Lord Balfour reflects on ancestor's divisive legacy

Roderick Balfour says Balfour Declaration's promise to protect non-Jewish people remained unfulfilled to this day

Afp November 01, 2017
A century after his ancestor wrote a letter that became a foundation stone for the state of Israel, Lord Balfour condemns the "complete imbalance" in its application from the Palestinians' point of view. PHOTO: AFP

LONDON: A century after his ancestor wrote a letter that became a foundation stone for the state of Israel, Lord Balfour condemns the "complete imbalance" in its application from the Palestinians' point of view.

Roderick Balfour spoke glowingly of Israel's achievements in an interview with AFP but said the Balfour Declaration's promise to protect non-Jewish communities remained unfulfilled to this day.

"I'm sure Arthur would say 'this is unacceptable', that there's got to be more help for the Palestinians," the banker said in reference to his great-great-uncle Arthur Balfour's 1917 missive.

The Israeli-Palestinian conflict: 100 years of history

"Israel has got all these people living in their midst, probably it's time that they took stock of that and helped," the 68-year-old said, speaking in his London apartment ahead of Thursday's centenary.

The Balfour Declaration was a 67-word letter from Britain's then foreign secretary to Lionel Rothschild, a prominent British Zionist, supporting the creation of a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

The document eventually led to the creation of Israel in 1948, the displacement of around 750,000 Palestinians and decades of strife between the two communities.

Balfour pointed to the "abject circumstances" in which many Palestinians live but placed some blame for the perpetual state of conflict on hardline factions like Hamas and Lebanon's Hezbollah.

US jury convicts man of murdering singer Hudson's family members

He highlighted the "quite widely-held views" that it suits such groups to "make sure that the population remain kind of benefit-led and repressed, and are constantly able to blame Israel for their woes."

"You get the sense that some of the leadership don't want to see Palestine become wealthy and in parallel to Israel, because people would be comfortable and they might not feel so aggressive," he said.

Balfour, who has a copy of the letter on the mantlepiece in his house, said he would like its "humanitarian aspect" to be celebrated.

He said his ancestor would be "absolutely amazed" at how Israel has prospered since its founding and at its advancements in medicine and technology.

"I think there is pride, but there is obviously work to be done by the international community to try and make sure that this doesn't remain a festering sore in the world of international politics," he said.

On Thursday night Balfour and Lord Jacob Rothschild - a descendant of the 1917 letter recipient - are hosting a dinner at London's Lancaster House.

Hamas cedes Gaza border crossings to Palestinian Authority control

Visiting Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his British counterpart Theresa May are expected to attend, alongside other dignitaries. Balfour said he became aware of the declaration's magnitude only gradually.

A copy hung on a wall while he was growing up, but it was largely out of sight in his father's lavatory.

"The family didn't sit around saying let us remember the Balfour Declaration," he recalled. "One was aware of it, but I wasn't aware of its significance to the diaspora."

It took a Jewish taxi driver in London, who began singing impromptu songs in his honour on discovering his name, for a teenage Balfour to realise that. The reaction has not always been so fulsome.

Israel mulls expanding settlement in east Jerusalem

When Balfour travelled to Israel in the 1990s at the invitation of president Ezer Weizman, he received an unexpected grilling from immigration officials on leaving the country.

After Balfour produced his presidential invite, he recalled an unimpressed agent asked: "So what were you doing the other 48 hours?"

A lifelong financier with no political experience, Balfour has nonetheless found the declaration's legacy inescapable - even in British high society.

People at social gatherings have invariably chided that his family is to blame for all the present-day problems there.

"I say: 'well that's a bit harsh, because it was the British government,'" Balfour added. "People love a scapegoat."


Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ