Is govt debt crucial to country’s growth?

Published: April 16, 2018
Focus should be on  attracting FDI, boosting tax proceeds and investment. PHOTO: FILE

Focus should be on  attracting FDI, boosting tax proceeds and investment. PHOTO: FILE

NORTHHAMPTON: A recent IMF report showed that government debt in some of the poorest economies of the world has risen exponentially. These countries account for a significant fifth of the world’s population but only contribute about 4% to the global output.

Reasons cited behind this build-up of debt include the sharp drop in commodity prices in 2014, which adversely affected commodity exporting countries, natural disasters including the Ebola epidemic, civil conflict and high levels of public spending, which were not linked to financing productive investment.

Is the government bankrupt?

Although the IMF classifies Pakistan as an emerging market country, a similar picture of rising debt levels is witnessed in the country as well. Latest data from the State Bank of Pakistan reveals that the country’s total debt and liabilities have risen by 14.9% in Q2FY18 relative to the same period last year.

This forms a share of 71.7% of the GDP, which is clearly much beyond the ascribed 60% of the GDP-debt level as prescribed by the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitation Act 2005. Two pertinent questions that arise at this point; 1) Is debt all bad? 2) How do countries manage their debt levels?

Debt: Bane or a Boon? 

Debt is crucial to a well-functioning economy. Firms can use it to finance investments for future productivity and households can use it to finance lumpy purchases. Similarly, governments also borrow to finance productive or non-productive expenditure.

Proponents of government debt argue for its positive impact on growth, inflation and savings and more sophisticated capital markets, which enhance the volume and efficiency of private investment. Domestic debt markets can also help strengthen money and financial markets, boost private savings and stimulate investment.

Critics of government debt argue that when governments borrow domestically, they use up domestic savings that would otherwise have been available for private-sector lending. This results in a smaller pool of loanable funds that could otherwise be used for productive investments by the private sector.

Critics also argue that government debt has repercussions on fiscal and debt sustainability. Domestic debt is considered more expensive than concessionary external financing. As a consequence, the interest burden on government debt may absorb significant government revenues and thereby crowd out pro-poor and growth-enhancing spending. Hence, this makes the management of the government debt crucial.

Pakistan plans to borrow record $13b next fiscal year

Debt management

Debt management is crucial to avoid countries entering into any a vulnerable position. Effective debt management is critical to macro and financial stability, and financial and overall development. The main objectives of public debt management involve meeting the financing needs, minimising costs and maintaining risk at a prudent level.

The IMF advises that borrower countries, lenders and international institutions should all work together. Low-income countries need to proceed prudently when taking on new debts. They should focus more on attracting foreign direct investment and boosting tax proceeds at home. Moreover, debt should be used for investment in projects, which offer a high rate of return. This advice is not just limited to low-income countries but is applicable to emerging markets like Pakistan as well.

The writer is a doctoral candidate at The Bartlett, UCL


Published in The Express Tribune, April 16th, 2018.

Like Business on Facebookfollow @TribuneBiz on Twitter to stay informed and join in the conversation.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (3)

  • Ismail Mirza
    Apr 16, 2018 - 12:05PM

    No, not government debt but rather curbing population growth, getting everyone to pay their fair share of taxes, less reliance on low-value added commodities for export and greater focus on the production of high-value added goods and services, etc…Recommend

  • Shah Alam
    Apr 16, 2018 - 2:17PM

    Pakistan should take more debt to buy JF-17s fighter jets, Babur missiles, build more nuclear bombs and of course for CPEC.

    We can float more Sukkuk bonds and pay higher interest to attract foreign money.Recommend

  • Ehsan Ul-Haq
    Apr 16, 2018 - 8:22PM

    Debt is one person’s liability, but another person’s asset. Paul KrugmanRecommend

More in Business