Is Afghanistan the next caliphate?

Published: April 16, 2018
Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS

Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS

Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS The writer is an international relations analyst based in Islamabad. He can be reached at

Terror outfits often expand their influence by merging into other groups or by cobbling together alliances. They essentially do it when their existence is threatened or for consolidation of power in an alien territory. It helps them to expand their scope, scale of operations, and influence. Moreover, it also helps them to foster human resource, wealth, technology and ideas. This is quite true for the Islamic State. Despite its so-called defeat in Iraq, the militant group has survived on the scores of loyalists left behind in Syria and parts of Iraq. It is now looking to expand its influence by shifting its headquarters and franchises elsewhere. Moreover, it is also seeking to regroup all their leftover fighters in the region.

Many experts and officials believe that the group still poses a potent threat to regional security. As Iranian intelligence minister stated that “ISIS has lost land, but has not surrendered its arms, and is looking for land in Afghanistan, Pakistan and Central Asia in order to revive the idea of an Islamic caliphate.” Likewise, General John Nicholson said that “right now we see them very focused on trying to establish their Khorasan caliphate inside Afghanistan.”

Furthermore, the statistics show that the estimated structure of IS in Afghanistan varies. According to an Afghan security official, there were estimated 4,000 IS fighters spread over Nangarhar province. Although the size of the group has fallen over a period of time, the support by the Afghan government and the US provides them the opportunity to expand their scope, scale and operations.

Border clashes threaten Pak-Afghan thaw

Yet, it is true that in the land of warlords, a foreign entity has never survived. ‘Alexander the Great,’ stuck by Afghan archers’ arrows, barely managed an escape through the Indus River. Later on, the Moguls, the British and the Soviets, were vanquished and humiliated. This is one of the main reasons why the IS may not get its way with the Afghan populace.

In addition, the IS’s momentum is constrained by the fierce competition provided by the local insurgent groups. The group has a weak and unacceptable radical ideology. According to a report by the Middle East Institute, its two former commanders said that they joined the IS for a steady monthly income rather than its ideological appeal. Unlike the IS, the Taliban enjoy massive support within the Afghan population, driven as it is by religious ideology. No other group had ever enjoyed such acceptability and support. Therefore, the IS has to compete with other local groups which will further make things difficult for it.

Even so, Afghanistan, a country with weak administrative set-up is quite vulnerable to terrorism. Sardar, a young barber living in Kunduz, said that Afghan government officials had asked him for hefty bribes to resolve a long-running family dispute over land. When this happened, he turned to the Taliban who in his home in Chahar Darah resolved the issue in 48 hours.

However, the weak physical, economic, social and political deprivations as well as a lack of assets and income, reflect the vulnerability that captures the uninsured risks. These factors offer incentives for insurgent and terrorist groups that exploit the grievances and vulnerabilities of the local populace to engineer and keep the strategic cause alive. This helps them in recruitment and funding and garners moral and political support. Such state of affairs provides them the variety to stick to the same cause, until another one looks more profitable.

Top Islamic State commander in Afghanistan killed in airstrike: officials

On the other hand, the US and Afghan governments may like to support the IS, in response to Pakistan’s alleged support for the Afghan Taliban. Furthermore, it is very likely that the US will support the outfit to sabotage the CPEC, which is seen as the primary threat to US hegemony.  It is too early however to predict the rise of IS in Afghanistan. But if that does happen it will surely complicate the regional security equation.

Published in The Express Tribune, April 16th, 2018.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (6)

  • Furkan Awan
    Apr 16, 2018 - 12:40PM

    U.S should ensure that Democracy comes to Afghanistan Recommend

  • numbersnumbers
    Apr 17, 2018 - 1:39AM

    And of course the author can provide credible support for his delusions that “The Taliban enjoy massive support within the Afghan populations”! OR NOT!
    The Afghans expierenced the Taliban’s draconian rule some decades ago and have no desire to return to their seventh century paradises!
    And in the Afghan’s eyes, there is no “alleged” in Pakistan’s decades long open support of terrorist proxy groups like Afghan Taliban destabilizing Afghanistan!Recommend

  • Rex
    Apr 17, 2018 - 2:46AM

    “Is Afghanistan the next caliphate?”
    Oh no, Pakistan is!Recommend

  • Imran
    Apr 17, 2018 - 4:48AM

    you are giving these terrorist animals too much credit. They don’t have the brains to think through all this. They are usually just sent with detailed instructions and funding from a large neighbouring country. Unfortunately for us the language is way too similar to the enemy’s and so communication task is made all the more easier for our enemy which is a lumbering slumdogRecommend

  • Trollslayer
    Apr 17, 2018 - 10:48AM

    The author would do well to research the proponents of Caliphate in Pakistan, starting with TYLRA and on to the countless other organizations that espouse millenarian discourse in Pakistan. Recommend

  • Ali
    Apr 17, 2018 - 10:00PM

    Excellent. The piece worths it. Recommend

More in Opinion