent the continued interference in its internal affairs. Do not suffer from the illusion that Pashtuns are favourably inclined, all Afghans across the board hate Pakistan. The purveyors of violence continue with their follies as the country keeps plumbing to new strategic depths.
@MS - Mariya: Your points may be right (I do not know so well) however just one issue - it is not in the 80s that Pakistan intervened. Nasruallah Baber created the Taliban (BB later claimed credit for it) in 1994. They were provided funding till and even beyond 9/11 (airlift from Kundz - see in wikipedia under title of "airlift of evil") . even now large swathes of Taliban are provided shelter in pakistan. The strategic depth theory is still very much alive in Pakistani strategy and is not forsaken.
This results in the average afghani still hating Pakistan (don't blame the Afghanis - Pakistan is reaping what it sowed).
If pakistan wants Afghan friendship then the minimum it could do is (1) stop aiding and providing shelter to Taliban (the argument was made that Pakistan does not shelter taliban, but then it also did not shelter OBL - or did it ?), (2) provide development and reconstruction support to Afganistan and invest in infrastructure there (India provides the largest and most successful reconstruction programme in Afghanistan - a fact attested by international acclaim including from Japan and China - but Pakistan opposes it) (3) give up support to cross border armed groups as a principle of state policy
Jaat, besides india, israel, karzai regime, and usa and its stooges, every other country.
The reason why Pak will continue to look after its interests: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vmryon21258&feature=player_embedded (Afghanistani general saying the border is at the Indus River).
Afghan policy bearing fruits.
Afghanis-Specially Farsi Ban(Persian accent) don't like Pakistanis and this is the fact. Where as majority of Pakhtoons favours Pakistanis.
@Basharmal: Why not Pakistan form federation with Afghan - after all, all Muslims and have same blood. That way it is possible to balance India - who have no blood links with Afghanistan people. When federation happens, all business in Central Asia captured by Afghaini-Pakistan Emirate - think of it - not impossible dream.
Amber, please don't be surprised. Here is a simple quiz: Name one country in the whole world the people of which love Pakistanis.
Before all of you Pakistanis jump on me; is this the Pakistan that you want to leave for you children and future generations?
The abuse comes from the TAJIKS mainly and this bellicose attitude towards the Pashtuns has been there since 1920s. In 1974 two Tajik leaders were cold shouldered by Pakistan on orders of late Mr Bhutto who had an insight to their dealings and had he been alive today; We would not be facing the present situation, We ourselves have lost our bearing as a nation and need to take care of that before embarking on improving relations with Afghans.
Afghan Taliban mainly represents the rural conservative pushtoon. They don’t represent the 55 percent non-pushtoon population of Afghanistan. Tajiks, Uzbeks, Shia Hazara, Baloch, Turkmen and moderate pushtoon hate Taliban, and there is a huge ethnic divide between pushtoon and non-pushtoon.
Our strategic depth will remain restricted to the 45 percent pushtoon population of Afghanistan. After withdrawal, US, Russia, Iran, India and NATO will continue to support the current regime. If US decides to maintain airbases in Afghanistan, the Taliban will never be able to attack non-pushtoon areas in strength.
Don't read too much into this....
Afghanistan is not the only country in the world to hate Pakistanis.....
May be Pakistan wouldn't need to interfere in Afghan affairs if the Afghanis hadn't always tried to undermine Pakistan with Indian and Iranian backing since the British left. It gave Pakistan a chance to forge a rare alliance and stabilize their western borders by supporting the Afghan resistance. That support led to a backing for a pro-Pakistan govt in Kabul. India and Iran tried to do the same by backing their favourite factions. Why should Pakistan apologize for trying to protect its interests ? If the Taliban had listened to their Pakistani allies and given up OBL, Afghanis wouldn't be in this terrible situation. Before 9/11, Taliban had a developing working relationship with USA. And now its not just Afghans, but also Pakistan who have to pay for Taliban's mistakes. Pakistan has supported a political, diplomatic solution to Afpak always. Regardless, Farsi Afghans/Tajiks will never be friendly to Pakistan and Pakistan should do everything to minimize that headache especially once the Americans leave. We cannot afford to have a hostile puppet govt in Kabul taking dictation from India or Iran.
This is a baloney story...."Ran into Pakistani ambassador in lobby! lol.
Amber I understand (yes we did not mind our own business in 1980s) but to simply blame Pakistan for their current state is wrong. Just like most Pakistanis seem to be throwing blame on everyone except themselves...the Afghans are doing the same. Below is an extract from an article in GUardian. The purpose to paste it here is that the high corruption in Aghanistan and Pakistan is fault of its own people and no one else. Yes everyone has enemies and evil neighbours like India but the enemies get strength when the house is not in order.
''Deeming the HOOAC a failure, the international community pressed Karzai to set up a corruption commission. Instead, what emerged was the monitoring and evaluation committee (MEC), partly funded by the UK's Department for International Development.
Karzai immediately doomed the MEC by appointing Professor Mohammed Yasin Osmani as its head. He had been the chairman of the HOOAC, which under his tenure had got nowhere. "It was a real kick in the teeth for internationals and signalled Karzai had no intention of going after those who were corrupt," the rule of law official said.
To add insult to injury, Karzai appointed Azizullah Lodin, the former head of the international election committee who had been fired over the 2009 election fraud, as the new head of the HOOAC.
Karzai is reluctant to go after corrupt warlords and officials close to him because, having become president without a power base, he has had to cut deals with them to shore up his position.
At the same time, internationals applied pressure on MCTF officials to put together a test case. In June last year, the attorney general's office arrested Mohammad Zia Salehi, another Karzai aide, on bribery charges. Karzai intervened and he was released. Similarly, in March this year, the presidential aide Noorullah Delawari was arrested on corruption changes, and then released after Karzai intervened.
The Kabul Bank fiasco remains the country's most notorious corruption scandal. To date, no one has been arrested over the disappearance of $900m of depositors' money. Last month Abdul Qadir Fitrat, the former head of the Afghan central bank, fled to the US, saying he did not want to be a scapegoat.'' GUARDIAN
Just login to any online Afghan/Pashtun forums and introduce yourself as Pakistani. The amount of abusive words and hatred you'll receive is unbelievable.
Unfortunately most Pakistanis suffer from the delusion that the Afghans love us and love the Taliban.
A note to the editor: I don't think there is such a word as 'Afghanis'
It won't be long before the real, majority Afghans are back in power.
We in Pakistan have been fed the delusion that the Afghan people support the Afghan Taliban and want it back into power. Far from it, they hate Pakistan for meddling in their affairs. We on the other hand seem to think that we know best whats in the Afghans interest.