Can CPEC cause Dutch disease?

Published: December 8, 2017
SHARES
Email
Planning Commission deputy chief promises to end load-shedding next year. PHOTO: FILE

Planning Commission deputy chief promises to end load-shedding next year. PHOTO: FILE

Planning Commission deputy chief promises to end load-shedding next year. PHOTO: FILE pervez.tahir@tribune.com.pk

First the etiology of the Dutch disease. In 1959, the Netherlands discovered huge deposits of natural gas in the North Sea. It resulted in a massive upsurge in oil exports. The new-found wealth led to the expansion of social security. By the 1970s, unemployment rose some five times and the welfare spending became unbearable. In 1977, this phenomenon of a fortune turning into misfortune was labelled by The Economist magazine as Dutch disease. Pakistan hasn’t discovered a big cache of natural resources. How can Pakistan catch the disease? The disease is not specific to natural resources. Any economy that experiences a sudden high inflow of foreign currency for any reason is likely to suffer from it. Including the early harvest phase of $46 billion, the total expected inflow under CPEC is stated to be $62 billion. This is close to the entire external public debt payable by Pakistan. The large size of the inflow in a short span of time makes it possible, though not probable. Here is how.

Sheer size of CPEC portfolio appals IMF

In the case of the Netherlands, the boon of oil exports turned out to be the bane of non-oil exports, which lost competiveness due to a rapid appreciation of the real exchange rate. Together with the non-traded sector, the oil export sector crowded out the traditional exports with adverse long-term effects. The increased oil exports raised incomes, money supply and demand for non-traded goods and services. In the case of CPEC, the inflows are being utilised largely on the import of power generating machinery and construction equipment. These imports do not directly affect the money supply in Pakistan. A small part of the inflows is spent on domestically supplied goods and services, notably construction and retail trade. It does add to money supply as foreign exchange is converted into local currency. Since the exchange rate in Pakistan has, in effect, been kept fixed, the increased money supply and domestic demand tend to increase prices. As the purchasing power of a unit of foreign currency is less than before, its real value appreciates. Even if the exchange rate regime were flexible, the increased supply of foreign exchange would drive up the nominal exchange rate and thus real exchange rate. In both cases, the traditional export sector suffers. The effect is made worse by the movement of capital and labour away from the export sector and towards domestic non-traded sector.

The CPEC inflows are recent. Pakistan has suffered an absolute decline in exports for three years in a row since 2014-15. Failure to break away from concentration on traditional products and destinations lies at the roots, besides the critical constraints of energy and law and order. There is a revival of exports coinciding with the CPEC inflows. This does not mean that the Dutch disease has died down; only that better energy and security situation and expectations about the Special Economic Zones have reinvigorated exports. The outlook for the global commodity prices has also improved. But the exports still have to contend with a rupee that is overvalued to the extent of 20 per cent. This could worsen with the acceleration of financial flows under CPEC.

London mayor-led delegation shows interest in CPEC

Policymakers have to focus on some deeper questions raised in the context of the Dutch disease. If the assumption is that the CPEC inflows are going to be a recurrent feature for a long period, the economy has to adapt to the required structural changes. These changes will entail shifts that can hurt labour as well as businesses used to get by in the traditional mould.

Published in The Express Tribune, December 8th, 2017.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.

Facebook Conversations

Reader Comments (7)

  • abood
    Dec 8, 2017 - 10:16AM

    Imf saya that rupee is over valued by 10 to 15%.in the article the writer mentions its 20%.how do you guys have so much of variations in your calculations.i guess these are just numbers to give to the public and have no true basis.Recommend

  • GKA
    Dec 8, 2017 - 12:36PM

    This Dutch Disease has been here for a while.

    Since the 80s Pakistan has been relying on extensive international dole outs. Thier first batch of F16s was part of this. Then post 9/11 a huge packet came again. Then there are coalition support funds.

    Add to that the Saudi largesse

    So there is a lot of reliance on “strategic funding”.

    Which is why CPEC has such support, without it Pakistan would face a huge belt tightening.Recommend

  • rk singh
    Dec 8, 2017 - 12:51PM

    Nobody heard of Dutch disease. But we can rename it “CPEC disease”.Recommend

  • BrainBro
    Dec 8, 2017 - 1:51PM

    Dutch disease is when the forex inflow is so high that it appreciates the currency to levels where the exports hurt. Pakistan has to borrow on high interest (5% + at junk sovereign rates) to pay for its coupons on current debt. The author really has no idea what Dutch disease is in reflection to macro bookmaking.Recommend

  • Baligur
    Dec 8, 2017 - 1:54PM

    Yes GKA is right. It’s not CPEC that is the cause of dutch disease. It’s the special combination of nuclear weapons and terrorists that we possess which allows us to extort money from the rest of the world. Recommend

  • cuban
    Dec 8, 2017 - 2:37PM

    @BrainBro: Dutch disease is when the forex inflow is so high that it appreciates the currency to levels where the exports hurt. Pakistan has to borrow on high interest (5% + at junk sovereign rates) to pay for its coupons on current debt. The author really has no idea what Dutch disease is Spot on!Recommend

  • PakPukudenguta
    Dec 9, 2017 - 12:05AM

    The article is based on wrong assumptions. CPEC is not going to give any dividends to Pakistan. The corridor will be used by China alone AND NO OTHER COUNTRY. Open your eyes and look at the map and the geography. Next, even China will not be paying a single paisa. In fact they will be owning half of Pakistan in the next decade. So, don’t worry, you will not catch this decease. Recommend

Leave Your Reply Below

Your comments may appear in The Express Tribune paper. For this reason we encourage you to provide your city. The Express Tribune does not bear any responsibility for user comments.

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive. For more information, please see our Comments FAQ.

More in Opinion