The ghosts of Afghanistan

Published: December 1, 2019


PHOTO: REUTERS The writer is a member of staff and a political science graduate from LUMS. He tweets @KamilBreakdown

The ghosts of Afghanistan can trace their misery back to 1978, the year that changed the course of history for a once-prosperous country. The rise of Afghanistan’s communist party to power brought with it widespread radical reforms aimed at modernising the country. Their internal struggle prompted an invasion by the USSR making the region a volatile breeding ground for civil wars and insurgents. The Afghan people, in these circumstances, had no choice but to flee from the country to save their lives. The preservation of life is, after all, the bedrock on which the hierarchy of human needs is based upon.

The Soviet invasion, subsequent civil war, rise of the Taliban and the War on Terror made the country virtually uninhabitable. More than three million refugees fled to Pakistan alone — something that stands as one of the biggest mass scale migration for any region till this day.

In an alien country, without an identity, without the prospect of livelihood and without a glimmer of hope, these refugees turned ghosts meander through a sad existence. They have been plagued by the same problems over a generation. They left their country to save their lives yet were stripped of the ability to make one.

In 2016, more than 380,000 refugees left Pakistan, however the UNHCR reported the presence of 1.3 million Afghan refugees in 2017. These ghosts, who have resided in Pakistan (many of whom were born here) for more than three decades, have always been deemed as Afghan nationals. Pakistan’s inability to make concessions for these individuals could be marked as a significant diplomatic failure as well.

National integration is but a dream for many of these refugees who have been born and raised in a country that refuses to acknowledge them as part of its population. The refugees cannot claim a Pakistani passport or a National Identity Card (NIC). The only acknowledgement of their presence comes in the form of Proof of Registration Cards (PoR). This provides them with a temporary legal status along with freedom of movement.

These ghosts cannot buy property, vehicles or mobile SIM cards. Workplaces tend to look away from people without a valid NIC. Schools and universities cannot enrol them without the necessary documents that they are not allowed to have. Hospitals often refrain from admitting pregnant Afghan women because they cannot issue them birth certificates.

Pakistan opened its doors to the Afghan refugees in the aftermath of a war that was crucial for our geopolitical ambitions and safety. Our hospitality however has left much to be desired. India on the other hand has stepped in to fill the vacuum. They are now providing education, training and resources for Afghan individuals who will ultimately lead the Afghan opinion on geopolitics. Pakistan had the chance to leave a mark on the very fabric of Afghanistan and form a bond that could have persisted for centuries. If we could have integrated these refugees, educated them and sent them back, we could have created an ally that would have stood by us for the foreseeable future.

Instead, these ghosts trudge through their routines, knowing that the State and the world in general have failed them. Pakistan can still salvage the situation by implementing a multitude of options yet the powers that be seem inclined to drive them back rather than appreciate the opportunity they have at hand.

Perhaps we are to blame as well. When Prime Minister Imran Khan proposed naturalising third and fourth generation Pakistan-born Afghan refugees, he was met with thunderous criticism and backlash. Therefore, it is safe to assume that Pakistan will always be somewhat complicit in the suffering of the Afghans.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 1st, 2019.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (1)

  • John Chaudry.
    Dec 1, 2019 - 2:40PM

    Simply we cannot afford them. They should be repatriated with honour to their own land. The nearly four-decade of hospitality is more than enough. We pay a very high price accommodating these alien. Currently, the Afghan issue is oscillating around there leadership. They are in no hurry to resolve it. It,s there problem if they cannot find a solution. Recommend

Leave Your Reply Below

Your comments may appear in The Express Tribune paper. For this reason we encourage you to provide your city. The Express Tribune does not bear any responsibility for user comments.

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

More in Opinion