HBL calls potential $630 million US fine 'disproportionate'

HBL Chief Executive Noman Karamat Dar admits mistakes but denies any wrongdoing

KARACHI: Habib Bank Ltd (HBL), facing a possible $630 million fine over compliance failures by its New York branch, admitted mistakes on Tuesday but denied any wrongdoing and said the penalty sought by US regulators was disproportionate.

New York State’s Department of Financial Services (DFS) said on August 28 it was seeking to fine HBL up to $630 million for “grave” compliance failures with anti-money laundering rules, in what would be the largest penalty ever faced by a Pakistani financial institution.



“There is no specific wrongdoing,” HBL Chief Executive Noman Karamat Dar told a press briefing in Islamabad. “Yes there are mistakes, but we are saying that the fine for these mistakes is disproportionate.”

HBL, which has announced its plan to surrender its US banking licence, has been embroiled in accusations over money-laundering compliance failures by its New York operation for more than a decade.

But the case has gained added weight amid growing political tensions between Washington and Islamabad following US President Donald Trump’s demand last week that Pakistan do more to cut off sanctuaries for Afghan Taliban insurgents.

The DFS, which has pursued several aggressive enforcement actions against foreign banks, has said HBL’s compliance systems were “dangerously weak” and “serious and persistent failings” at its New York unit appeared to affect the entire enterprise.

It identified instances of so-called “wire-stripping”, whereby a bank deliberately strips out information related to a payment, such as the originator or beneficiary that may raise suspicions.

Dar admitted that the bank had made a mistake in not identifying some transactions but attributed it to human error.



The bank has said operations outside the United States would not be affected and it would contest any fine. Dar said whatever happened; there would be no long-term effect.

“Our liquidity, profitability and strength is enough to take the bank forward,” he said.

Until April 2015, Pakistan’s government held a 42.5 per cent stake in HBL, the country’s oldest bank. However, it sold its shares as part of a privatisation drive, bringing in more than $1 billion. The DFS, however, still lists HBL as majority owned by the government.