Obama delivers harsh message on Polish democracy during NATO summit

President Duda did not respond to Obama's criticism, and Polish officials later sought to play down the comments

Reuters July 11, 2016
President Barack Obama listens as Polish President Andrzej Duda makes a statement following their meeting at PGE National Stadium in Warsaw, Poland on July 8. Obama slammed Polish democracy but viewers of Poland's main evening news program saw exactly the opposite. PHOTO: AP


US President Barack Obama expressed concern on Friday over Poland's moves to shackle its constitutional court, in unusually blunt comments calling on the former communist EU country's government to do more to protect democracy.

Speaking alongside President Andrzej Duda after they met at a NATO summit in Warsaw, Obama said the ruling conservatives had taken some steps to address US and European concerns but more should be done. Duda did not respond, and Polish officials later sought to play down the comments.

NATO allies commit around $1 billion per year to support Afghan forces

"I expressed to President Duda our concerns over certain actions, and the impasse over Poland's constitutional tribunal," Obama told reporters.

"I insisted that we are very respectful of Poland's sovereignty and I recognize that parliament is working on legislation to take some important steps, but more work needs to be done," the US leader said.

Obama's criticism follows an unprecedented decision by the European Commission earlier this year to open an investigation into whether government policies threaten the rule of law. The EU probe, which can ultimately lead to the suspension of a member state's voting rights, is still open.

Critics say the government's changes to the constitutional tribunal undermine democratic standards and are part of a broader push to seize more control over state institutions, charges the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party denies.

Obama warns against 'adversarial' Brexit negotiations

Duda's spokesman Marek Magierowski belittled Obama's criticism.

"President Obama made his statement, president Duda made his," Magierowski told reporters. "It's difficult to force president Obama to say what this or that politician in Poland would like him to say. I don't see a problem here."


The eurosceptic PiS rushed through parliament an amended version of the reforms on Thursday, in an apparent effort to reassure its western allies over the issue. But opposition critics said the change fell short of what was needed to preserve democratic checks and balances.

The government, which has also come under criticism over rules allowing for more state surveillance and public media reforms, argues it is only trying to make the constitutional court more effective and transparent.

Speaking to reporters with Duda at his side, Obama said an independent judiciary was the backbone of democracy.

"As your friend and ally we urged all parties to work together to sustain Poland's democratic institutions," he said.

"That's what makes us democracies, not just ... the fact that we vote in elections, but the institutions we depend on every day such as rule of law, independent judiciaries."

Obama condemns 'calculated and despicable' Dallas attack

A Polish government spokesman, asked about Obama's criticism, said legislative changes to the court rules were still being finalised.

"The parliamentary majority is trying to finalize the conflict, presenting compromise proposal," Rafal Bochenek said.

PiS won a landslide election last October, unseating long-ruling centrists on a promise of more economic fairness and national pride. Its popularity remains strong, driven by increased welfare spending, but its efforts to exert control on state institutions have deeply polarized the Polish society.


Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ


Most Read