When desire shall fail

No, George, this is no country for young children, this is no country in which to bring up and school your son.


Amina Jilani March 04, 2011

The most depressing thing this past week, amidst the myriad of things depressing in the incohesive, incoherent state of Pakistan (including the gunning down in the capital of the federal minister for minorities), was reading George Fulton’s farewell to a country he so passionately adopted.

Well, George, passion and desire cannot last; they are fleeting, elusive and ignore reality. The time inevitably draws nigh when truth dawns and prevails. You have had a good innings. What has killed your passion for the Islamic Republic, incapable of getting any act together, is the national mindset which, of course, has been with us for decades, long before you came on the scene.

It all started when socialist-democrat Zulfikar Ali Bhutto laid down the path for Ziaul Haq’s religiosity — but that is now conveniently forgotten, even forgiven. In the name of religion, to constitutionally transform an entire community into a minority, ignoring the fact that it had been part of the majority since the country’s birth and then, later to banish alcohol, gambling and Sundays, with the aim of clinging to power, is a sure recipe for disaster. And, by George, so it has proven to be, spreading tentacles wider and wider as the years have passed.

What is frightening is that it was the aftermath of the Salmaan Taseer murder that brought it all home; that the horrible blasphemy laws, in full operation for all the years you have been here, finally hit target. That the so-called ‘liberals’ were silenced out of fear, that rose petals were showered on a religious fanatic who had murdered in cold blood.

Is there hope? Well, definitely not for George and for millions who think as does he. We know what ails the Republic, apart from its ghastly collection of civilian and military self-styled politicos who lack any intent and will to do right by their country, who uphold all that is black about it — as does this present pathetic prime minister with his daily fear-inspired statements that the blasphemy laws will remain with us, dangerous and deadly.

This is a country which bans a filmSlackistan — because it depicts with some accuracy the vapidity of life for its youth. On the other hand, it is readying itself to view with passion and fervour (of the religious type) Aik Aur Ghazi, a film in which a convicted criminal is hailed as a hero because he has killed in the name of his religion, believing, as does cowardly hero-murderer Mumtaz Qadri, that those alleged to have committed blasphemy must die — the blasphemy laws are the sole laws that are followed in this glorious Islamic Republic where honour is held in such high esteem.

We need to learn a lesson from the Tunisians who were on the march last month. Banners were spotted, held up by protesters, which read “Politics ruins religion and religion ruins politics.” We failed to heed Muhammad Ali Jinnah when he told his budding legislators that religion is not the business of the state. His followers scoffed at him. When the country was but nine years old, religion was made very much the business of the state and it has continued to be ingrained to the extent where it is now in danger of stifling what is left of the state.

Perhaps the message of the young Tunisians may spread — but let us not hold our breath because it is the falsified message of the mullahs and maulvis which is apparently heeded by the youth of Pakistan.

No, George, this is no country for young children, this is no country in which to bring up and school your son. You need to get him out, and fast.

Published in The Express Tribune, March 5th, 2011.

COMMENTS (66)

Lookwithin | 10 years ago | Reply FYI - Pakistan is in the turmoil not because of the mullahs(I am not saying they are perfect but there are other factors aside from them), namely because of the well to do families of Pakistanis who do not love their fellow countrymen/women - they will cut their throat from behind as soon as the others back is turned - hasad/jallan for someone progressing in any field. The fact that as long as it does not effect them it does not warrant an eye blink even. Also because of the VIP culture where the elite will give rishwat and use their connections to their own benefit but hell may break loose if they help out a poor person. Where you treat your maids and servants as they are third class citizens. Where "progress" is following the norms of the western society ie "dating" "wearing western clothes" "celebrating valentine, basant while 100000s go hungry" but they do not pay attention to the most important point that every western citizen abides the law and if they do not then there is hell to pay whether its the president of the country/hollywood or a common citizen. I am sick and tired of everyone blaming the religion of peace when not even one of u understands the quran - when was the last time you read quran, read it with meanings and understood it! And even the government is not to be blamed after all they are from the people of pakistan... in fact you can see what pakistan is like through the government. STOP BLAMING government, mullahs or other people but get your act together and analyze your own selves each and everyday first then not only pakistan but the world will also be a better place. Writing an article maligning the mullahs doesnt mean you have done your duty .... duty is when someone is being robbed at gun point and you stop your car to save them! wow my first comment got deleted
ALI | 10 years ago | Reply some time i thinks that all the people from FATA should shift to islamabad or some better place (due to DRONE attacks and instability) but then i realize that FATA is their home land, they grown up there, how they can leave their motherland. Mr George was a foreigner, he was not a son of this soil. , he just spent few years over here . Why we are discussing him so much.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ

E-Publications

Most Read