End the army operation in Fata

Ayaz Wazir May 09, 2010

Deprived of their basic human rights, the people of Fata have suffered for a long time and continue to be punished for sins they have not committed. The semi-independent status of the area ended with the events of 9/11. The army was deployed without consulting the tribesmen and in total disregard of the commitment of the Quaid which he had made in his address to them in Peshawar. Today, Fata which presents a grim look and has become more destitute than it was before. Every corner in every street and village bears the brunt of the operations which has brought barely any change in the safety and security dynamics for which the troops were deployed — except for clearing, albeit temporarily, some areas and denial of training camps to unwanted elements.

Those associated closely with the army, in one form or the other; support its deployment and subsequent operations in the area on flimsy grounds. One such argument that I heard was that the tribesmen not only welcomed deployment of the army but garlanded its officers upon arrival in the areas. What a naive way of looking at things indeed. They forget that in the past the colonial masters who entered the area bearing cannons were also greeted and garlanded on arrival. But what happened thereafter? Did that prevent the tribesmen from firing upon them in the dead of the night? Did that subjugate the tribesmen? Did the roads, bridges, hospitals and schools that they built change the hatred of the people for them? If not, then let us look afresh at the situation and take steps which can reverse the tide.

Let us examine the nine years of war to assess as to whether it has made the lot of the common man better or not. Everybody acknowledges that life in Fata was much better before the war on terror than it is today. It has made things difficult on all counts. The area has been turned into a war zone where death and destruction is everywhere.

The entire infrastructure for sustaining life including supply of daily provisions and communications is in shambles. Even the civil armed forces which used to mingle and interact freely with the people cannot do so anymore. The army was deployed in Fata mainly to stop infiltration of militants from across the western border. In the process it got entangled with its own people.

Another group associated with the political agent system in Fata views return of peace through revival/strengthening of that system. It’s yet another naïve way of looking at the problem. They easily forget the role played by that system in keeping Fata totally isolated from the rest of the country. We hardly see any civil servant leave a significant impact by undertaking projects of public interest. All of them had their own personal interests which they have looked after very well.The people of Fata have lived under the political agent system for more than a century and the army for almost a decade now. They are not happy with either since neither has done anything for their welfare.

The government needs to set its house in order and take charge of affairs in Fata. The army is neither trained nor has the capacity or acumen to bring in political and economic reforms. It should go back to the barracks and leave the matter to the civil government to interact with people, restore their confidence and undertake developmental projects in the area at lightning speed. Short of this nothing will restore trust and confidence of the tribesmen in the government which is handling the situation through remote control from Peshawar/Islamabad.


Jamil | 13 years ago | Reply @ Bangansh If you think the army has cleasned Bajaur, South Waziristan, Swat and Buner from the Taliban then you are really living in a fool's paradise. You need to visit the areas and see for yourself as to who has cleansed whom. These areas were never controlled and ruled by the Taliban. The control and rule of the area has always been that of the government though its authority was dented by the Taliban particularly in Swat which is not a tribal area and where all the government's machinery was there to have reacted in time. As far as bajaur and South waziristan are concerned, the control of the government has always been there and even more stronger than in the settled areas. The army moved into the tribal area much before the beginning of the targeted killing of the local notables. Why didn't the army react to have saved those innocent souls and also prevented the Taliban's influence in the area? The locals in Bajaur and South Waziristan have given the ultimate sacrifice of vacating their homes for the army to operate freely and eliminate militancy from that area. But when we look back we see no changes for the better, rather things have gone worse and the displaced people reluctant to return.
Bangash | 13 years ago | Reply @Jamil The army has indeed cleansed Bajaur, South Waziristan, Swat and Buner from the Taliban savages. No longer are these areas controlled and ruled by the Taliban. However given the stubborn nature of Taliban, we will continue to see attacks by small scale teams. The effort against Taliban needs to continue. Mr Wazir and all others are silent when the Taliban seize FATA and Swat by force and establish their rule in these places, but start screaming when Pakistan Army enters the areas to re-establish government control.
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ