More and more Muslims

Published: February 12, 2018
Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS

Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS

Representational image. PHOTO: REUTERS The writer, a former editor of The Express Tribune, is director of the Centre for Excellence in Journalism at IBA, Karachi. He tweets @tribunian

Every year, hundreds of Hindu girls are forcibly converted to Islam after being kidnapped by unidentified persons usually with the connivance of the local police.  With growing radicalisation in Sindh – once the land of Sufis and tolerance, many outsiders are now bringing their brand of faith to the province.

A trip last week to Ranikot, the famous fort located near the town of Sann, once again illustrated how the province is changing. There is a distinct air of change in the socio-political set-up of the province – not just in terms of the mosques and madrassas that one sees along the highway but the graffiti on the walls and the appearance of the locals.

Possibly one of the biggest victims of the new brand of Islam are Sindh’s religious minority communities. It is estimated that Hindus comprise 6 per cent of the total population of the province, a figure that cannot be independently verified given that the census data does not tell us about the various religious communities in the country.

Over the years, the Hindus have been marginalised as their role in Pakistan is questioned despite the fact that they are the original inhabitants of this land.

I was saddened when I read a column by my friend Kapil Dev, who once wrote that during the cricket World Cup in 2011, “many who knew that I am a Hindu, including some of my colleagues, asked me who I would support India or Pakistan.”

“I didn’t understand why on earth they would ask me such a stupid question – just because I’m Hindu. Why isn’t the same question asked of a Christian when Pakistan plays against Australia, England or New Zealand,” he asks.

But the problems don’t end there. When it comes to cases of forced conversion, these are mostly reported from Sindh. Although Pakistan became a Muslim-majority state post-partition — with Muslims dominating politics, the economy, and society — Hindus managed to retain a degree of social influence in the Sindh province, where they are seen as successful merchants. But that seems to be changing now.

At the same time a number of lower-caste and low-income Hindus in Sindh continued to toil on farmlands for powerful, rich landowners, many of them in some sort of bonded labour arrangement. They face social discrimination and are often cut off from the Hindu community at large.

A 2015 report by the South Asia Partnership-Pakistan argued that social, cultural, economic, and religious factors have combined with feudal power structures in rural areas to enable forcible conversions. A whole system is in place to ensure this practice – from the connivance of the police to the no-questions-asked policy of some custodians of religious shrines where this is done. By the time the girl is produced in court, it is already too late.

In November 2016, the Sindh Assembly unanimously passed a bill against forced conversion of religion in the province. The private bill, Criminal Law (Protection of Minorities), was tabled by Pakistan Muslim League-Functional (PML-F) lawmaker Nand Kumar in 2015. It was referred to the standing committee on minority and human rights for feedback and then returned to the assembly.

But one month later, the Sindh government decided to review the bill after religious scholars objected to some of its clauses. The decision was indicated in a policy statement issued by Senior Minister for Parliamentary Affairs Nisar Ahmad Khuhro. Muslim religious scholars believed some of its clauses were against the teachings of Islam and contrary to the Constitution.

The state’s attitude, as well as that of many eminent Muslims, is that conversions are actually a form of earning blessings. Needless to say that the conversions are often backed by powerful shrines, seminaries, and clerics, as well as local politicians. Seminaries and shrines protect the couple and say the girl willingly eloped, converted, and married.

This poses a challenge for lawyers and activists, who have to figure out if these marriages are born of free will or are marked by threats and violence. And almost invariably, the girl’s testimony that she exercised her right as an adult to marry settles the case, while her parents continue to insist she is being pressured by the influential followers of the shrine where she converted to Islam.

How long can this go on? Pakistani Hindus are calling for help. We cannot continue to look the other way.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 12th, 2018.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • Bunny Rabbit
    Feb 12, 2018 - 12:32PM

    AS long as these converted girls are happy with in laws , it should not cause any problems to any one else . Recommend

  • rk singh
    Feb 12, 2018 - 3:43PM

    Dear Sir, thanks for such a honest article. You have shown real courage to expose such evil practices. But you need not feel depressed.You might belong to the less than 1 percent of people in Pakistan who are tolerant of minorities. Our Modi government came into power after promising citizenship to Pakistani Hindus. But they seem to have forgotten them now. They are hardly taking care of Pakistani Hindus who are already in India now. There is hardly anything you can do- as a lone individual. But thanks anyway.Recommend

  • Farid Ahmad
    Feb 12, 2018 - 4:29PM

    It seems a propaganda against Islam. No one including Hindu is force-ably converted to Islam Around the world daily many non Muslims are accepting Islam due to the best teaching of Islam. Specially in USA and CANADA and UK thousands of non Muslims have been converted by their own free will, If someone say they are forcibly converted to Islam than what will be your response ????? Is it possible in USA Canada or UK to force a non Muslim to accept Islam without his or her free will???????.

    Muslim had ruled 1000 years in India. Entire history and even current population of India strongly witnessing that NO NON MUSLIM WAS FORCIBLY CONVERTED TO ISLAM. As if it was happened than majority of Indian population should be Muslim instead of Hindus.

    Actually teaching of Islam has much attraction for minorities specially for women. Islam has given great status to women and that’s why Hindu girls are accepting Islam under their own free will. Recommend

  • Farid Ahmad
    Feb 12, 2018 - 4:38PM

    Dear Sir / Madam

    If a Muslim women or man accept Hinduism or Christianity, you call it freedom and freewill however, if Hindu women or man accept Islam than why you feel trouble??? why you call it forcibly converting Islam ?????. No single case has been proven in court which could confirm that claim that hindu girls are forcibly being converting to Islam. Recommend

  • Fahad
    Feb 12, 2018 - 5:50PM

    One sentence is enough for who are criticizing.

    There is no complusion in Religion. – Surah Al-Baqarah [2:256] – Al-Qur’anRecommend

  • I am a Khan
    Feb 12, 2018 - 6:00PM

    If a Hindu converts to Islam or rather reverts to Islam, why do some hypocrites have a problem with it? If ALLAH chooses to guide you no one can misguide you and If ALLAH chooses to leave you astray, no one can guide you. Recommend

  • cuban
    Feb 13, 2018 - 3:35PM

    Every year, hundreds of Hindu girls are forcibly converted to Islam after being kidnapped by unidentified persons usually with the connivance of the local police.
    It’s called kidnapping and slavery by the rest of the World – often warranting extended prison sentences. Recommend

More in Opinion