Flawed diplomacy and Kashmir

Pakistan says that the Kashmir issue should be resolved according to UN resolutions

Durdana Najam October 09, 2016
Pakistan says that the Kashmir issue should be resolved according to UN resolutions. PHOTO: REUTERS

Pakistan says that the Kashmir issue should be resolved according to UN resolutions. The resolutions give the Kashmiris the right to self-determination. It is for the Kashmiris to decide if they want to be part of Pakistan or form an independent state. On the other hand, India claims Kashmir to be its integral part. Both the countries are signatories of the UN resolutions on Kashmir. Therefore when Pakistan raises the voice that Kashmir banaiga Pakistan, it negates its stance on the UN resolution. When India draws claim at Kashmir unilaterally, it too backtracks on its commitment to the UN resolution of granting the Kashmiris the right to self–determination. The only domain where Pakistan can raise voice about India’s atrocities on Kashmiris is in galvanising the international community towards the issue.

Islamabad's flawed foreign policy delaying held Kashmir's resolution: PPP

It is this faceless protest by both India and Pakistan that has emboldened the new and young leadership to realign the Kashmir cause. The pattern, in which the separatist movement is going forward it would be the creation of a Greater Kashmir with Gilgit-Baltistan and the Pakistani part of Kashmir as a part of it. The willingness of the Kashmiris to face the State’s aggression in the aftermath of Burhan Wani’s assassination is a reminder that India’s occupation of Kashmir is unacceptable to its inhabitants.  Putting huge forces with the arbitrary power to quash nationalist cum separatist sentiments has only fuelled aggression against Indian policies on Kashmir. The seed of hatred against Indian prosecution of the Kashmiris has its saplings sprouted all over India. In the new awakening marking Indian political landscape, there is a strong suggestion of finding a political solution to the Kashmir issue.  In the leading Indian cities, protests were held to persuade India to disembark from its headstrong attitude towards Kashmir where human rights are being violated without restraint. Every pellet that blinds a Kashmiri sharpens his vision to get Kashmir back from the clutches of its artificial rulers. It is flawed to think that, a movement can be suppressed by rendering the fighters, incapacitated.  It would only invigorate the sentiments. India needs to understand that today’s Kashmir is not being dictated by cross-border interventions.  It is not terrorism per se, of which it is trying to find a solution from the Pakistan government. With the violation of human rights, including rape, assassination, abduction, mass killing, extended curfews, India is only painting itself a shame to democracy.

The role of international community in identifying the rights of the Kashmiris has been pitiable.  In a travesty of truth, the international community dominated by the west has always turned a blind eye to violations that do not carry benefit to its interests. Gaza has borne Israel’s worst hatred in the midst of west’s criminal silent. Why should it take Pakistan to present dossier after dossier to the UN to expose India’s wrath against the Kashmiris? It is surprising that a single incident of discrimination against any minority or perhaps a woman in Pakistan would attract the attention of international NGO’s, but pellet bullets and indiscriminate harassment of the Kashmiris do not create the kind of noise that would squirm India out of its shallow self.

The Kashmir issue has proven that Pakistan and India refuse to learn from history

Is it difficult to find a solution to Kashmir’s growing unrest?  The valley can be calmed down if the rights of the Kashmiris are restored. First by pulling the military’s heavy contingent out and then by restoring the political legitimacy of the heirs of Kashmir politics. The first insurgency beginning in 1987 was the result of the brazen rigging that deprived the Hizbul Mujahedin its political role.
India needs to come out of the terrorism syndrome.  Having become a household name after 9/11, India has used terrorism as a veil to camouflage the struggle of the Kashmiris.  The portrayal of Kashmir situation as an act of terrorism instigated by Pakistan has plunged Kashmir deeper into human rights violation. Such optics will only breed militancy, which would be impossible for India to curtail in a few years. And eventually, Kashmir’s unrest would come handy for the western powers to encircle China.

Any mishap and the reason to bring UN-sponsored boots to the state could become plausible. The Pakistan-China Economic Corridor’s success also depends on how the situation in Kashmir is handled. The changing dynamic of the region with economic collaborations and media blitz taking the lead in forming public opinion, it would be difficult to suppress Kashmiris with violent state policies. India’s claim on Kashmir is a veneer that will not last much longer!

Published in The Express Tribune, October 10th, 2016.

Like Opinion & Editorial on Facebook, follow @ETOpEd on Twitter to receive all updates on all our daily pieces.


Amin Budh | 4 years ago | Reply The writer tries to be unnecessarily impartial when he says that both Pakistan and India negate their own stances. Wrong..! When Pakistan says Kashmir bagena Pakistan then this is people of Pakistan saying it. Officially, Pakistan has always demanded for resolution of the issue in the light of UN mandate. On the contrary, when India says that it is their integral part, it is her minister of foreign affairs speaking in UN. This is negation, rather a height of absurdness and preposterousness; having signed a number of treaties (including Shimla and Lahore) and also being the one who approached UNO for Kashmir resolution, India should be ashamed of itself for being a liar and showing total disregard for international norms, values and human rights and its own word.
Zee | 4 years ago | Reply So many factual errors in the article...The UN Resolution doesn't give Kashmiris the option of independence...according to UN Resolutions Kashmir had to either choose between accession to India or Pakistan...
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read