Argentina faces historic vote on legalizing abortion

Lawmakers in Pope Francis' native Argentina vote Wednesday on legalizing abortion

Afp June 13, 2018
Demonstrators hold up green handkerchiefs during a demonstration in favor of legalizing abortion outside the Congress in Buenos Aires, Argentina, PHOTO: REUTERS.

BUENOS AIRES: Lawmakers in Pope Francis' native Argentina vote Wednesday on legalizing abortion, which if passed, would make it the most populous country in South America to allow women to terminate pregnancies.

The debate has divided Argentinian society. Though it has shed some of its traditionalism by pioneering the legalization of gay marriage in Latin America, it remains strongly influenced by the Catholic Church.
The Chamber of Deputies is deeply divided over the issue and after weeks of bitter debate, the result of Wednesday night's vote is far from certain.

Of the Chamber's 257 deputies, 109 are expected to vote in favor of the bill, 117 against, with the remaining 29 undecided lawmakers casting the decisive votes in the lower house.

"Today we see an almost a neck-and-neck vote, with a slight advantage for those against the bill," said Martin Maquieyra of President Mauricio Macri's ruling Cambiemos party, who will vote against.

Pro- and anti-abortion groups have called for demonstrations outside Congress on Wednesday.

Abortion bans around the world

As in most Latin American countries, abortion is illegal in Argentina, except in cases of rape or when the life or health of the woman is at risk.

The new bill would decriminalize abortion during the first 14 weeks of pregnancy, and even afterwards in cases where the fetus suffers from conditions not compatible with life outside the womb.

If passed, the bill would then go before the Senate, where it faces an uphill battle to become law. Analysts point out that more senators have spoken out against the bill than in its favor.

Macri, who has come out strongly against abortion, has asked lawmakers to vote with their conscience, and said he would not veto the bill if passed.

"We hope that the respect is maintained, we are all Argentines, we can have very different ideas, but with respect," said pro-government deputy Daniel Lipovetzky.

Once considered highly unlikely in traditionally Catholic, conservative Argentina, support for decriminalizing abortion has grown in recent years, boosted by a vociferous #NiUnaMenos (Not One Less) campaign against violence against women as well as by last month's referendum legalizing abortion in Ireland.

That momentum has set it on a collision course against the religious right, determined to block the legalization of abortion, a war being fought on the pope's turf.

In March, as the abortion debate heated up, the former Buenos Aires archbishop sent a letter to the Argentine Episcopal Conference asking them to "make a contribution in defense of life and justice."

Supporters of the bill have denounced church pressure.

"It complicates things... But if abortion has been legalized in Italy, where the power of the church resides, I don't see why this would represent a greater difficulty in Argentina," said sociologist Sol Prieto from the University of Buenos Aires.

"The church no longer has a monopoly, the religious dynamic is changing in recent times in Argentina," said Prieto.

According to official health ministry statistics, over 17% of the 245 recorded deaths of pregnant women and girls in 2016 were due to abortion. NGOs say some 500,000 abortions a year are carried out clandestinely, often in conditions which pose a health risk for women and girls.

Teenage student returns to Italy after forced abortion in Pakistan

"We are not questioning the personal and religious beliefs of the legislators, we are debating whether clandestine abortion is going to continue or whether the state is going to guarantee legal abortion, so there will not be one more dead," said activist Myriam Bregman of the Workers' Left Front party.

Macri's vice president, Gabriela Michetti, has come out strongly against the bill.

"Being in favor of life is much more progressive and respectful," she said.

"If a woman does not want to be a mother, whatever the motive, she can entrust the child for adoption."

Whatever the outcome, the tide of public opinion is blowing in one direction, according to sociologist Prieto.

"I don't know if the law will be adopted, but if it's not voted in this time, it won't be long before it is. It's a movement that you can't stop."

Latin America has strict laws outlawing abortion, except in Uruguay, Cuba, Guyana and Mexico City, where it is legal.


Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read