Police wonder which militant groups are kosher

Published: June 20, 2011
Despite numerous attacks, Pakistan lacks a national policy on how to deal with terrorism. DESIGN:  JAMAL KHURSHID

Despite numerous attacks, Pakistan lacks a national policy on how to deal with terrorism. DESIGN: JAMAL KHURSHID


There is “massive confusion” in the police department about whether they can take action against certain banned groups such as the active Jamaatud Dawa unless they get the go-ahead from ‘big brother’.

These groups differ from clearly marked ones such as the Lashkar-e-Jhangvi or Tehreek-i-Taliban, who are fair game. In any given month, the police arrest at least a dozen of their operatives, who are paraded in front of the media, albeit under blankets to protect their identity. The proud officers rachet up the number of suspects and everyone goes home happy.

But what about the groups that fall in a grey area? In background interviews, senior police and civilian intelligence officials reveal to The Express Tribune that the confusion begins when they come across suspects who operate under groups with an “untouchable status”.

Take, for example, certain outfits such as the Jamaatud Dawa (JuD) whose members were “sashaying around” [Dhandanatay huey phir rahey they] in a massive rally to openly mourn the death of Osama bin Laden, as one senior police official put it. It was ironic that the force had to offer them “protection” for their rally, he remarked. They even openly offered funeral prayers in absentia for the al Qaeda leader.

“Today, if [Sipah-e-Sahaba Pakistan’s general secretary] Maulana Aurangzeb Farooqi comes to the city and holds a rally, nobody in the police force would know whether he should be allowed to make a speech or not,” said this officer, who has vast experience and specialises in terrorism cases. To make matters worse, the police have the complaint that the intelligence agencies are usually arrogant about these matters and tell the police force that they should be consulted first before any action is taken.

“Without a doubt, there’s massive confusion in the police force today about what to do with certain people belonging to some banned militant groups,” said a senior civilian intelligence official, who corroborated the police official’s claim. He stressed there was a dire need to set up a platform where police, civil and military security agencies can coordinate and work out what is kosher.

This confusion and its fallout has been noted and discussed not just inside the force, but by observers too. It should hardly come as a surprise that the police in Karachi, as those elsewhere in the country, don’t know what to do, said Zahid Hussain, who is the new Pakistan scholar at the Woodrow Wilson International Centre and the author of The Scorpion’s Tale: The Relentless Rise of Islamic Militants in Pakistan. “Despite numerous terrorism incidents, Pakistan lacks a national policy on how to deal with terrorism,” he said. In fact, some of our security agencies engaged in counter-terrorism are still not clear in their heads whether militancy and all militant groups are a threat to the country.

Hussain blamed the government for failing to come up with a national policy and warned that the longer we wait, the more difficult it would become to craft one. For him, it was a shame that the national counter-terrorism authority that was supposedly established to deal with exactly these questions, remains ineffective. “They’re still bickering over whether this body should come under the interior minister or prime minister,” he said.

But why should there even be kosher and non-kosher groups at all, argue others. These categories for militant groups are “mere excuses” being made by the police, in the opinion of former Inspector-General of Police for Sindh Afzal Shigri. It was the duty of a police official and every law enforcement authority to arrest all terrorists. A policeman works under the law and if he catches a suspect according to the law, no one can stop him from doing so. “It is ridiculous, in my opinion, to say that they can’t act unless Big Brother winks at them,” he said, adding that it’s highly unfortunate that today the police was playing second fiddle to the agencies. “Police have the powers to arrest and interrogate. They have all the powers, while intelligence agencies technically have no such powers.”

The truth is that the police has its own national police management board which can be approached for all such conundrums and from whom legal opinion can be solicited.

For Shigri, it’s the policeman’s job to withstand pressure from all internal and external players, even if it comes from the intelligence agencies. “Worst comes to worst, the influential [people] can have an officer transferred. So why be afraid of that?” he asked. In his view, the current situation also indicates a lack of leadership within the police. “An officer who is earning just his salary, [about] Rs20,000, wouldn’t care for such things,” he explained. “It is those who are earning two million rupees a month who worry about transfers and Big Brother pressures.”

Published in The Express Tribune, June 20th, 2011.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (9)

  • BruteForce
    Jun 20, 2011 - 10:20AM

    It is a lesson in stupidity that the Pakistani agencies haven’t realized that Terrorists dont need a No-Objection-Certificate to work for LeT today, and LeJ tomorrow! Recommend

  • Feroz
    Jun 20, 2011 - 10:21AM

    The Police must do their job without bias and fear or favour. Enforcing the rule of Law is their job and interference from any quarter (political, bureaucracy or agencies) must be resisted for the Police to regain peoples confidence. The role of the lowly beat constable as the eyes and ears of the Force, should not be under estimated.Recommend

  • Ali Abdulla
    Jun 20, 2011 - 11:12AM

    It is known to every one that our big brother ISI is ruling our country!
    Why blame the poor police men?Recommend

  • anwar gul
    Jun 20, 2011 - 11:18AM

    they are all islamic fascists who deserve to be hunted down.what is the confusion about?? these islamic terrorists have killed 40000 of our people,what are we still confused about? just because a person doesn’t shave doesn’t make him a holy cow or a good person.we have to stop giving automatic respect to beards and burkas.these people have used and abused religion for their own personal power for too long.Recommend

  • Jun 20, 2011 - 12:03PM

    It is not difficult to see the problems the police on the ground face. When the JUD and Hafiz Saeed are being used as pawns for negotiation with India, the signals to the rank and file of the police will be ambiguous. Recommend

  • ashok sai
    Jun 20, 2011 - 12:36PM

    Any terrorist group which acts against India or US will be protected by Pakistan, its as simple as this.Recommend

  • Zeeshan H
    Jun 20, 2011 - 12:49PM

    Hahha so the new name for the “establishment” is “Big Brother”?… I like!

    And Mr Shigri is kind of unrealistic… does he really think that police should waste their time catching militants who are just going to be let go on orders from above? And being transferred IS a pretty big deal…I’m sure while he was working he would have been none too thrilled if he had been transferred from Karachi to Tharparkar…Recommend

  • Farhan Khan
    Jun 20, 2011 - 1:20PM

    @anwar gul:
    You stop respecting something they don’t accept … They will start dis-respecting something that you won’t accept.Recommend

  • Hedgefunder
    Jun 20, 2011 - 2:21PM

    So the Law & Order policy is being played on the whims of few Clowns with their personal agenda and interests rather then the interests of the People and Nation at Large!!!!
    Some bloody state of affairs this country has resigned too!!!Recommend

More in Pakistan